Return to the Fragrant Plants Forum | Post a Follow-Up

A plea to all the nurserymen that sell us gardenias!

Posted by meyermike_1micha 5 (My Page) on
Sat, May 2, 09 at 23:12

Please, we know your out there, looking at our posts, probably laughing at all the problems we have with our denias and the reasons why we fail...fortuante to have the key to beautiful denias, so if our fail, we will run out and buy another.
Do you really want us to be sucessful at the ones we buy from you, or hope we will never find out the great fertilizer you use,or your secret to the beatiful denias so ours will fail, just to make more profit from us? So if we fail such as I, or mersiepoo, we will buy another such as I have today!

Please, I am begging you, tell us what you do to keep the denias you sell us in containers so green and in big bloom..PLEASE! My denia I bought today has 4 HUGE blooms and is very green. It is rootbound too...I know you have been growing this one in a container for quite sometime...

It is not as if they were just thrown in a pot and shipped to sell with in days of being pulled from the ground to sell off to the mat

SO PLEASE, if you are a container gardenia nursery seller, please help us out here, and tell us what you feed your denias to keep them so healthy, until we get them to our homes, only just to see them deteriate...or not look as vibrant.
Or,,,,,, is it not the fertilzer that is the culprit, but a "contolled temperature enviroment" that does the trick?
Oh well, lets see how long before I get yellow leaves and a sick plant again....

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: A plea to all the nurserymen that sell us gardenias!

it's likely that their growing conditions are not indoors so, container or no, they produce plants for the market outside and in quite different conditions than what you are trying to do.
probably nothing more than regular water and fertilizer, perfect lighting and warmth. i've seen zenobia pulverulenta and franklinia altamaha growing on the hot, black tarps in baking sun at a local nursery and, as soon as i take them home and plant them in perfectly natural growing conditions, they croak!
you may have to resign yourself to treating them as annuals as they are not the best candidates for cold-climate indoor culture, esp. based on what i read on this forum.
they are quite common in zone 8 but i don't know if i would try to overwinter them inside if i had to. if it's any consolation, most of the highly fragrant lilacs don't prosper here in our heat but many of us wish they were as easy as the gardenias. ;-)

RE: A plea to all the nurserymen that sell us gardenias!

You know,,,you're right!

If I can make a few last through the winter, then that is something to be greatful for.
I suppose if I had a year round greenhouse with all the perfect enviromental factors needed for them, I would consider them perenials.

Since I do not, then I will have to look at them as annuals, and if my miracle, a perenial when they make it through our harsh winters.

You shouild smell all my huge awsome lilacs right now. Thanks for your insight!


P.S. I guess barely any nursery owners frequent here.......They should to see what we are all saying, and share their sucess, unless they do come here, and decide to add nothing to this forum.....

RE: A plea to all the nurserymen that sell us gardenias!

Vinegar...Yup that is what it is....;-)

RE: A plea to all the nurserymen that sell us gardenias!

All my gardenias pretty much croak by late winter too. I am going to buy a heating mat this year, and I am also going to put a bunch of lights on the thing too, if I had had more light and heat I know my gardenia would have survived. And no I'm not in denial, ha ha! It had one big fat bud that was near the light bulb. If it hadn't gotten throw off the deck, it may have even BLOOMED! Ya, ha ha ha!!!

RE: A plea to all the nurserymen that sell us gardenias!

meyermike, i'm glad someone else thought to ask the nursery people about this. there must be something we're missing, since the plants i buy are always dark green and full of big fat flowerbuds. i brought one home two days ago and put it in a bigger pot and the buds dropped off 36 hours later. grrrrr! maybe i shouldn't have moved it into the bigger pot?

and jeff al, i feel your pain too. how can mine be so fussy here, and yet last summer i saw one going crazy in the parking lot of a green mill restaurant?! i know the cooks aren't taking time out from flipping pizzas to give it miracid.

RE: A plea to all the nurserymen that sell us gardenias!

I am not a nursery guy and I do not have any magical answers for you but some trial and error learning that took me a few years (I would say I killed a few hundred over time -- that I am willing to admit to). I am a simple country gardener and I grow them outside in Zone 6, so I have no tips for container growers. I also do not grow the hothouse variety because of my zone, those are the ones you get around Easter.

Yes I know they say it's 'iffie' here as prennial but someone should have told me that many years and plants ago.

My rule is the first year is a wash do not expect anything but stimulate the root growth. Remember when planting it is a wood plant so treat it like a bush your transplanting... this was my hardest lessen. You have to sacrifice the first year you plant it of great flowers if you want it to stay alive, acclumate and grow its roots. At least in my zone.

I plant mine where they get sun a good portion of the day but not all day and I have learned to keep them near the light post or garden lights. We have an outside air conditioner/ heater which blows hot air when running... They really love it near there.

I cut them back when I cut my roses back in the late fall using the same rule... anything smaller than the width of a pencil.

The other things I do: I plant hostas at their base to suck up too much water, we have clay soil so I plant them on a slight mound with rocks under for drainage and mine seem to really like coffee and flat soda in the summer. Oh I also keep them in the same bed I have my lenten roses, I find that if the lentens can come up in the winter then that part of the soil is not too frozen.

My oldest one is around 8 or 10 years old but it has had many offspring. Hope this helps someone.

Now if I could just grow a peonie..... :-(

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Fragrant Plants Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here