Return to the Harvest Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Can I safely substitute zucchini for cucumbers in this recipe?

Posted by jbmag Kansas (My Page) on
Sun, Jul 11, 10 at 18:01

I have an abundance of zucchini this year and found a recipe for dill zucchini pickles that doesn't include sugar (we don't like "sweet" pickles). It's awful! The texture of the zucchini was great, though, so I was wondering if I could safely substitute the zucchini for cucumbers in my favorite dill pickle recipe.

This is the brine:

2 c white vinegar - 5%
6 c water
1/3 c pickling salt

I pack cucumbers into the jar with a dill head and a garlic clove and pour the brine over the top. BWB for ten minutes.

My concern is that most recipes I find for zucchini pickles has a 1:1 ratio of vinegar and water. I will be using a 1:3 ratio in this recipe.

Thanks for the advise!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Can I safely substitute zucchini for cucumbers in this recipe

Sorry, no. That recipe is not safe for any type of pickle. That is a really old recipe based on vinegar that was as much as 40 % acidity. Nowdays we use 5% acidity and brine must be at least half vinegar to water ratio. Anything less can lead to botulism. Some cheap vinegars and rice vinegars are only 4 %.
So, if you will use half 5 % acidity vinegar,half water, and then use the salt, dill, and garlic, and process for 10 min. you will be fine. Then you can use for both cukes and zucchini.


 o
RE: Can I safely substitute zucchini for cucumbers in this recipe

It's always a big help to provide sources for recipes. Otherwise we have to ask and wait or search to determine if it's safe-tested or not.

I see that dill pickle recipe is posted as an old favorite on the University of Minnesota Extension site, but they strongly caution that this is a recipe with less tolerance for acidity alterations, that jars should NOT be overpacked with cucumbers for the same reason and that processing times and temperatures (for Minnesota altitudes only) must also be properly controlled and monitored to be certain of sufficient heat treatment to kill spoilage microorganisms.

Basically that tells me this is a recipe with no margin for error in acidity, density or processing. I'm already uncomfortable with this pickle; I wouldn't consider subbing or changing anything.

My personal recommendation is to forget the zucchini. If you make the cucumber dills, be sure you're precise at every stage of the process.

Carol

Here is a link that might be useful: Minnesota Method Dills with Cautions


 o
Second Response

Linda_Lou, we cross-posted. It surprised me that this recipe specifies 4-6% vinegar, which makes it even more "interesting."

Carol


 o
RE: Can I safely substitute zucchini for cucumbers in this recipe

Thanks so much for the advise. I think I'll try Linda's suggestion and increase the vinegar so it's half and half.

Appreciated!
jennifer


 o
RE: Can I safely substitute zucchini for cucumbers in this recipe

If you find the pickles are a little more sour than you care for, you can always add just a "pinch" of sugar after opening.

Also, apple cider vinegar is less harsh, though it may slightly darken the pickling solution.

Carol


 o
RE: Can I safely substitute zucchini for cucumbers in this recipe

FWIW - I bought a package of the Mrs. Wages Kosher Dill Pickles Mix. The recipe on the back says to use:

3-1/3 cups white vinegar (5% acidity)
7-1/3 cups water
1 pkg Mrs. Wages Kosher Dill Pickle Mix

It goes on to say that if more liquid is needed use a ration of 1:2 vinegar:water.

So is this recipe safe? I always assumed you needed equal parts vinegar/water. I didn't read the pkg before purchase. And I was planning on making zucchini dills.


 o
RE: Can I safely substitute zucchini for cucumbers in this recipe

Yes, the Mrs. Wages recipes packets are safe because they have added citric acid in the mix. They are fully acidified. The addition of citric acid is what allows for the lower ratio of vinegar to water in packaged mixes and in commercially canned pickles.

Dave


 o
RE: Can I safely substitute zucchini for cucumbers in this recipe

That information is 10 years old.. Plus, we are not thrilled with the Minnesota methods. They did their own independent study. As you can see, they do not meet USDA guidelines for safety.
I sure would not trust them. Not knowing what I have studied about botulism.
Check the package of Mrs. Wages and see if it has citric acid added. I do agree, I use cider vinegar due to the more mild flavor.


 o
RE: Can I safely substitute zucchini for cucumbers in this recipe

Yeah I have never understood why the Minnesota extension's methods have never been updated to keep up with the times. All the other state extension's have kept current but it is as if MN is determined to be the last hold out of the 30's and 40's. They have several different recipes on their website that I sure wouldn't touch!

And yes, Mrs. Wages lists the citric acid on the package ingredients, or always has in the past. I haven't bought any packs this year to check if it is still there yet as I'm still using up last year's packets. It is in them.

Dave


 o
RE: Can I safely substitute zucchini for cucumbers in this recipe

Thanks. I just read the Mrs. Wages packet - and yes, citric acid is listed as the last ingredient. We also have maltodextrin and "spice extractives". Salt and garlic are the only ingredients I can readily identify!

This was definitely an impulse purchase on my part.


 o
RE: Can I safely substitute zucchini for cucumbers in this recipe

It sounds like the Minnesota site is making a concession to canners who insist on making this old recipe. I don't know how stringent their testing is, but their language makes it very clear that there is no margin for error and it is a risk.

Pixie_Lou, while it is generally true that pickling recipes require a minimum of 1:1 vinegar to water, there are some safe-tested recipes that don't meet that minimum. You have to consider the source.

For example, this NCHFP recipe for Fresh-Pack Dills calls for 2 quarts of water to 1 1/4 quarts of vinegar. So there are exceptions. It's one of the more confusing aspects of canning.

Carol

Here is a link that might be useful: NCHFP Fresh-Pack Dills


 o
RE: Can I safely substitute zucchini for cucumbers in this recipe

I highly recommend that you all get yourself the most current USDA guidelines, The Ball Blue Book, and So Easy To Preserve.
Please read my message about the Univ. of Georgia. There is NO money to fund this any longer. They are doing all they can just to keep the website information online.


 o
RE: Can I safely substitute zucchini for cucumbers in this recipe

  • Posted by jbmag Kansas (My Page) on
    Mon, Jul 12, 10 at 22:41

One more quick question. . . if I use Linda Lou's suggestion and go half and half with the water and 5% vinegar, can I mess with the spices a little? Specifically, can I add cayenne pepper to the brine before pouring it over the packed zucchini, garlic clove and dill head?

Appreciate the advise! I'm always nervous about deviating from a canning recipe. The consequences could be scary!


 o
RE: Can I safely substitute zucchini for cucumbers in this recipe

There's no problem with adjusting amounts of dried spices, herbs, peppers.

Carol


 o
RE: Can I safely substitute zucchini for cucumbers in this recipe

The Minnesota site is old ! That is always something to check, the date of the information.
You can add as many and different dried things as you want, as long as you are not adding fresh things, it is fine.


 o
RE: Can I safely substitute zucchini for cucumbers in this recipe

That Minnesota site may be old, but I found the same recipe on sites from Michigan, Ohio, Florida, Maine, Pennsylvania, North Carolina, New Mexico. I quit searching at that point, but I'm sure there are more. Two sites were updated in 2008 and one in 2009. None except Minnesota offered the cautions I quoted, which actually makes them more safety-aware than comparable sites.

So it's understandable that home food processors would trust a USDA recipe (albeit an old one), posted on Extension/University authorized sites and offering recent revision dates.

Carol


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Harvest Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here