Return to the Herbs Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

Posted by tomatotomata 10 (My Page) on
Sun, Feb 24, 13 at 15:12

I've been persuaded by knowledgeable voices here to grow only one plant per pot. Basil is a given, but what else? There are just too many choices! What would be your choice?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

I suppose it depends on what you use most for cooking. For me, it would be basil (of course), thyme and sage. Chives or Rosemary would come in close to tie with sage (both grow well in ground for us), and I have become very fond of tarragon. I have become so dependent on having fresh herbs I would have a hard time choosing just three. Thyme is so useful, surely it deserves to be second after #1 basil :~).


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

Since we moved a year ago these are what I have replaced: Parsely, Bay laurel, thyme, rosemary, oregano, mint, Lemon verbena, and chives; so I guess these are what I really do use for everyday cooking. I have all of these in large pots in sunny spots.


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

Rosemary and Dill, in that order.

I couldn't decide on a third herb -- I like several, can't settle. But why limit yourself? Get many pots! Haha.

In this year, I will triple my herb varieties for my balcony garden. I have limited space but dangit, I'll find a way. Is there a reason why you're limited to three pots?


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

I assume you are looking for culinary herb choices? Because there are a wealth of "herbs" used for dyeing, medicinal use, utilitarian uses, etc.

If speaking only culinary use: sage, angelica, parsley or basil (toss up).

Sage - beautiful blooms/foliage, culinary & medicinal use, perennial, hardy, “Cur moriatur homo cui Salvia crescit in horto?” [trans. “why should a man die while sage grows in his garden?”]

Angelica - so beautiful. I tend not use it as much as just admire it. Culinary and medicinal uses.

Toss up between basil and parsley - both tasty and easy to grow. Parsley medicinal as well as culinary.

FataMorgana


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

I'd grow the ones that are pricier to purchase. Arugula would probably my #1, followed by shiso (also ridiculously pricey for a small bunch of leaves ~ maybe 8?) and then green onions. The latter, I have my own issue with solely because in Asian markets in SoCal, I bought them for 10-15 for $1 whereas in SF, it's over a dollar for ONE. Combined with how easy it is to grow and the overall cost savings, I think I'd choose these three.

But like others have said - it depends entirely on what you cook with and/or eat a lot of, in conjunction with your zone and what you can make thrive, I guess.


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

The easiest ones. For me that would be bay, rosemary and mint. But I would miss sage, thyme and parsley. Sadly Basil is not easy here. I never buy any herbs so if I can't grow it I don't use it.


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

Sage, lovage, rosemary


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

I do not know about Lovage, will it grown in our warm climate? Maybe as an annual in the fall like Florence Fennel? Mint needs a moist area here in Texas but seems to do well in large enough pots, but needs to be used or it will get leggy and woody. Sweet and Thai Basil does fine in our area, in fact I am still waiting to see if my Thai Basil has lived thru our winter season. Sage seems to do fine here also. A Bay tree would need a large pot after a few years. As for Thyme I keep looking for one that will not just up and die off, maybe in pots it would do better? I have even stuck Lemon Grass almost anywhere and it does fine under almost any conditions but gets to be a large bushy plant on one year. Your cooking habits should decide what you will chose to grown.
Happy gardening.
Paul
As everyone has


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

Rosemary, garlic chives, sage for the criteria of year-round harvesting, and the food grilling purposes. :)


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

Oregano(per.), Thyme(per.), Savory(ann/per.).

Things like chives, parsley, mint, basil, ..often available in stores. And I have never liked rosemary that much. I have sage, but rarely use it.
Other than Rosemary, I have the rest of them in my garden plus shiso, lemon balm, lemongrass, marjoram, leeks, chinese celery, mints ...


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

Hi. Been there in the past when I had to limit myself to "the bare minimum" in potted plants. Here's what I think: What the other folks are saying about what you go to first when cooking; is what you should grow. I also say, go one step further and ask yourself, "What am I too lazy to run out to the store for in the last minute?" Some of the herbs that I grow were a direct result from that last thought. I found myself running out just to buy one item--usually a herb...And always something that won't keep fresh over a few days. My go to herbs are often: Ginger, long green onion (always a great substitute when out of regular onion), and basil.
Good luck!


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

My ranking is first mint, second sage, and third lovage.


