Return to the Conifers Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
? Picea a.Reflexa and Acer p. CQ

Posted by chohio 6 SW OH (My Page) on
Thu, Jun 12, 14 at 19:01

Hoping this is no big deal. I can hear a couple of you saying it's just inner needle drop and normal but it's the 1st time I've seen it and I wanted to double check to be sure. The first photo was a few weeks ago from the front with nice new growth. The following 2 are from the back and the inside that I noticed while spreading mulch. The outside still looks great.
 photo PARelexa514.jpg
 photo PARelexa514.jpg
 photo PARelexa514.jpg

Since there are so many with Acer's I thought I would ask here since we have authorities come in here to read.
This is Acer p. Crimson Queen from last year
 photo AcerPCrimsonQueen513.jpg
Put it in end of May 2012 and we promptly went into a drought as we all did in the country yet it came back fine last year per the above photo although I noticed the below injury on the bottom of the tree last year and figured either from the drought the year before or mulch had washed up high against the trunk.
 photo Acer.jpg

This year it started leafing out when we got an unheard of snow in late April of several inches and when it melted the weather went into mid to high 80's within days on the still baby leaves not out all the way grown out yet and it burned them up and browned and fell off. So I've listened to all of you and know they can releaf but this has been over a month now and the bottom started growing the leaves shown here which is obviously root stock. So opinions please? Does the root stock leaves mean it's unlikely to grow the Crimson Queen uptop or is it still a wait and see and if it is, how long a wait and see could I go. It did so well so was kind of surprised this happened. Appreciate all of your responses. TIA
Cher
 photo Acer.jpg


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: ? Picea a.Reflexa and Acer p. CQ

The spruce looks fine.

The Maple looks like a goner. It may just be winterkill and unrelated to the April snow or freeze...looks like it to me.

You could, if you want, train one of those lower sprouts into a new tree, if they originate from above the graft, but it probably isn't worth it.

This post was edited by hairmetal4ever on Thu, Jun 12, 14 at 20:14


 o
RE: ? Picea a.Reflexa and Acer p. CQ

Hi Chohio, Your Picea abies is fine. If you wanted to carefully nip out some of the spent branches on the interior that would be fine and help with some air flow. Just go slow and make sure its dead before snipping.... Sorry to say, everthing above the graft on your maple is dead. I can tell from the color. It wont be back. This doesnt mean it would have turned out differently, but anytime you see your understock flushing out like that , dont hesitate and nip them off flush to the trunk. Dont let them get your cultivars energy.Unless you want an Acer palmatum...its time to start over with that one.
Best of luck
Al


 o
RE: ? Picea a.Reflexa and Acer p. CQ

Ohio had a pretty rough winter. My father near Canton had -14 a couple times - not sure how cold you got down in SW Ohio.

His Jap maples actually look OK, but his neighbor's Seriyu had about 50% crown dieback, although it appears to be recovering.


 o
RE: ? Picea a.Reflexa and Acer p. CQ

hairmetal4ever we also got -14 but that was with wind chill. Definitely had zone 5 weather here and zone 4 with wind chill. It just surprised me because the CQ part leafed out and then burned up. Darn I loved that thing but will not put in another CQ as this Winter showed if we have an exceptional year it can't cope. I have 4 other Jap Maples that did fine. The person that writes a gardening column here for the paper I think stated she lost 7 Jap Maples so I was feeling real good when all of mine were leafing out at that time. :) I won't keep the tree as I like to many cultivars to keep a normal palmatum, let alone it would be too big anyway for that space. I'll pot it though for a year or so and send it out to my brother's farm. :)

Al I appreciate your opinion. Normally I would have pruned the rootstock leaves but not being sure if it would releaf had decided to leave them to feed the tree until I got some other opinions. Just ticks me off that I am now short a Jap Maple.

Appreciate the comments on the Picea. I could hear Ken in my head saying every few years you lose interior needles so thought that was it and now know for sure.
Cher


 o
RE: ? Picea a.Reflexa and Acer p. CQ

  • Posted by whaas 5a SE WI (My Page) on
    Fri, Jun 13, 14 at 7:01

cho, are you saying your lowest temp was -14 with the windchill?

We had -60 windchill and there are Crimson Queen's alive around in protected spots.

I bet the cold just accelerated its death but an injury like that is surely going to weaken a tree and not help with pumping water to the canopy. I just found that same type of injury on Nook Green Arrow earlier this spring, as you can imagine it was dead.

I guess my point is that the winter really isn't to blame on this one.


 o
RE: ? Picea a.Reflexa and Acer p. CQ

Yes Cher, The bottom portion of your tree looked compromised. Did you buy it like that? Or was something hungry? It may have played a part in its demise.

Al


 o
RE: ? Picea a.Reflexa and Acer p. CQ

Thanks whass for your answer. I did feel the injury was the main issue. That's why I was so happy to see the top start leafing out this Spring. It was another year of living with it, but I felt the tree had just have too much go wrong. Someone else was posting in Acer's about their CQ so it made me nervous but I hate not getting another as it's a great size for that location. Was out looking today and let me tell you all the trees have skyrocketed in price in the last year and didn't see a decent CQ among them anyway. We'll see.

Al I'm not sure what happened. It was fine when I got it then a year later I noticed that lower damage. I will say I discovered just a month ago that a rabbit has been getting in under a spot in the fence which I ran out and closed up so whether he was in the yard a year ago I can't say or just stress from the drought of 12 that appeared last year, I don't know but I do appreciate the answers as I will be keeping an eye out for some kind of replacement for sure now.
Cher


 o
RE: ? Picea a.Reflexa and Acer p. CQ

Cher: I am further south that you and had -13F (no wind chill factored) twice last winter. i was fortunate to suffer no damage on the maples.

However, in our area the palmatum problem is generally not the lowest temperature, but rather what you described. The palmatums start to leaf and the sap is flowing and zap along comes a freeze. That damaged tissue cannot recover. It is not your choice of cultivar,CQ,but rather an endemic problem.

IMO the reward still outweighs the risk.


 o
RE: ? Picea a.Reflexa and Acer p. CQ

You know after I wrote that baxz I remembered that was the actual temp the one day without chill -14. Under my patio which is mostly enclosed the temp was 3. I was watching a lot this past Winter to see how much warmer it stays under there based on how cold it is. It was 17 degrees warmer plus extra with wind chill. Seems like it was -25 with wind chill but thankfully it's a distant memory right now. LOL

You could be right on that tree with the freeze because I thought it was ok and it was the second year to leaf with that prior injury. Maybe a combo problem and the freeze just was too much with the injury there too. My other Jap Maples did fine but their leaves were slightly further along so that may be why they made it. Not seeing anything local yet to replace so it may be Fall or next Spring. Anyway I sure do appreciate all of you taking your time with the responses.
Cher


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Conifers Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here