Return to the Citrus Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Why is my Owari Satsuma so bland?

Posted by julia42 8b/9a Houston (My Page) on
Mon, Nov 7, 11 at 17:41

So I have a small Owari Satsuma tree that I put in the ground last spring. It set quite a bit of fruit, but I pulled most off, leaving only two. They've started turning orange, so I tried one today. It wasn't terrible or anything, but I found it to be pretty bland. It was sweet, but with very little tartness or richness of flavor. Maybe slightly dry, too. I've had many satsumas before, but I've never known the variety. I was under the impression that Owari continues to be pretty highly regarded, even with all the new varieties that are available. I've heard that Satsumas improve with age - perhaps my tree is too young. Or perhaps it was this year's drought. Or maybe I watered too much? Maybe I picked it too soon? Or too late? Does anyone have any thoughts about this? I'm pretty new to fruit growing... Thanks!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Why is my Owari Satsuma so bland?

Hello!
I'd guess it's a combination of things...drought-stress could certainly contribute. How often did you water?
Also, what are the temperatures like in Houston lately? Here, in the foothills of the Sierra Nevada mountains,
we don't harvest until later this month (and into December). I've always heard that the fruit needs the frost.


Josh


 o
RE: Why is my Owari Satsuma so bland?

I'd say that I deep-watered about once every two weeks, except during the hottest parts of the summer when I upped the watering schedule to once a week. The tree itself is very healthy-looking and has put out plenty of new growth throughout the summer.

Temperatures are still pretty warm here, though. We had one night dip to 33, but mostly we've had highs around 80, lows around 60. Maybe I should leave the other fruit and see if a better flavor develops?


 o
RE: Why is my Owari Satsuma so bland?

Proly the biggest issue is that this species has a reputation of not producing particularly spectacular fruits until the tree is about 5 or 6 years old.
If your tree is healthy and growing, proly you just need to have a little patience. My Brother has 2 in Austin, 4 years old; and this year they are making lots of fruit for the first time. It's a little colder in Austin; so as Josh said, may just be the touch of frost that makes them better... for sure it helps with the color.


 o
RE: Why is my Owari Satsuma so bland?

I've got 11 year old satsuma trees making mostly inferior fruit. Best satsumas fruit I've eaten were from trees planted in 1989. My navel oranges and grapefruit long ago made good fruit. Other mandarins are better but slow also.

Here is a link that might be useful: mrtexas


 o
Satsumas

You may as well pick the fruit off for at least 5 years to let the tree grow with the crummy fruit it will produce. When they start to bear fruit the growing almost stops.


 o
RE: Why is my Owari Satsuma so bland?

Well, that's not very happy news, at least for a garden grower. I have similar issues with my Meyers; if you don't take off most of the fruit in the first year or two, the tree will make fruit, but not grow. That's for my field trees; but for my garden trees, that get more special care, I try to strike a balance between keeping some fruit for my reward, and putting more fertilizer to help the tree grow. Look for my "Garden versus field Meyers" posted recently on this forum to get an idea.


 o
RE: Why is my Owari Satsuma so bland?

Hmm. That is a bit disheartening. I don't mind pulling fruit off for a few years, but five is kind of a long time to wait... Especially when, as your average suburban homeowner, there's a good chance we might not even be living here ten years from now...

MrTexas, if you had to recommend a satsuma or mandarin, which would it be?


 o
RE: Why is my Owari Satsuma so bland?

My 5 year old container Armstrong satsuma gave me 2 wonderful fruit this year, on par with the commercial mandarins I have had. Id love to get and Owari one day. Mrtexas knows his stuff and what he has posted now and before is good information.

mike


 o
RE: Why is my Owari Satsuma so bland?

Satsuma is seedless. Most other mandarins have seeds if that matter to you.


 o
RE: Why is my Owari Satsuma so bland?

  • Posted by fruitnut Z7_4500ft elev SW TX (My Page) on
    Tue, Nov 8, 11 at 15:36

Nearly all the fruit I grow including citrus, figs, and stone fruit is sweeter off trees that are grown at low to moderate vigor and with a long period of moderate water deficit. Young trees are usually grown at higher vigor, more water and fertilizer. This is needed to get a tree with some size but results in those early fruits being inferior.

The reason modest water deficit gives sweeter fruit is that the tree increases osmotic potential of it's tissues by increasing sugars in order to withdraw water from dry soil. Modest water deficit also reduces cell size resulting in firmer plums and pluot. Fruit ends up smaller and sweeter.

My citrus gives sweetest fruit when the tree basically has only one growth flush per year due to less water and fertilizer.


 o
RE: Why is my Owari Satsuma so bland?

Fruitnut, that makes sense. It seems like mostly people are telling me to have patience while the tree matures. Okay - I'll take all your advice.

MrTexas, I do like having at least one tree that's mostly seedless (which will probably remain my Owari) for my kids. Personally, me and my husband can deal with seeds, and I'll have an opening for a new tree come spring. I'm also considering a grapefruit or pummelo if you have a favorite.


 o
RE: Why is my Owari Satsuma so bland?

My favorite grapefruit a both very seedy, golden grapefruit and duncan grapefruit. The advantage of golden is it is very early. Mine are sweet now and were edible a month ago. Duncan is later. The red grapefruit so popular won't be ready until at least Christmas. Golden grapefruit is available at the master gardener sales in Houston. Duncan is the gold standard for grapefruit flavor, the best I've certainly ever eaten. Duncan is harder to find although I propagate it to sell I don't know of anyone else doing it in Texas.

Here is a link that might be useful: mrtexas


 o
grapefruit

The Texas red grapefruit are seedless and very nice in color. But I thought eating was about flavor. IMHO red grapefruit are good tasting but not the best. Give me a hard to find seedy white duncan grapefruit any time for the best flavor.


 o
RE: Why is my Owari Satsuma so bland?

My best satsuma now is BC2. All my satsumas are young and BC2 is sweet. I pulled out my mature tree. It was @8 years old and the fruit just did not sweeten up. I have had satsumas sweet as candy that were only 3 years old. Sold the house with the plants and haven't been able to find another tree with such sweet fruit. If I had known, I would have taken the tree. My favorite grapefruits are Duncan and Ruby Red. Duncans are very sweet with traditional grapefruit flavor. Ruby reds are super sweet....my favorite. I gave my Golden grapefruit to my brother in law. Did not care for it. It has mild orange and mild grapefruit flavors. Not as good as a regular grapefruit, nor as good as a regular orange. It was a heavy bearer every year with no problems, but did not care for the fruit. I don't know what part of town you live in, but RCW Nursery normally carries the Duncan. JRN Nursery with have most all other citrus. Good luck.


 o
RE: Why is my Owari Satsuma so bland?

Thanks for the suggestions. I was just going to say that I hadn't seen Duncan in any nurseries around here - I guess I'll have to drive up to RCW to get one if I decide on that (I'm down in Pearland). I'm hoping to make it to a citrus tasting or two this winter before I pick.

I grew up on Rio and Ruby Red grapefruit in the RGV (Rio Grande Valley), so it may be hard for me to move past the sweet pink grapefruit, but I'll try to keep an open mind if I can find the others to try. I'm hoping to make it to John Panzarella's open house in December...


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Citrus Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here