Return to the California Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Cherry trees

Posted by patty4150 SoCal (My Page) on
Sun, Apr 2, 06 at 15:52

Anyone in So Cal have luck with (fruiting) Cherry trees? I know they need chill, but a few success stories might push us towards trying them. Or failed attempts would be nice to know about too. We live in Thousand Oaks, so have some small coastal influence (cooler than the inland areas) and a few frosty nights every year.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Cherry trees

There in Thousand Oaks you are not even close to getting the required 600 to 800 chill hours needed to produce a good crop of sweet cherries.

My only suggestion would be to buy some dwarf cherry trees and grow them in large pots. Then every September bring them up to your friend's house in Big Bear in your pick-up truck. (No friends there? Make some!) Let the trees spend the winter up there and then in April go get them. You'll have lots of delicious cherries this way!


 o
RE: Cherry trees

I've been trying to locate sources of new cherries from Zaiger Genetics, DWN doesn't have them in stock at the moment:

Minnie Royal
Patent #Pending. Ripens 2nd week of May. Sweet, dark red flesh. Used as pollenizer for Royal Lee. 400 hours

Royal Lee
Patent #Pending. Ripens 2nd week of May, about 14 days ahead of Bing. Dark red & sweet. very firm, good size and color. 400 hours.

I've also heard that some CRFG growers in SoCal are able to produce cherries from Royal Rainier. Mature trees of Royal Rainier produce fruit even in years when there are just about 450 chilling hours.


 o
RE: Cherry trees

I live in Granada Hills and I planted Lapins and Royal Rainier last year as an experiment after reading on the Laguna Nursery website that Lapins fruited in parts of OC. The supplier said that if Lapins fruited, there would be no problem with Royal Rainier.... Granada Hills must have more chill hours than TO however.
Joereal, those cherry cvs you listed sound tempting. Perhaps there are cherries in more people's futures (and gardens) when those get released, if they can get past the common thinking that cherries won't grow here (and keep the squirrels away).


 o
RE: Cherry trees

Greenwich, did any of the trees flower this year? I got a 3-1 and Stella on it came ready to bloom a bit. Bing and raineer had no blossoms this year(not as precocious). You do have more chill then T.O. being in sunset 19, they are 20 or 21.


 o
RE: Cherry trees

One thing that we should never forget is the type of rootstock those cherries came with. The most common mistakes made by a LOT of nursery suppliers is NOT disclosing the behavior and buyers NOT knowing the behavior of the cherry tree when grafted to particular rootstocks. For example, if cherries are grafted unto Mahaleb, it would take between 7-10 years for the cherry to come into production, and especially longer in Southern California. You end up with a giant cherry tree after the 4th year and have concluded incorrectly that you don't have enough chilling hours and so would want to dispose of the tree.

I strongly suggest that homeowners buy cherry cultivars on Gisela series of rootstock, especially Gisela 5 (ultra-dwarf). The cherries come into production only after a couple of years, sometimes they flower on the season that you bought and plant them. If the cherries on ultra-dwarf didn't bloom after three years, then you can safely say that you didn't have enough chilling hours, and simply graft more appropriate varieties over them.


 o
RE: Cherry trees

Bob Vieth, CRFG member and Thousand Oaks resident, says:

"I have had luck with Black Republican, Black Tartarian, Early Ruby, Van, Lapins, Governor Wood, Brooks, Park Hill, Corum, one strain of Rainier (I know of 3[;the others not successful]). All presently are grafted on Early Ruby."

Joe


 o
RE: Cherry trees

It's been five years, but I'm pretty sure mine is lapin. In years of heavy rainfall (last year) I had enough to keep me happy. Nothing on my tree -- including blooms -- this year.


 o
RE: Cherry trees

Where can one find Minnie Royal or Royal Lee cherry trees? I live in northern Santa Barbara county and have always dreamed of having sweet cherry trees around. I love the idea of cherry trees that only need ~400 chill hours.

