Return to the Canadian Garden Exchange Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Posted by bonniepunch USDAz4 AgCanz5a (My Page) on
Sun, Sep 9, 07 at 9:54

In past years I have hosted unusual seed Round Robins, but because of the rising postage rates and the fact that it is difficult for people with only one or two sorts of unusual seeds to participate, I thought Id try a different way this year. So - an exchange is being offered. I will accept envelopes until the first of December (this will give you a chance to collect your slow to mature seeds).

This exchange will work like this:

- You send me your unusual seeds in a padded envelope, along with $1.86 in postage and a return address label.
- I will swap your seeds for others that I have received from other people.
- I send your new seeds back to you using your padded mailer and postage.

Pretty simple! Of course there are some other rules I have to apply to keep things working smoothly . If you are interested in participating, please read the following, and if youre interested, please email me and I will get back to you.

The first big rule is determining what is, and what is not, an unusual seed. This isnt for costly or rare seeds, so please do not expect or include any. An unusual seed, for the purposes of this exchange, is a seed that you probably wont find in Veseys or Canadian Tire. Seeds for tropical or houseplants are unusual. Seeds for plants usually sold as bulbs or live perennials are good. Heavily hybridized plants are ok as long as you know the name of the parent(s) - Hostas, Daylilies, and Iris for example (the big green and white Hosta in the backyard does not count!). Echinacea White Swan, white Cosmos and Bee Balm are not unusual seeds. Ligularia, Petasites and Heuchera are examples of unusual perennial seeds. There is no definitive list of what qualifies as an unusual seed and what one person considers unusual may be very common in another area, so I will ask people for some examples of seeds that they would like to send. I may veto some of your selections if I think they are too common or if they are being included by everyone (I want this to be as fair as possible for everyone participating). Some examples of unusual seeds that I will be including are Astilboides tabularis, Eucomis, Paeonia officinalis, Clematis brachyura, Hosta Inniswood, Actaea (Cimicifuga) racemosa and actaea simplex Brunette.

No veggies. I know some people will want them included, but most people will not, so Im putting them out of the running early on.

All seeds must be marked with a common name, if known (not all plants have common names), and a botanical name. Please note if the seeds are from a commercial source or collected. If the plant the seeds came from is a hybrid, then that must also be indicated (please give the name of the parent/s, when known).

The seeds must be placed in a leak-proof envelope. I use 2x3" ziplock type envelopes I buy at the dollar store. I recommend against using your own pre-made paper envelopes these have a history of coming open in transit and the seeds are lost. If you must use them, then make sure they are sealed thoroughly with tape!!! The same goes for those paper coin envelopes they dont always travel well, so tape them shut.

You may include up to five envelopes of the same sort of seed. These will be exchanged for five different seeds. This way, even people with one or two types of unusual seeds will be able to participate. Please keep the number of seed envelopes in your padded mailer to less than thirty. Large seeds should have at least six to twelve seeds in the envelope. Medium seeds should have at least two dozen in the envelope. Small seeds should have a good 1/8 teaspoon full in the envelope. You may put more seeds in the envelope if you wish, but please do not put in fewer than suggested.

If you are sending seeds that will require refrigeration until they are planted, please indicate on the packet, and I will store them as required.

There is no way of knowing what people will send in so there is no way of knowing what you will get back. It will be a surprise. You may make a couple of suggestions as to seeds you would particularly like or dislike and I will make every effort to accommodate those requests, but there are no guarantees.

Further suggestions and comments are more than welcome!

BP


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Bonnie, Thanks for organizing! Sent you a list of what I have, look forward to hearing from you. Kirsti


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Looking forward to this Bonnie! Sending you an e-mail.


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

thehills - I've sent you a reply to your email - if you don't get it, let me know here! Sometimes GW email doesn't work properly :-)

BP


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

tiffy - got your email and have replied as well.

BP


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Just letting you know I got the e-mail. :O)


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

oof - got busy yesterday so I didn't respond here to let people know I was recieving their emails!

Anyhow, I already got acknowledgments from two other people that they are getting my replies and tinkerbel - I got your email and also replied.

