Pet damage, or a slug/snail, is my guess. A weevil would usually go to the core. I can't suggest anything until we know for sure, but when you're repotting you can do a thorough inspection of the undersides of the leaves, where the critter may be hanging out.

Expecting jade but got agave...Nice plant, though!

Christopher.

Cactusmcharris, thanks so much! It may be a slug/snail because I had it outside before taking it in. The problem started outside.

Kaktuskris, I just noticed that, oops! Thanks

'White cracked hole and scratches'

Now most forums wouldn't discuss homemade sugar donuts with claws, but we have a full-service one here, just blessed with it, I think.

I wouldnt be too concerned, it may not even be from a creature, though it does look suspiciously like it. It could have been anything that poked a hole thru the leaf, the generally make spots like that to seal off the wound.

I see spots like this on agaves alot around here, its often from a pup growing too large and stabbing its terminal spine thru a mature leaf.