Return to the Canna Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Canna Flame seeds for trade!!!!

Posted by siam_cannas (My Page) on
Sun, Feb 22, 09 at 18:11

Hey everyone,

I picked my first pod of Canna Flame seeds. I only have enough to trade with a few people right now, but I will have more soon, ( pods on the cannas are ripening).
Canna flame is a medium height canna with large yellow flowers spotted red. It grows true from seeds. It was entered in to the canna internation trial in the Uk last year. I got seeds from my friend Keith Hayward of Hart canna.

Here is a picture of it.

canna flame

If you are interested in trading canna seeds please e-mail me touchmybody19@yahoo.com

Thanks,
Siam


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Canna Flame seeds for trade!!!!

Siam,
I have enjoyed your past post here, but regrettable suggest you double check your seedling of C. Flame which was grown in the canna trials in the UK. You will find that C. Flame is a garden hybrid that does NOT breed true or produce offspring true to type. This seedling is not C. Flame and should not be referred to as such. It is only a seedling of that cultivar. I am sorry to point this out.
Regards, Kent


 o
RE: Canna Flame seeds for trade!!!!

Hello kent,
I have to call someone in the UK tomorrow and i will let you know.
Its interesting how you say that you have enjoyed my posts, yet you have never commented on any even when i asked for other member's opinions.

Siam.


 o
Kent, do you have canna virus?

Hello kent,
I have heard that you have and sell cannas infected with CANNA VIRUS. Is that true? Most canna producers/ hybridizers have canna virus.


 o
RE: Canna Flame seeds for trade!!!!

Siam,
Following your last post, you apparently have another agenda. No question that in the past; all growers have dealt with canna virus along with a multitude of other issues. If you bothered to completely read my old profile you would have seen that I retired from the commercial business over 6 years ago and simply continue to grow a few cannas and occasionally post comments relative to the importance of an issue; I consider important. In your post you mistakenly suggested that your seedling was true to type. This is NEVER the case in typical canna hybrids. Knowledgeable professionals already know this. The canna world is full of misnamed cultivars resulting from this. In some cases it is simply an honest mistake or lack of knowledge and occasionally the individual has other motives.
We all await your phone call inquiry and just for the record, I made the call before my post!
Regards, Kent


 o
RE: Canna Flame seeds for trade!!!!

Siam,

Dude, I was just starting to warm up to you. Attacks like yours show a smallness of mind and unwillingness to learn.

I will have no further contact with you.


 o
RE: Canna Flame seeds for trade!!!!

Hello Kent.
You have accused me of having another agenda. I don't! However, I could say that you have another agenda also and that maybe you dont want me to trade those seeds.
In addition, why are you awaiting my response? You already made the phone call and have the answers, or else you would not have posted. I made the phone call and I dont have the answers!
Furthermore, no one had the exact information until a few days ago when you saw the picture i posted and then proceeded to make your inquiries. And still there is alot to be questioned.

And Fatbaldguy, your jumping to conclusions and assuming that I am attacking Kent. For you information, I was not. Just inquiring. (You have stated you dont want to have contact with me therefore you should not reply). I am simply clearing up your misconception.

Siam


 o
RE: Canna Flame seeds for trade!!!!

hi, i sure would like canna seedpods from you. i have blue jap mg seeds to trade.


 o
RE: Canna Flame seeds for trade!!!!

Siam,
Kent was trying to help you to explain something important.
I do not see he has an agenda. You might apologize to him as what you said is harsh and untrue. Kent helped me in my early days of growing, and I am ever grateful to him. Do not burn bridges with someone from whom you can learn a lot. And I hate to see people 'fall out' over a misunderstanding.

As for seeds of hybrid cannas, as Kent is explaining, they do not grow seedlings true to their parents. It is ok to say that 'Flame' is the pod parent the seeds came from, but also state that any seedlings will not be the parent or called 'Flame', as they will be new hybrids.

I don't know which 'Flame' Keith sent these seeds, but if it is from Chiltern's .. which I thought it was .. this seedling is not that as it has a small orange flower and this seedling does not. An example of how names get confused.

Good to see you all here :-)
Alice


 o
RE: Canna Flame seeds for trade!!!!

Hello Alice,
Just as the Tropical Series grows true from seeds, I was told that canna Flame grows true from seeds. I know the difference between growing true from seeds and hybrid seeds from a pod parent. I dont think I need to apologize to anyone. Kent told me exactly what he wanted to say and as he wanted to say it and I told him back exactly what I thought.

Siam.


 o
RE: Canna Flame seeds for trade!!!!

OK, but that 'Flame' is not the true from seed that it is supposed to be. And I do not believe Kent should have been a victim for his input. But ok. We are all entitled to our opinions, as you are to your's, also. And I will not say more.
All best to you :-)
Alice


 o
RE: Canna Flame seeds for trade!!!!

Thanks for your help and the information Alice. It was appreciated. I will think about what you said.
I had reasons for the things I said. This is the end of my posting on this topic also. Its not going anywhere. You are right, we all have different takes on the issue. Whether i am wrong or not, I will know in time ( I have some experimenting to do). I wont be responding to any more posts on this issue.

Siam


 o
RE: Canna Flame seeds for trade!!!!

Thanks for the effort Alice!
For anyone interested in seeing the true C. Flame, they can view it at the link provided;
http://www.clainescanna.co.uk/Trial2008/album.html
You will need to open the file in the upper left corner labeled "Trial Photographs". There are at least 4 photos of Flame. As you can see, there is absolute no similarity to the seedling shown in this post. This is the typical result of growing any hybrid canna seed.
Attached is a partial copy of the email I received from Keith Hayward who conducted the trials.
"Kent; Siam's picture on Garden Web shows that Flame doesn't come true from seed.
I sent him seed collected from my Flame, which is mostly red/orange blotches with yellow edges to the petal."

Regards,
Kent


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Canna Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here