Return to the Canna Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
what happened to the stripes?

Posted by BedofCannas Delaware (My Page) on
Thu, May 16, 13 at 21:48

I have Cannas, Tropicanna and unknown named variety(red). I conquered leaf roll last year. (The first year I ever saw it). This year, the Tropicannas' are coming up and there are no stripes on the leaves. Any suggestions of what happened?
Photo is of last year, August, I believe.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

I cannot offer a reason for your cannas loss of stripes because the photo image does not allow me to have a close detailed view. We need to confirm which cultivar you grew because I am certain that you are not growing C. Tropicanna. You MAY be growing C. Tropicanna Gold which does have green variegated leaves; but the bloom color seems to be a bit wrong. You can do a search for both mentioned cultivars above to compare to what you are/were growing.
Just for the sake of clarification, do you have other photos from last year or can you attach a photo of what you have growing now. Did you replant this year’s rhizomes from stock grown last year? How were they protected over the winter? What was the source of your cannas?
For the record; your tall red bloom/green leaf cultivar may be C. Robert Kemp.
Kent
Photo: Tropicanna Gold:


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

Please excuse my mistake . You are right they are, "Tropicanna Gold". I bought (2) in a pot at Lowes. The other cannas I grow are "The President". At Least that's what the tags said when I bought them. (still have tags) I have to look through my DVDs. I do not keep the photos on my laptop, but I will look for them. I did replant this years growth from last years stock. I overwintered them in my cool basement in paper bags and misted them every so often. Never had a problem with them for several years until now. Will post when I find the up close photos.. Thank you!


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

I found last summers photos.


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

Here is the Tropicanna Gold at present.


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

You definitely grew C. Tropicanna Gold and that is a great photo of the bloom. I rather thought you meant to say Tropicanna Gold but wanted to at least clarify the correct name for the benefit of any visitor to this post that might be misled. Also, there are occasions where a seller mislabels their plants or rhizomes and I wanted to be sure I was responding to a specific and unique form of canna.
For the benefit of any who are not aware, both Tropicanna and Tropicanna Gold are considered to be stable chimeras (periclinal chimera plants). This typically infers that these plants contain two or more genetically distinct types of cells due to a mutation located on the apical meristem. With the stable periclinal chimera these growing points tend to be fixed and not change. Canna cultivars such as Tropicanna, Tropicanna Gold, and Pink Sunburst etc. produce stable plants with variegated leaves.
I have seen a few of these stable chimeras loose variegation on rare occasions but never more than one or two out of a few hundred. This occurred very early in the season and usually by the second or third leaf the variegation became normal. The only other time leaf variegation was lost was because of viral infection and that was only intermittent on the leaf. At this time I doubt anyone can give you a definitive answer but I hope you would consider posting photos later of your cannas so we can see what has transpired.
Glad you found the label for your President and would also like to see a photo of them when available.
Kent


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

Man, I wish there was someone on this forum who actually knew what they were talking about. =P

Kent, you're awesome.


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

Kent , thank you so much for your help. You obviously have an extensive knowledge of these gorgeous plants. That being said, when I signed up for this forum I never stated I was much more than an amateur at growing the Cannas mentioned. My ignorance of some ,never experienced, issues of this plant does not warrant a rude response from other members. I am here for answers and help.


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

Mike, LOL!

Bed, you missed the twinkle-in-the-eye. Mike was addressing his comment to Kent and, I assure you, Mike has never been rude to anyone. He is one of the nicest guys on the forum. We all wish you luck on your cannas and believe me, I think we are ALL learning from Kent. What a wealth of knowledge. Welcome to the forum! It is nice to have new posters! :)

Carol in Jax

This post was edited by love_the_yard on Mon, May 20, 13 at 17:52


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

Bed, apologies if my post was misinterpreted. Like Carol said, I was totally kidding, and pretty much in awe of the kind of information Kent has and regularly provides others.

I mostly lurk on this forum, but Kent has been throwing knowledge at posters for quite awhile, from what I've seen. I just wanted to toss him a well-deserved compliment, not criticize someone seeking answers.