I want to make sure one thing I wrote above is a bit clearer, just to avoid any confusion - you can send me up to 30 envelopes of seeds. You do not have to send that many if you do not want - that's the maximum per participant. Duplicate seeds envelopes are allowed - up to five envelopes per sort of seed. So some examples of what you can send are:

1x30 (thirty different sorts of seeds)
2x15 (two envelopes each of fifteen different sorts of seeds)
5x6 (five envelopes each of six different sorts of seeds)

BP


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Would Baptisia (Blue Indigo), oxalis triangularis, dianthus superbum, four o'clocks, malva Ruby Regis, Malva Braveheart, and Malva Zebrina, be considered as rare and unusual seeds?


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

claubill - I would say that the Baptisia and the Oxalis would be on the unusual side, but the others are a bit more common that I am looking for.

BP


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Jennifer F - I received your envelope in the mail this afternoon.

BP


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Bev W - your packet came in the mail yesterday afternoon.

BP


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Bumping this up.
Bonnie I like to send in some North American Rock Garden Seed packages plus a few from my garden such as
Dwarf Goatsbeard, aruncus aethusefolius 18 cm
Campanula rotundifolia (incurva)20 cm
Salvia argentea, silver sage
Spilanthes acmella, an unusual annual without florets
Thalictrum rochebrunianum 1-1.5 m


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

I've been crazy busy the past few weeks getting all my plants sorted out and prepared, so I have been neglecting this for a bit! Sorry 'bout that!!

Anyhow, there is still plenty of time for people that want to participate to send in their seeds.

BP


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Sharont - I got your envelope in the mail this morning.

BP


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Hi
I would love to be a part of the swap. I am working on a germination project and need seeds of all kinds. I have some already too.

Thanks
Wendy
Are these considered unusual?
Poached Egg plant?
What about Dwarf or Streaked Hosta Seed?
Hosta Frances Williams seed.
Trumpet Lily seed or
Crocosmia.
Amaranthus "Molten Fire" and
Amaranthus "Hot Biscuits"

Please e-mail me when you get a chance - I have others as well, some a bit more unique like Allamanda etc but need to know how many seeds per pkg etc.

Thanks so much


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

uniqueseedlady - I apologize for taking a while to respond to you - I was away on holiday and I had very intermittent web access. Some of your listed seeds would be good ones for this exchange. I have tried to email you privately, but you do not have email enabled on your gardenweb page - if you could email me (click on my name or 'my page' and you will get a link to email me). I am home from my holiday now so I will respond right away.

Wanda C - your seed packet arrived yesterday.

BP


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

I woudl also like to join in. I will go to my box and see what I have and ask what you would think is unusual. Thank you


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Seeds sent today, thanks again for organizing Bonnie. Kirsti


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Seeds sent today, thanks again for organizing Bonnie. Kirsti


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

I'm sorry I couldn't get my act together gathering up all the seeds. - Family obligations too much at this time. I will have to drop out. Please delete my name. Thanks

Annie


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Marcelle G - your seeds arrived yesterday.
Tiffany E - your seeds arrived this morning.

orphanannie - these things happen - it's no problem :-). If you find yourself with the time and the inclination in the next couple of days, there should still be time to get a package to me, especially if you're in Ontario.

Anyone else thinking of joining in, there's still time. You should plan on putting your seeds in the mail by Monday or Tuesday.

BP

BP


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Bonnie,

I'd really like to participate.
I have
double red "Sunrise" morning glory
"Double Click" cosmos
yucca
fern-leaf pink peony
small wild orchid
geum "Mrs Bradshaw"
double purple datura

Do any meet the 'unusual' criteria?

Marlene


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Marlene - I've just sent you an email, please let me know if you didn't get it (some people have a hard time with mail sent through GW)

BP


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Hi Bonnie
Sorry I am writing alittle late for the exchange, I would love to join if I am still on time, I will send you an email with what I have.


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

wildflower - there's still time! I haven't received your email as of 7:00PM, so I sent you an email just in case yours went missing :-)

BP


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Kirsten O - I got your package in the mail this afternoon.

