Do my eyes deceive me, or does that soft yellow one have pink midribs? I personally loathe and detest white midribs (on any but the palest of yellow, cream, soft white, or near-white blooms), but I love pink or melon or lavender midribs.

Could that soft yellow one be a polychrome? (It's hard to tell.) I love polychromes.

I think you know which one has got my vote!

pretty seedlings, I like # 1 and # 4 pictures.

jean

I like three and five.
kay

3 & 5 are my favorites too, I especially like the color of # 3.

I like 5 the best, followed by #3 and #4. I'd love to see them all again without raindrops.

Debra

They are all really nice, but I like 3, 4 and 5 the best.

There doesn't seem to be a clear winner so far. Seeing just a bloom doesn't give anyone an idea of plant habit, but 1 and 2 are blooming in the foliage so I have them both marked to go even though the flowers are pretty enough.

Polymerous, Yes I think there is a hint of pink in the midribs on 4 and hints of pink on the petals. I don't know if it's enough to qualify as a polychrome.

Debra I'll try to post dry pictures of 3,4, and 5. The water on these was from a 10 minute shower this morning that wasn't enough to do any good and there is no rain in the forecast so it shouldn't be a problem. The problem is having to drag hoses constantly. Seems like Jean and I are the only ones not getting rain. These flowers have a lot of substance though so they do hold up well when it rains.
Val

I can't even decide about my own but here goes. I would definitely keep #5 and #4. Marg

Nice Val. I like seeing the raindrops on them.
3, 4 and 5 based on looks.

Julia

I like 5 then 3 best.

I like #4 best.

I might save #3 and #5 for one more cross.
Ed