Return to the Citrus Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Are there citrus that does well on its own roots?

Posted by thisisme az9b (My Page) on
Sun, Jan 3, 10 at 20:36

I have a couple trees that really only do well when grafted to another rootstock. Are their any good fresh eating citrus varieties that grow well and healthy on their own roots that are easy to propagate?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Are there citrus that does well on its own roots?

Are you asking in reference to in-ground or containerized plants..?

Mike;-)


 o
RE: Are there citrus that does well on its own roots?

Hi Mike, in ground or in container just so long as you say which is which along with any specific planting requirements.


 o
RE: Are there citrus that does well on its own roots?

The reason why I ask is because I am familiar with growing in containers, and do not have enough authority or experience to be able to help you with in-ground. The only ones that I grow in my yard in the tropics are on their own roots, and some do great, others do not. My grapefruit and certain oranges do ok.. I never tried a citrus on different root stock in ground there.

There are some here who are pros, experts at it, a couple in particular who would be able to help you. I think of rhizzo right off the bat whom I miss around here, fruitnut, tsmith, and a few others! I think certain root stock is need to avoid nemetodes destruction and disease in ground? Some need to be hardy for in-ground if my memory from past posts is correct..

I would like to know too for plantings I would like to do when I head to the Carribeans for my yard.

As for pot culture, I grow both and both grow remarkable...I think this was brought up in a post once before too, and I can not remember..Sorry.

But through my experience, both grafted and those on their own roots are doing amazing!

Hope to see what someone has to say about in-ground...

Mike...:-)


 o
RE: Are there citrus that does well on its own roots?

Dr. Malcolm Manners coulod help you....but I know Meyer Lemons do great grown from their own seeds...and many types of grapefruits.


 o
RE: Are there citrus that does well on its own roots?

Wilmington, while it's true that 'Meyer' lemon seeds grow easily, they won't generally end up being 'Meyer', since it has a very low level of nucellar embryony -- nearly every seedling is sexually produced, and therefore genetically different from 'Meyer'. That's why it was so long before we had so-called 'Improved Meyer'; unlike so many other varieties that were easily rid of tristeza virus by just growing some seeds, 'Meyer' seedlings didn't come true to type.

And Mike, I suppose one always has to have some caveats with any recommendation. The reason for grafting onto a rootstock is that the rootstock gives you something you need or want, that the own-root plant would not.

So for example, sweet oranges on their own roots are tremendously cold-hardy and produce very high quality fruit. But their root systems are shallow, necessitating frequent irrigation, and they are (except for 'Valencia') highly susceptible to phytophthora foot rot.

Indeed, most varieties will be at least somewhat susceptible to foot rot, which is the major reason for the use of rootstocks in Florida and many other areas, where that disease is prevalent.

Grapefruit are ok on their own roots, but you can make a richer, sweeter flavored fruit with a rootstock. Also, they are not very cold-hardy on their own roots.

Some mandarins are good on their own roots. In Florida, 'Murcott' is sometimes grown that way, even from seed. With mandarins, the major reason for grafting is likely to improve fruit size and/or overall yield. 'Dancy' is notorious for making tiny fruit unless you graft it to a vigorous rootstock.


 o
RE: Are there citrus that does well on its own roots?

Malcolm_manners,

Thankyou for for sharing your expertise here, and in satisfying my curiousity about the same question..

Mike:-)


 o
RE: Are there citrus that does well on its own roots?

Dr. Manners:

So good to see/hear from you on here.....and ordinarily i would defer to the "Dr." BUT, I have grown several "true" meyer lemons from seed....and they bore in as little as four years...I will admit, however, that one of the meyer lemons turned out to be a true lemon of some sort with the classic lemon shape and nipple...it fruited at 4 years as well....and died at 26 degrees which the other young meyers shook off with ease. And grapefruit, at least in my are and points further north like Charleston, SC, seem to indeed have extra cold hardiness imparted to them....most of these trees have seen the upper teens. ANd I'd put my grapefruit up against just about anybody's for flavor....better than any in California, equal to Texas grown....but alas, inferior to Indian River as my rind is a wee bit thicker.


 o
RE: Are there citrus that does well on its own roots?

Wilmington, I'd not be surprised if 'Meyer' seedlings were quite similar to the parent, especially if self-pollinated. But they should virtually all (perhaps absolutely all??) be sexually produced, not nucellar in origin, so should have some genetic variation. Much like one sees among purebred dogs -- very similar, but not quite clones.


 o
RE: Are there citrus that does well on its own roots?

Improved Meyer Lemons are very easy to root cuttings, which of course would be a clone of the parent, and grow fine on their own roots in ground or in pots.

Key limes also grow well on their own roots, though I have only done so in pots.


 o
RE: Are there citrus that does well on its own roots?

Thank you everyone for your feedback.

john how do you root those cuttings?


 o
RE: Are there citrus that does well on its own roots?

I take about a 10 inch cutting, clip off all the leaves except for 2-3 on top, and place it deep in a pot (only 3-4 inches of the cutting visible). I use about 50% pine bark and 50% potting soil. I water it lightly to keep the potting medium moist but not soaked, and I place the pot outside in the bright shade (or morning sun). According to climate, this of course should be done in spring or summer. It works every time for me.


 o
RE: Are there citrus that does well on its own roots?

Thank you john that is exactly what I wanted to know. I have some young fast growing trees that want to be bushes. I want to train them to be trees so I am always tossing cuttings. I figure why not make some more trees. I will either get fruit from them someday or trade them or give them away. Anything is better than tossing them away.


 o
RE: Are there citrus that does well on its own roots?

I know for a fact the Australian lime's are grown on their own roots. When I purchased a Australian Finger Lime from Four Winds Citrus Growers (it came on its own rootstock). This is probably due to the fact that the rootstock already has high disease resistance and root rot resistance.

I am now working on making new plants of it from cuttings. I am still trying to track down the other varieties of Australian limes especially the Desert Lime.


 o
RE: Are there citrus that does well on its own roots?

Are there citrus that can stay in the ground in cold weather? That was kind of a surprise to me. I am in the Pacific Northwest. Our winter temps will go down to 20 degrees a couple of times in the winter and, occasionally even lower, but so far never below 10 degrees. I always bring the plants, which are potted, inside in the winter, but that mystery tangerine I posted about is 4+ ft. high and wanted to be bigger until I clipped him off. It is getting kind of big to move. If there are varieties that are cold hardy enough and can stand the wet winter weather, I would try them.

Thanks,
Mona Everett


 o
RE: Are there citrus that does well on its own roots?

I live in Central Valley, CA so I don't experience true freezes. But it's 8a,8b,9a range where our freezes are 25'ish a couple times in winter.

There are varieties of citrus that can stand colder weather -- but what is usually discussed is the upper foliage and fruit. Any of them in typically sized containers are going to suffer root loss if unprotected below 30F weather, which can severely compound the problem if even lower. Unless you are burying the entire pot in-ground (or creating a giant mulch mound around it), it is best to continue your practice with relocating the citrus of the extreme cold.

If you are asking about in-ground plantings, the satsuma mandarin is supposed to be very cold hardy, so are kumquats, and many lemons will regrow the canopy if the rootstock was protected adequately (much easier than protecting the entire tree) during rare freezes.

However, you might visit this link to check out his opinions about cold hardy citrus, esp from WA folks asking about it. He thinks it's a myth.

Here is a link that might be useful: Cold hardy Citrus a Myth?


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Citrus Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here