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

I would choose Mint (I currently have 37 varieties), Lemon or Lime Balm, and Basil


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

I would choose the ones I use most and enjoy the most in cooking. That would probably be basil, hot spicy oregano, and either German thyme or dill. I probably use dill more often, but enjoy the thyme more when I use it. :)

The only herbs I grow and virtually never use are sage and stevia.


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

Basil, Oregano, and Thyme.
Mint falls in fourth place. It would be hard to live without mojitos.


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

I love basil - but since it's an annual, it's a pain to have to keep replanting.

Is there some trick I'm missing?


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

River_City, you have to replant it yearly, but I cut mine back (AKA big harvest) a few times a year and it lasts until the first frost.


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

  • Posted by batya Israel north 8-9-10 (My Page) on
    Sat, Oct 5, 13 at 3:28

basil, lemon verbena, rosemary

then mint, Syrian hyssop (za'atar), which grows wild here but I love it in my garden, wormwood, yarrow....

Don't think I can limit myself to three!


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

I have several I couldn't be without any

mint easy grown good in tea's but main reason I grow it my bearded dragon eats it so its free dragon food to me.

rosemary - one I always loved always thought of this as the basic herb to grow with sage parsley and thyme.

Bay - king of herbs to me no bay I'd stop even if I don't use it daily.

They are all there for a job I don't think you can choose only 3 for eg if you were making curry you can hardly put basil in it rather than coriander.

the 3 things you cook most will depend on what your favorite 3 are


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

River_city, there is a variety called pesto perpetuo that is supposed to be perennial. I believe it's a new hybrid. At least it is something I only recently learned about. I can't vouch for it, but I am going to try it!

Angie


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

Wow - I love this thread. Someone from Israel, and then UK!

Thanks for the tip HotHabaneroLady (whoa what a name!) - I just ordered a couple pots.

I'm addicted to rosemary - currently have about a dozen varieties, and just planted another today (santa barbara). Try a rosemary cocktail sometime....


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

Rosemary, sage, and thyme


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

Rosemary, Bay Laurel, and lavender.

If I could get a forth, it would be lemon verbena.


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

That's one large, nice looking bay laurel for zone 7. No problems overwintering lemon verbena outside in your zone? Is it grown against the house?


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

Interesting preferences. Sage, Thyme, Rosemary, Basil, Mint are among the most popular.
But nobody (except me) mentioned SAVORY. I think it is not know to most people. But it is the "FIVE SPICE" of the herbs. It has a little bit from, Thyme , Oregano , Tarragon and Rosemary. Its aroma is as long lasting as Thyme's. There are two kinds: summer and winter savory.
Then I have never ever grown and used LOVAGE. I will try it next year.


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

River City, I have overwintered lemon verbena onside before successfully, but currently have mine containerized. Yes, there are several bay bushes planted on the west side of the house, but white foundation keeps it relatively cool. When I grew them in pots, they never grew--they are trees after all, and my theory is that many people who grow them in pots are underplanting them grouping them with such herbs as parsley or oregano.


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

Basil, Basil, and Basil....

(and Rosemary and Sage probably)


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

joppa -i was going to say that too. basil was my first gardening success and im in love with it now!

but if i could only do one basil, my other choices would probably be rosemary and dill. i love mint also but dont use it often. i use rosemary and dill pretty regularly.


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

Sweet marjoram, peppermint and lemon verbena. I love them for their fragrance.


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

Fennel, garlic, and parsley are my go-to herbs. I was going to say cilantro but since the part I grow and use it for is a spice (coriander), it doesn't really count on this list.

Rodney


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

Rodney,

I also use garlic more than any herbs. But the thing is that it is readily available and if you plant it , you harvest it at one point.
So to me,, garlic is not an herb garden herb, just like onion.

Now you can pick another herb while you enjoy garlic too: LOL


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

Basil, Rosemary and Greek Oregano

I use Basil in everything and it would cost too much to purchase it at the store. I used to have almost every flavor but not after my room-mate did not tend to them most of the summer. Greek Oregano because 9f it's beauty and great aroma and Rosemary because it cooks well with all the chicken and turkey I am suppose to eat. I have a rosemary that is 5' tall and 7' wide. The more I cut it the more it grows. Ted did not manage to kill this.


