Return to the Far North Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Lily problem

Posted by north53 1b Manitoba (My Page) on
Fri, Jun 28, 13 at 0:13

I'm trying to help a new gardener in Wpg who is having a serious problem with her lilies. Trouble is, I live up north, so I'm only seeing a picture.
She took the picture with her phone and sent it to me. I'll post it for you. Maybe we can help her out. It's not a very clear picture, however.
She describes these blobs as slugs and they are devastating her lilies. I've never had slugs attack my lilies, so I'm confused by this.
Here's the picture.
lily problem photo photo_zpsf080b2d5.jpg
Could it be the grub of the lily beetle?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Lily problem

what about this

Here is a link that might be useful: Larva not grub?


 o
RE: Lily problem

This is most likely lily blight. Very probable in rainy, wet seasons with lots of hail or heavy rain.

Ginny


 o
RE: Lily problem

Larval stage of red lily beetle.


 o
RE: Lily problem

Thanks everyone,
That's a very clear picture, ClBlakey.
So, larval stage of the red lily beetle.

Anyone else dealing with this scourge? They don't seem to be in our area yet, but I'm sure it's just a matter of time.


 o
RE: Lily problem

Not here yet. A friend of mine in Toronto is plagued with them, but she declared war against them and seems to be getting the better of it. She hand-picks and destroys them. She calls them ERBs - Evil Red - - - Beetles, yeah, that's the B word she uses.... LOL Apparenlty neem oil can be used - not sure as a remedy or a preventative but now it's not for sale in Canada.


 o
RE: Lily problem

They look a bit like escargot maybe hand pick and cook in garlic butter. Unfortunately they do not appear on the edible bug list. Shame!

Here is a link that might be useful: Maybe the list is incomplete


 o
RE: Lily problem

That is definitely the red lily beetle. The adults and larvae have voracious appetites and can easily eat all the leaves.

That is the larval stage of the insect you are seeing there. They cover themselves in their own poop as a defense mechanism. She'll need to scrape them off and squish them. The beetle's season is the whole growing season so she will need to be on the lookout for them. The thing is the beetles are sorta smart so when you touch them, they fall to the ground upside down as a defense mechanism.

My lilies were inundated with them last year. This year when I first saw them I used a foaming wasp spray on the plants. That seemed to have worked wonders as I have not seen them again this year.


 o
RE: Lily problem

Good to know, Shazam. Will have to remember that if they ever make it to this part of the country.


 o
RE: Lily problem

They come into new areas on nursery plants and as eggs on bulbs. I have heard talk of them being pretty bad in parts of Manitoba already, but what nobody seems to be able to answer is whether they're overwintering successfully year to year. I suspect most winters could wipe them out here, only to show up again on new infested plants. This seems likely considering the incredible decimation in warmer areas versus scattered reports over the past decade around here. It doesn't seem like they've really taken hold.


 o
RE: Lily problem

Thanks north, I was curious as to how a bug that was for the most part plant species dependant would travel. I am off to see if I can find what is chewing holes in my dog wood and one hydrangea.

SCG


 o
RE: Lily problem

I haven't heard of anyone in my area having them and I hope it stays away. Sometimes being in the cold harsh north is a good thing. But then I haven't bought any new lilies lately, so there's no chance of importing them either.


 o
RE: Lily problem

Yes North being up here has benefits for sure. Looking at it that way I am very fortunate. The winters can get cold and the summers are so hot and dry that things like mosquito's, fleas, ticks or the like are rare. I am hoping this holds true for thrips and the like....

side note I couldn't find any bugs on the shrubs that are chewed........I hope I have enough patience to leave dr doom and malathion in the cupboard.

SCG


 o
RE: Lily problem

Ok guys, as of this afternoon I'm infested with lily beetles too. I haven't purchased lilies for at least 5 years so they must have flown in from somewhere.

I guess I'll get hand-picking. #%$&* I just signed up for our garden club's garden tour, which is in July when there will be NOTHING blooming but lilies.

Totally. freaking. upset.


 o
RE: Lily problem

So sorry North. Everyone has an opinion but mine would have Dr. Doom out. Good luck with whatever method you choose.

