Who did you purchase it from? Could they have sold you the wrong one? It looks like H. "Lemon Lime" to me. (I've including a pic of my "Lemon Lime" for comparison.)

Hmm, could this be the baby's "terrible twos?" ;)

Kidding of course. Whatever it is, it's cute...very spunky!

I guess it could have been mislabled - but still, I think it looked right last year (mostly?). Its just kind of weird.

Yes, it was mislabeled. The newest growth last year was showing that the plant had longer, elongated leaves. Some of the leaves also had some variegation last year. The plant was just so immature that it sort of looked a little like Baby Bunting, but now that it has another year of growth it was definitely something else.

It looks like Hosta 'Lemon Delight' with some 'Lemon Lime' reversions. Or it was 'Lemon Lime' with some sporting to a plant like 'Lemon Delight'.

To me, it looked like it was beginning to sport last year. Love the new look (even better than Baby Bunting). Enjoy it, and if it stays so wiggly-cute for a few more years, you can name it and register it.... if that sport to Baby Bunting hasn't already showed up and been registered. Cool!

-Babka

Can I also say that I love your idea of labeling your hostas on rocks with a sharpie?! May have to do this!

Thanks - these hostas keep me learning! I can see it does look like Lemon Lime - very nice hosta also....
I am liking its pretty ruffles better than Baby Bunting I think.
So, Schiba, I guess one of the cool things about the rocks is I can turn it over and write a new name on the back! All my rocks are from Lake Ontario - my son brings them home everytime we go up to the lake. I needed something to do with them!
I do need to get some sealant to put on them though - the sharpie wears off without it.