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

To eat...dill, basil, spearmint.

In the garden (with my roses) lavender, catmint, bee balm :)


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

After years of growing various herbs, thyme is the one that has always been dependable, available, and trouble free, as long as I grow it in a pot in adequate sun. I have never been left without it when I go to make my favorite spaghetti sauce. (I can't say the same for oregano, despite its cooperative growth and overwintering abilities).

Lemon verbena, despite its weediness, would be my second pick, as I am never without a healthful tea as long as it is anywhere on my property.

Since it is so helpful in chest congestion, which is a recurrent concern for me, white horehound is my third must-have herb. Since it can be used in candy (it is very bitter otherwise), I guess it can skitter into the culinary category. I have had it overwinter in the same large pot on the north side of my home for two winters now with minimal attention.

The above are the ones I have always been able to rely on; the least demanding, and the most useful to me. They have never died on me from lack of attention or hardiness, or from insect damage. I love basil and cilantro, but have had little luck with them, as they sicken and die on me because I cannot provide enough sun or consistent moisture. Sage grows well for me, but I have found that it is almost as good dried as fresh, and can be purchased in large amounts for use in tea fairly economically. Bee balm comes back for me, but I hesitate to harvest my little stand of it for fear it will give up and not come back at all; additionally, in its early growth it greatly resembles the poisonous snakeroot, which some birds have sowed in my garden. Lovage grew well for me the first year I planted it, but never again. I live close enough to several grocery stores to purchase as much celery as I want whenever--and celery is a staple that stores well.
Etc.


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

French tarragon, sweet marjoram, and true chives.

For me tarragon is an absolute must in salad dressing and it is rather expensive.

As it happens I do have four biggish pots of tarragon permanently outside in my little garden, since, as I grow it, tarragon is not very vigorous and I want to be sure to have enough. But I still end up using a lot of dried, store-bought tarragon.

I have yet to crack the secret of tarragon cultivation. It thrived for my mother in the ground in neutral soil in Pennsylvania. She had sufficient quantities to be able to use it lavishly in cooking. Her garden was also cooler and breezier than mine is in the summer. Come to think of it, her soil was more clay than sandy, too, but basically just good.

Harold McGee, the food scientist, says that the flavor of tarragon, which is related to anise, changes when you combine it with food, into something different and wonderful (fennel does the same thing). He says basil has the same chemical -- though it tastes quite different to me -- not as peppery.

Two other musts are chervil and summer savory, the bean herb. These are hard to find and delicious fresh.

Of course I do grow parsley and basil and would grow dill if it were more tolerant of my urban summer heat. But you can also easily get these in the store.


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

Just looking at google books, I see that tarragon is an alpine type plant that is said to thrive at temps between 40-60 degrees!

Definitely a cool weather plant, by preference, like so many desirable things, including chervil and watercress. Oh, well. I keep trying.


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

A couple of things, Monarda. Tarragon isn't related to Anise. It just has a similar flavour. The former is in the Asteraceae and the latter is in the Apiaceae. And I'm not sure what your source means by an Alpine plant. It is native to dry semi arid soils which doesn't sound Alpine to me. And I'm sceptical about its being a cool weather plant. Here we are advised to grow it in a warm sunny position. Can you share your reference?


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

When I think of alpine, I think of a mountainous environment. Somewhat dry, rocky, kind of poor soils. Sunny but moderate temps during the day with cooler nights. At least during the summer.

Now whether tarragon is an alpine plant, I haven't a clue.

Rodney


 o
RE: If you could only grow 3 herbs, what would you pick?

Well, my source didn't say Alpine, exactly, it said "grows best at temperatures between 45 and 60 degrees." (Thereabouts.)

I have seen sources saying it comes from Siberia. Whether this is correct I can't really say. I also saw a source that said it grows well in the North American Midwest in soil that is arid on top and moist way below -- so the roots have to quest for it. That would be prairie conditions, no?

I believe it will withstand some heat in the right conditions. Some people also say they have success in a deep pot. My mother's were grown on a hillside and did very well.

My plants hang in there, but aren't especially vigorous. I think the problem is the bouts of extreme heat and unrelenting humidity we get here probably. I bet out on Long Island they would do much better, because the nights there are cooler and more refreshing, however hot it gets during the day.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Herbs Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here