SCG


 o
RE: Lily problem

I move quickly and overreact frequently, and I have already ordered $60 worth of pharmaceutical grade Neem oil.

Beetles picked the wrong garden. LOL


 o
RE: Lily problem

Lol, I do the same. My planting style is the same too. I buy then try to figure out where it can go. Usually with a lot of wrong decisions.

I do wish you luck. I, and my gardens, are so newi would be devastated. Not to mention having a glorious garden like yours that people would tour. Uggg

SCG


 o
RE: Lily problem

Oh no!
Have you tried the baby powder treatment? I found a discussion about it on another website. And where did you find Neem oil? I looked for it uptown today, but didn't see any.

Here's an excerpt about the baby powder from PlantLilies.com.

"Hi-
In the May 2011 issue of Garden Central, I read Mary Louise Miller's request for help fighting lily beetles. My good friend Bill taught me how to deal with them: TALCUM POWDER. Yup, ordinary talcum powder. Baby powder with talc, not with cornstarch, works very well. I buy the largest size and poof it beside the lilies and on the ground around them. I begin in the spring with the first sign of growth, then apply it regularly afterwards. It works on all stages of the beetle. It is cheap, safe for humans and plants, is biodegradable and works. I think it suffocates the critters because it is such a very fine powder. It also works on ant hills. Just cover the top of the hill and block the entrance to the nest. Hope this idea helps restore lily plants and sanity to those trying to enjoy these glorious plants."


 o
RE: Lily problem

Marie (I think... memory sketchy), email me about the neem oil. groundskeeperjilly (at) gmail (dot) com. Anyone else who wants to know too.

As someone who has had a baby in the last decade, I can tell you that you might have more trouble finding real talcum powder than neem oil. It's highly unsafe to be inhaled regularly, and all the companies I'm aware of have switched to corn starch!


 o
RE: Lily problem

  • Posted by pudge 2/3 Sask (My Page) on
    Sat, Jun 29, 13 at 23:33

I dread finding any sign of these beetles - nothing so far in my yard and i did a pretty good check today. Sorry that you have to deal with that, Gil. I wondered what Lilynook had to say about it all - here's their suggestions

Here is a link that might be useful: Lilynook


 o
RE: Lily problem

They destroyed most of my lilies last summer. I have a few left and am hand-picking the beatles and grubs each day. I intend to plant more lilies this fall and will patrol them like a soldier next summer!


 o
RE: Lily problem

Has anyone tried food grade diatomaceous earth for these or other problem bugs? f

SCG


 o
RE: Lily problem

Hi,
I tried diatomaceous earth earlier in the spring. I spread it all around each clump of lilies as they were coming up. I don't know how it worked really. We have found many lily beetles-the first in April as I was raking off the leaves. We have been vigilant looking for them. Now we are finding the larvae. I am sure we knocked them back somewhat with our picking but my clumps of lilies are so large and thick( and in the middles of daylily display beds) that it is impossible to see all of the eggs that might have been laid.
But if you look for larvae each day you will find many of them before they chew up the whole plant. Just look for leaves that have been chewed back to the stalk. With the beetles I look for plants that have holes in the leaves. If there are damaged plants you can bet there is a beetle there.
What bothers me the most with red lily beetles is they never seem to stop over the summer. We are finding some more adults now. Their life cycle doesn't seem to end as summer continues. I don't know if these new adults have flown in from somewhere else. I can't see that they would be hatching from the earth at this point.
It is very frustrating to have to start again with the adults while you are still finding larvae! And not so easy as when your lilies(and everything else) was just emerging from the ground.
I know people who have had success with a mouth wash solution but with how large my over 70 clumps are and with how much rain we have gotten this year I just don't have the time for spraying. If I had fewer lilies I would definitely try it.
Debbie


 o
RE: Lily problem

Debbie,

I am sorry to hear about your infestation. Fortunately I only have a few plants and they haven't been reported this far west, YET. *edit*---- dang they are not very far from me now, possibly here.

From research inspired by this thread I am am looking into neem oil to have on hand.

Good luck

SCG

This post was edited by SouthCountryGuy on Mon, Jul 1, 13 at 22:37


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Far North Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here