Thanks in advance -

Joe.


 o
RE: Cherry trees

  • Posted by socal23 USDA10/Sunset23 (My Page) on
    Thu, Aug 3, 06 at 10:13

Something to keep in mind about Thousand Oaks is the effect of topography. The area near the 101 freeway (Santa Monica Mountain foothills) is a lot warmer than most of the city. My parent's house in Thousand oaks (near Plantas and Arboles) is in a cold-air drainage, they get killing frosts every winter and a considerable amount of chill.

Ryan


 o
RE: Cherry trees

I found Bay Laurel Nursery is taking orders for 2008 for Minnie Royal and Royal Lee.
My cherries are not on Mahaleb or Mazzard. I can't remember what they are on, could be G61/1?? I planted Lapins in fall 2005 and Royal Rainier in winter 2006. No blooms yet, Lapins is around 7 or 8 feet tall already, I will start chopping next year now that the roots are established. It has plenty of competition as I have a small yard and all is planted chock-a -block so that should keep it in check a tad.


 o
RE: Cherry trees

My tree is on colt, which is as widely used as the two mentioned. I couldnt find a gisela :(. My tree had severe leaf spot. My copper spray was not cutting it, so I bought some daconil.


 o
RE: Cherry trees

Wow such talk of cherries. I usually get all of my cherries up by Palmdale at a U pick place. I always get an e mail from him. It's at www.gatherafruitfulharvest.com

I hope this helps everyone out. I love cherries can't wait till summer.

Bucky


 o
RE: Cherry trees

If you can't find the Gisela series of rootstock, buy the Ultra-dwarf cherries from Home Depot and graft unto them. I believe they are Gisela. There are two types of ultra-dwarf cherries from HD. Self fertile Bing and Stella.

I have some nice cherries harvested last year from my ultra-dwarf Bing bought from home depot and I planted those cherries in 15 gallon pots, and now I have grafted about 5 other kinds of cherries unto it, doesn't seem to affect it. The grafts last year are now swollen with flower buds, and still it is in the same pot.


 o
Tree height

Indeed, you can keep them ultra-dwarf. They are only 5 ft tall and the pot is about 18" tall. So the cherries last year were literally within reach of my teenagers. I can't believe the very cheapo Ultra-dwarf cherries from Home Depot can bear fruits while potted!


 o
RE: Cherry trees

That's a good idea,

Bucky


 o
RE: Cherry trees

I laughed when I read this post, not at you, but because here in the Central Valley we are all wishing beyond hope that we can grow guavas, mangos, macadamias, etc., and down south you guys want the cherries! We have plenty of those and peaches too.


 o
RE: Cherry trees

Here's even a cheaper source of dwarfing rootstocks for cherries:

Krymsk 5 Cherry rtstk
Dwarfing Cherry Rootstock (PAF)(TM) A hybrid of P. fruiticosa x lannesiana. Similiar in size to Gisela 5. Trees can be maintained at 10'. Non suckering, precocious and compatible with all cherries. Developed by Russian breeder Gennady Eremin at the Krymsk Vavilov Institute. Royalties go to support his program. This rootstock is patented and may not to be reproduced without permission of the patent holder.

$3.75 each, $3.25 each for 5, and it can go down to $1.85 each depending on quantity.

I am planning to buy many of these rootstocks and transfer over my cherry cultivars unto them and then replace the existing cherry trees in my yard. Will just plan to keep them up to 10 feet high. Will try them on few cultivars first, and if they did okay, the existing cherry trees will have to go.