Anyone else - If you're in BC it's too late to mail me anything. If you're in the praries or the maritimes, your package needs to be mailed today. If you're in Ontario or Quebec, you need to get your packages in the mail today of tomorrow.

BP


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Thanks for the message.My computor has been down while I moved and I have had to rejoin , hense new name.Thanks for doing this.Did you ever get the first package that I sent you? The cardamon is doing great.


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

horsetail - you're Marcelle then, if I'm remembering correctly? I don't remember anyone else mentioning they were moving, but things have been so chaotic this summer and fall, I'm lucky I remember to get up in the morning :-) And if my memory is functioning at all correctly, yours was the sempervivum package that went missing? It never did show up, unfortunately :-( The replacement ones did great and got quite large, one even put off some pups. Now I just have to hope for a decent winter and they should survive just fine. I'm glad to hear the cardamom is doing well - it's pretty easy to grow and shouldn't give you much trouble :-)

BP


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Sunita K - your package arrived today
Kirsti D - same thing, your package also arrived

As of today, this seed exchange is now closed. If your package isn't already in the mail, it is too late. I am waiting for one further package to arrive (from MV) that I know of - if anyone else has sent a package and I have not posted that it has been received, please let me know. As soon as the last package has arrived, I will exchange the seeds and mail them back out to everyone.

BP


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Maria V - your package arrived today
D Simpson - your package also arrived today

I figured I'd get them yesterday, but the big snowstorm we had then meant no mail delivery.

I am not expecting any other packages, so I will swap the seeds tomorrow and get the envelopes back in the mail to everyone by Thursday.

BP


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

OK everyone - they're in the mail! I expect the Ontario envelopes should start showing up early next week, and the BC and NS ones should be there by the week after.

BP


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Thank you BP for doing this exchange again this year.
Santa arriving early certainly brightens tedious christmas shopping. LOL


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Bonnie,
Seeds arrived today...What a delight!!!!!I'm definitely thinking sunshine and flowers even if it is snowing.
Thank you for all your work and to the others for participating.

Marlene


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

The seeds are starting to arrive at their destinations, so everyone, keep their eyes peeled.

I mentioned already to someone, but thought I should make a general mention, that many of these seeds are somewhat, to very challenging to germinate. Sunflowers are cheap, easy to find, and popular for a reason (super easy to grow), and we were exchanging unusual seeds. Please be sure to look up any/all of the seeds you received that you received that you are unfamiliar with, so that you can have the best chance at success (some good sites for germination info: backyard gardener and Tom Clothier's site). Even with this knowledge, not everyone will be successful with everything. It took me four tries at germinating Actaea before I had any success, and I've been growing from seed for twenty years, so I (usually) know what I'm doing :-)

But the theory is that you learn as much from your failures as from your successes, and where you're successful, you'll have some interesting plants for next to nothing :-)

Happy gardening everyone!

BP


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

Received mine today...wow...very interesting seeds...some I d never heard of but they re all cool! I m looking forward to growing them..

Thanks Bonnie for organizing this!

S


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

  • Posted by linkir Nova Scotia 6b (My Page) on
    Thu, Dec 13, 07 at 8:27

Hi Bonnie -
The seeds arrived and I'm So Pleased. This year Christmas will be one long and happy spring!!
Thanks for doing this,
Kirsten


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

  • Posted by jenf z7b BC (My Page) on
    Fri, Dec 14, 07 at 22:47

Got my seeds today Bonnie. Thanks so much, they are awesome. I can't wait to get started. Once again, thanks for you're hard work and have a great holiday season.
Cheers Jennifer


 o
RE: HAVE: Unusual seed exchange

I'm as determined as you to germinate Actea. My first success this year took two winters. It took three tries with three different seed sources. Just in case those seedlings do not make it through the winter, I'm giving the seeds you sent a go. Got to get them sown soon and into the cold!
Thanks Bonnie.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Please Note: Only registered members from Canada are able to post messages here (this may be indicated by the title of the forum. All exchanges not indicated otherwise are restricted to those living in the U.S.)

If you are a member from an area mentioned above, please log in.


Return to the Canadian Garden Exchange Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here