Haworthia Attenuata.

My opinion it's a bit off focus but looks good, you could wait for it to fill in more is an option even though I would remove one of the smaller

hmm, maybe H, limifolia.
picture is not very clear.
Leave it as it is, I should say. Don't repot in wintertime, but wait till spring.
greets
Harry

So the soil mix was really wet when I got it. Is it supposed to dry out between waterings?

Now it looks like it could be a form of Haworthia coarctata⦠either way, looks fine for now.

I would let it dry out or get close to drying out. It is a succulent.

Yes, I go for coarctata too.
harry