Here is a link that might be useful: Krymsk 5 Cherry rootstock


 o
RE: Cherry trees

Thanks joereal - now if we can only get ahold of some Minnie Royal and Royal Lee...oops they're patented! just wishful thinking.


 o
RE: Cherry trees

Greenwitch, I wish there were a royalty based program for us hobbyists. I will buy a budwood including royalty fees, and not reproduce the patented trees, it only stays in my property. I would love to pay the patent holders their due fee, which usually are minimal. Charges ranges from $0.65 to $1.65 per tree, based on what I see gets charged over by some bare-root suppliers. We are a niche market though, the enforcement is horrendous to have a profitable payback, but can be done profitably with an honesty system. More than 96% of people are honest, based on experiences with financial transactions.


 o
RE: Cherry trees

The fact is that the patent threat is not the home gardener but countries that have declared themselves unprosecutable under internation patent agreements. As such these countries have used more clever ways to try to access budwood for new varieties. It is a wonder that the patent holders would release any new variety to the public without first getting there money from a commercial release, condsidering how much they put out to protect themselves from this ever exsisting problem. There is no comparison between finanical transaction and patent infringment. There is no security when you place your money open to anyone on the street.

On a different note all the rootstocks offered as Ultra
dwarf are all typical rootstocks offered by all growers in the trade. None are unique,just great marketing!!
Check out their site

Here is a link that might be useful: Pacific Grove nursery


 o
RE: Cherry trees

Edlo, certainly you can qualify for me as to what you meant by typical. For one there are several scientific publications that I have come across, quantifying the performances of various cherry rootstocks such as the Gisela series and the Krmysk series. If you meant that being the typical is that all growers have access to any of these and none has an advantage over another, but I have a counter-example to this. It seems that there is a large gap as to what western growers and eastern growers do with the peach rootstocks. I have been trying for more than a year in trying to obtain the Peach Guardian Rootstock which is reportedly far superior than those rootstocks used in California in most of the Gulf states. None of our California or western nurseries are offering this rootstock, and this is a USDA sponsored rootstock. Why are we not using this or have tried using this? I may not know the answer and wouldn't want to speculate.

One thing is that most of my trees on lovell rootstocks are now dead, and would want to try a different one. I have nemaguard type rootstocks but trees are poor performers and wanted to try something out of the box called California.

Have you tried evaluating the Peach Guardian Rootstocks? It certainly is not available to some growers or intentionally all western growers seem not to use them. I may be a fool trying these gulf rootstocks out, but I only have a few $ to lose on these so am willing to try and get them legally into California.

Any insights would be appreciated.


 o
RE: Cherry trees

  • Posted by edlo z9/CA (My Page) on
    Thu, Feb 15, 07 at 9:10

Typical means that all the major growers are currently using these rootstocks. GM61 a typical rootstock in the trade that dwarfs to 65% of standard(25 feet +) is the rootstock used for your Ultra Dwarf Cherry. In tests that I have done through the years on container rootstocks I have tested GM61. It performs well for about 4 years then needs to be rootpruned and repotted to keep it going. This prosess sets the fruiting back a season while the tree gets reestablished. I have had better results with the Gisela 5 and would recommend it for home gardeners wanting to do cherrys in containers. The reason Gisela 5 is hard to find is that it has been dissapointing as a commercial rootstock and too expensive for most growers to offer to the public. As far as Krmysk it is too new and has little grower feed back in the states. Though it sounds good now it will be years before growers results recommend it for the home garden. There have been many introductions through the years that have gone no where once they get into production. The industry is not against good results but the industry does not often act on a whim. It is far too expensive. As for Guardian it is in trials and is showing poorly in all but heavy saline/sodic soils(soils with high salts)Texas has been positive on this rootstock I believe. Though a problem in a few areas on the west coast it is not a typical problem and as such expensive for growers to produce just for a few areas.


 o
RE: Cherry trees

Ed, thank you so much for the very USEFUL information. These are hard to come by. Truly appreciated your response!

Joe


 o
RE: Cherry trees

I bought two ultra dwarfs last year. A Self Fertile Bing and a Stella. Both are in 7 gallon containers on my patio. They both have blooms all over them this year.

