JOIN NOW LOG IN
iVillage GardenWeb iVillage GardenWeb THE INTERNET'S GARDEN & HOME COMMUNITY ADVERTISEMENT
Blogs Forums Photo Galleries Ask The Experts Tools & Directories        
Return to the Conifers Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Choosing Understocks for Grafting

Posted by gardener365 5a (My Page) on
Wed, Feb 3, 10 at 10:11

Always a good subject of knowledge and one that I am very interested in to hear opinions/experiences. Europeans have been grafting far-longer than Americans and I'm sure other countries too have valuable knowledge about this subject.

I've changed my preferences on fir - Jorg Kohout suggests:
Abies koreana
Abies veitchii
Americans typically use Nordmann/Balsam/Canaan

2-needled pines:
sylvestris seems to be universal.
what else are you using? especially for dwarfs/mini's?

5-needled Pines
Again, Jorg Kohout suggests:
Pinus armandii
Pinus wallichiana
Americans use exclusively strobus.

3-needled and combinations of 2-3-needled pines:
A friend in the US has found Pinus ponderosa to be a very useful understock.
Pinus strobus also seems to be a US choice.

Spruce:
Norway is much easier to work with than the sharp needles of pungens.

Larch:
What are you using? decidua I assume?

Cedrus (true)
Cedrus deodara has been reported by Bob Fincham as a zone 5 "root-hardy" understock.

Cypress:
Here in the US often cutting-grown rootstocks of Juniperus 'Hetzi' are used. They can be propagated early winter and grafted onto late the same year.
Any other Cupressus info?
Microbiota I've heard is very compatible with (at least) nootka. That's a 'wild' combination however. Nootka grafted to microbiota shows excellent compatibility after 20 years.

The concept of 2-3 needles hard pines (rigida, ponderosa, bungeana) being grafted to another pine of the same needle count, makes sense to my friend. It also makes sense to me.

Any more thoughts? It would be much appreciated. I'd like to learn a lot. (other genus and/or species combinations)

Thanks,

Dax


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Choosing Understocks for Grafting

"5-needled Pines. Again, Jorg Kohout suggests: Pinus armandii, Pinus wallichiana. Americans use exclusively strobus" - I'd carry on with P. strobus. The other two may well have cold-hardiness problems, anywhere colder than zone 7-8.

"3-needled and combinations of 2-3-needled pines: A friend in the US has found Pinus ponderosa to be a very useful understock. Pinus strobus also seems to be a US choice" - yes to Pinus ponderosa; but not Pinus strobus, except for Pinus bungeana and pinyon pines (these are more closely related to white pines than to P. ponderosa, etc.).

"Nootka grafted to Microbiota" - that's just weird, grafting a common plant (Nootka Cypress) on a rare rootstock (Microbiota) . . . I could understand the other way round!

Resin


 o
RE: Choosing Understocks for Grafting

Thank you Resin!!!

Dax


 o
RE: Choosing Understocks for Grafting

Polish Grafter Writes:

For firs, I use abies alba and abies koreana.
For 5-needled Pines , I use pinus strobus,pinus cembra and pinus peuce.
For pinus cembra, I graft them on pinus sylvestris understocks with good results.
For pinus parviflora Glauca, I graft them on pinus contorta var. latifolia understocks.
You can graft pinus koreansis and pinus pumila by using pinus sylvestris understocks.
For 2-3-needled pines, I use pinus sylvestris understocks.
For pinus ponderosa, I was told that it is better to use pinus ponderosa and pinus nigra understocks
For pinus virginiana ,I was told that it is better to use Pinus banksiana understocks.
For Spruce, Picea abies understocks.


 
 

 

 


Click here to learn more about in-text links on this page.



iVillage GardenWeb: The Internet's Garden & Home Community  
  iVillage Home & Garden Network