Return to the Cottage Garden Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Nice hardy shrub rose?

Posted by thinman Z5 MI (My Page) on
Wed, Apr 10, 13 at 13:16

Hi, all. I'm going to put in a new mixed flower bed this spring, whenever that might be. I'll probably be asking for ideas for its shape after the snow leaves and I can get a picture of the area to post here.

For now, though, I'm asking for a rose suggestion because I don't know a darn thing about them.. I think what I want is a shrub rose. I'd like it to pop, so probably it should be more towards pink than red, and if it could be fairly full, double flowered, prolific, hardy, and around three feet tall, that would really float my boat. Is that doable? Yellow would be OK, too, but not orange please.

Any helpful thoughts?

ThinMan


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

Do you care if it is scented? If not, I have heard great things about the Knockout series as far as disease resistance, long bloom season, and ease of care. Pink Double Knockout might fit your needs.

I have grown The Fairy and it bloomed for a log time with clusters of many small double roses. Often more roses than leaves were visible because it was so full of flowers. It also is unscented.

You could also ask on the roses forum.


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

David Austin's shrub rose 'Gertrude Jekyll' is a favorite of mine, lovely old rose fragrance and bonus, a repeat bloomer. Supposed to be hardy to Z5 but to be on the safe side I'd try to find one grown on it's own roots. Ht. 3-6 ft. but pruning shears could keep it lower.

Annette


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

I would vote for The Fairy Rose too. It blooms almost non-stop from June to Nov. No pests or diseases either. I've never even seen a Japanese beetle on any of mine. Completely carefree.


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

I've been reading about The Fairy and it sounds great. I'll look at the Knockouts and Gertrude Jekyll next. This is fun. Thanks a lot for the suggestions.

TM


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

Annette, David Austen roses are not hardy if they are on their own root. That's why here in Ontario, they are grafted to hardier stock. Yes they do quite well here in our zone 5 climate. I've 2 of them and will add more.

Bourbon roses, Explorer roses all do well. Let me give you a link to a Canadian supplier just for referencing. You can see how many options there are for your zone.

Here is a link that might be useful: Pickering Nurseries


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

Ianna it's the opposite here, a lot of the roses for sale here have been grafted on a rootstock suitable for California and don't fair well when we have a bad winter. D.A.'s on their own roots thrive here but then I'm Z 7-8ish. I stopped buying grafted roses and haven't lost a one other than the ones I have dug and given away. What rootstock is used in your zone 5?

Annette


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

TM, here is a pic of The Fairy in my slope garden on July 2. I have 3 of them in there and they are invaluable for constant bloom and interest. As well as low-maintenance on a slope. They play nice with other shrubs, trees or perennials and annuals. They do "rest" around August, but come back for another great round of bloom in the fall. You don't have to, but I do find that the bloom is better in the fall when I snip off the spent blooms, which is easy to do since they're all clustered together at the end of each branch.

This is one of mine from Oct 26 a couple years ago.

The last hurrah Nov 26.


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

TM, check out the Easy Elegance series of roses. I have quite a few and really like them. They are hardy in my Wisconsin garden. I really like Sunrise Sunset. I have 3 planted along the sidewalk and just added 2 to the garden room last summer.
 photo small5-25-2012011.jpg


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

This is going to be harder than I thought. Thanks, Annette, Babs, Thyme2dig, Ianna, and Mary Lu for helping me with this. Thyme2dig, your slope garden is outstanding, and I really like the looks of The Fairy. Mary Lu, I know you have a lot of roses, and thought maybe you would see this post. The Easy Elegance in your picture is just covered with blooms, isn't it? Very nice!

TM


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

I see that you have some nice suggestions for some roses that meet the height requirement (going to keep an eye out for the fairy rose and sunrise sunset :-) ), but thought I would offer another suggestion from my experience. I have had 'bonica' for several years and really love it. Sorry, no pics of the whole shrub, but it is a very pretty soft pink.


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

forgot to mention that my zone listed is Canadian zone info so equal to US zone 5 and bonica is listed as hardy to zone 4(US)
it is about 4-5 feet tall, but I keep it pruned (brutally at times) and it responds by blooming happily.


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

Greylady, is Bonica scented?


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

Bonica would be another great choice to consider TM, I haven't grown it myself but have seen it in other gardens, it's a winner.

Annette


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

Thinman, the link below opens to a page with all the shrub roses that are good for your zone. It's at least good to my Canadian zone 5 which is equivalent to a US zone 4.

Also FYI- explorer roses were especially bred from Canadian cold temperaturs.

Annette-- that's a good question. I never really bothered to find out. The David Austens here in Ontario are sold as grafted onto hardier stocks and that's all I needed to know. So far I've had no trouble with any of mine. No graph separations - nothing.

Here is a link that might be useful: see shrub roses good for zone 5


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

My personal favorite is Peace, although I think it's a tea rather than shrub...

What about one of the hybrid Rugosas? I've heard they are pretty easy care, no spraying needed. You could look to the Pavement series for shorter growers.


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

Bonica looks great, too. How am I going to choose? Now I'm not sure that one rose is going to do it for me. :)

Ianna - Thanks for the links to Pickering Nurseries. They have a lot of good info for each rose. It's a shame that their business is being so crippled now by being cut off from US sales.

TM


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

Thiman, I only meant to show you the wide variety of roses that can survive in your zone. Knowing the trade agreements (should have been renamed trade prohibitions) between the US and CAnada, I know it would be next to impossible to order from them from the US.

Ianna


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

Yep, I got that, Ianna. Thank you.

TM


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

I have had a Bonica rose for 10 years and I love it. It is very hardy and needs no special treatment. Blooms from June to late October in my zone 5 area. Lovely soft pink flowers. Just plant it and enjoy.


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

Most of my roses are from the Antique Rose Emporium.
These are mostly roses saved from old gardens and cemeteries. Rose Rustlers decided to try to save as many as they could before they were lost forever.
There is a window to select your zip code and one for your zone. See the online catalog for other types. I typed zone 5 and small shrubs. Notice the intro dates on these roses. Some are from the mid 1700's
This is buff beauty climber. I bought the original in 1998 and this is from a cutting taken in 2005 or 2006.
Kathy

Here is a link that might be useful: roses hardy in zone 5


 o
RE: Nice hardy shrub rose?

TM, have you picked a rose and planted it yet? If so, which one did you decide on?

Mine are all leafing out now and I haven't spring pruned most of them yet. Way behind this year.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Cottage Garden Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here