I live in San Diego so they would probably bloom anywhere in CA (although it was a very cold winter this year).

There is a big nursery down here called Evergreen Nursery (the north county location) and they have had a lot of these ultra dwarf cherry trees the past few years.


 o
RE: Cherry trees

I'm located in the desert, 29 Palms and want to get a Self Fertile Bing. Any suggestions on how or where I can buy one? I'm also looking for a dwarf Braeburn Apple and a good dwarf plum.


 o
RE: Cherry trees

At our farm, we plant only cherries on z-stem (from Dave Wilson Nursery). Bakersfield, California area growers say this has solved the "low-winter-chill" problem. I've linked to an article that talks about it.

Here is a link that might be useful: Z stem article


 o
RE: Cherry trees

  • Posted by hoovb z9 Southern CA (My Page) on
    Fri, Dec 14, 07 at 19:05

terencewel, thank you for that link. So what's an interstem? The rootstock is 1 variety, the trunk is Z stem, and the leafing/fruiting top is yet another?

Still, there just ain't any chill here. Guess I'll have to stick to mangos. :(


 o
RE: Cherry trees

I have one of those Ultra Dwarf cherry trees from Home Depot purchased a few years back. If I plant it in the ground, will it grow taller than 5' to 6'?


 o
RE: Cherry trees

  • Posted by jim123 z9 or z10 CA (My Page) on
    Sun, Apr 19, 09 at 3:10

Since this thread was started two or three years ago and I have not read every post, forgive me if this was already posted.

Two low chill cherries have been introduced in the past two or three years. They are from Dave Wilson Nurseries and are from Floyd Zaiger Genetics.

They are called Royal Lee and Mini Royal. Royal Lee provides larger fruit that is rated as excellent and Mini Royal is its pollenizer. Mini Royal's fruit is reported to be very good, but is smaller but very abundant.

Zaiger Genetics also developed an exceptional dwarfing rootstock for most stone fruits (not cherries) called Citation. It has proven to do well in many soils as well as encourage younger bearing. The Z stem mentioned by another poster is another Zaiger introduction. It permits cherries to be grafted to non cherry stone fruit rootstocks.

I wish I could tell you more about them, but that will need to wait until my newly planted trees have a chance to grow. They have only been in the ground about two and a half months. They look really healthy.

When released, they were reported to need about 500 hours of winter chill. More recent estimates puts it closer to 300 hours.


 o
RE: Cherry trees

My folks grow cherry trees in Southern California, zone 22 also, but a half hour from me.

About 8 years ago they planted Stella and Lapins based on a few reports of local success at the time. Both have thrived when it comes to leaves, vigorous growth, and have made nice shade trees. HOWEVER, the two tress have never gotten a heavy crop of fruit, despite having flowers. The most they have ever picked is a dozen or so in a year. I have suggested they start over with Minnie Royal and Royal Lee cherries.

My neighbor across the street has these two cherry trees, Minnie Royal and Royal Lee cherry, which are now over 3 years old. They have done well, flower, and set fruit here in zone 9b/10 or Sunset 22 of Southern California.

There are pictures of her trees on my blog with a brief description:


 o
RE: Cherry trees

It amazes me how well cherries do in this location, near the Cajon Pass in Oak Hills, at about 3700 feet elevation. Apple trees do well too. Apparently, there is just the right amount of chilling hours, and for two years running, my trees have been loaded. Bing and Ranier cherries...more than I could eat or even give away.


 o
RE: Cherry trees

Ultra dwarf Bing cherry tree from Costco produced fruit in Orange County. What I did was put it in a 15 gallon pot, then place on the north side of my house November 1st and very little water to induce dormancy. Then bring it in the full sun mid February. It took a couple years but got a couple dozen fruit ripening right now. Lot of hassle for a little bit of fruit, but I wanted to see if it would work. Much better results from Minnie Royal and Royal Lee planted in the ground, and just as tasty.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the California Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here