I was bowing before a god, not mocking the flock, promise.

Carol, thanks for the defense =)


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

Carol and Mike,
Being new here and not knowing anyone, Mike's comment took me by surprise. I took it the wrong way, for which I sincerely apologise to Mike. Thank you Carol for telling me about the twinkle, (lol) and the welcome! Much appreciated. I do love this site. I've learned a lot in a few days. All is good.
Lin


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

No apologies necessary Lin. We would all benefit from a Rosetta Stone to parse the intent of random internet messages lol.

Depending on where you ask your questions (on other sites), you could get stuck with a "u got the wrong name. research next time" answer to your question instead of the encyclopedic recitation Kent was providing. Seeing someone share so much is inspiring, and in my opinion, worthy of a joke (Kent doesn't know anything).

Gardenweb has had dozens of amazing contributers, and I try to share my gratitude where I can, even if it doesn't necessarily benefit me directly.

So, you know Carol and me now. No more "I don't know anyone" excuses! =)

Out of curiosity, how'd you go about handling your leafrollers? By hand, or chemically? Them rollers have been feasting in my garden this year.


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

The good ole leaf rollers. I extracted them by use of a pair of hemostats (sp?) The surgical clamps. Or,as soon as I saw the moth I would net it if I could. So far so good this year. I did have a beetle eating on one leaf. I remember last year I moved praying mantis to my Cannas from my Arborvitaes. I can't use any chemicals, for anything. My black Lab is super sensitive to everything not natural. In addition we adopted a few feral cats. I don't want to make any of them sick.


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

For all of the posters to this thread;

After being on a number of forums over a period of years I believe that the way each contributor handled and addressed a misunderstanding is commendable. Lin, Carol and Mike demonstrated intelligence and etiquette in clarifying a reply. Unfortunately this is not true for some forums but because of really good members such as you I choose to lurk here with the rest.
Mike, I appreciated the recognition but please don’t build that pedestal too far off the ground; the fall might hurt Humpty Dumpty! Then again, maybe you were implying my replies are windy!

Have a good day,
Kent


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

A modest god? That's a first.

Actually Kent, you bring up something interesting. You are a little long-winded (hey Kettle, it's me, Pot!) in your responses, but that makes what you do all the better.

You treat every poster like they're a botanist with a long term investment in the forums. You don't dumb things down, instead, you generally provide enough information (both scientific and practical) in a single response to kill a topic all together, as likely follow-up questions are wrapped up in your explanations.

I've seen novel-length posts that would take a normal person hours to write go completely unacknowledged. It's a crying shame when it happens. Most amazing bit though? Even when there's no appreciation shown, posters such as yourself continue sharing, explaining, and giving 100%.

For that, I'm grateful. Keep it up!

But anyway, yeah, Cannas...they're pretty.


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

I love all you guys. What a great place! :)


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

The Tropicanna Gold pictured earlier appears to me to have virus.


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

Yes, I agree. If I had known then what I know now, I wouldn't have bought the Tropicanna Gold at Home Depot. Thanks for your response.


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

bedofcannas- did your striped cannas ever show up? Or is it still a mystery.....


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

Hi Kato_b,
It wasn't that they disappeared. The Tropicanna Gold came back without their stripes ,as I called them. I attached a few photos that I took today. This year this is what they did.


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

I am coming into this thread a little late. I gather the diagnosis was that there was a virus. What are the indicators that would suggest this? I have been growing and digging up the larger variety of canna for a long time and recently started trying to get Tropicanna Gold to play nice for me. I find the tubers are so small that they are difficult to get them to overwinter nicely.


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

Oh boy I am sorry (jonijumpup) I had not been on here for a while. I never saw your post til now. Yes it was a virus. None survived the overwinter. And whatever the virus on the tropicannas is on the red president now. I threw all but 8 away and I will post a pic over the weekend sometime. I can't move the planting site. So what's the answer to this dilemma. start over again? Any help will be appreciated.


 o
RE: what happened to the stripes?

I'm sorry you lost your plants ):


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Canna Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here