PJ,

So no one, at least not the usual suspects, has shown you some echeveria names for this plant. I don't know what it is, but I suspect that there's a crested form that is readily available. You find that crest and I think that this will be your plant, but in a currently normal growth pattern (it shows potential for cresting, but that could be me trying to make waves).

I agree with cactusmcharris..

Is it a very small-leaved, small diameter (2" for the biggest rosettes) echeveria? Try E. minima; I picked up one from Lowe's that was labelled as such.