Return to the Hosta Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Demo of tree root strangulation invasion

Posted by hostahillbilly Zone 4 (My Page) on
Wed, Jun 27, 12 at 21:53

Earlier today I pried out a few of the 'red-flagged' hostas here at Hosta Hills.

Here's a shot of the tree roots from two small hostas that I dragged out of the Hosta roots from these two small plants.

For size comparison, I left my very large size garden gloves hanging off the front of the wheel barrow containing the tree roots removed:
TreeRootStrangulation2012-06-27_15-25-10_355

fwiw,

hh


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Demo of tree root strangulation invasion

tree root invasion sucks lol


 o
RE: Demo of tree root strangulation invasion

So what are the signs of "tree root strangulation?"

What kind of tree was that?

Deanna


 o
RE: Demo of tree root strangulation invasion

Deanna,

First, a Hosta that grew better for a few years, then began to diminish, and in the last few years, it may diminish DRAMATICALLY FAST.

So if you see one getting smaller, after only one or two or three years, it may SUDDENLY be so small that you don't even recognize it.

I really should look through pics and try to document this, but haven't, sorry.

With the vigor of this group, there may already be good documentation of this (one of the few) Hosta problem, so perhaps others will provide links to past threads, or . . .

If not, I will try to expand the informaton about this.

YAY, IT's SUMMER,

hh


 o
RE: Demo of tree root strangulation invasion

here is a pic of silver maple.. during a septic field rebuild.. at the neighbors ...

i wonder what soil that grass is growing in .. the sand above the grass was from the backhoe ... you can see the sparse grass.. best.. over to the right ...

ken
Photobucket


 o
RE: Demo of tree root strangulation invasion

Last year I dug up my 'Sagae' (planted in 2007) because it was still really small. Its roots were huge but since it was competing with a lot of tree roots there was hardly any top growth on the hosta. I removed the tree roots and added compost, bonemeal and a handful of alfalfa pellets to the plant hole and replanted 'Sagae'. At the time I thought that if I provided more fertilizer and more regular water the hosta would grow better because 'Sagae's roots were massive. This year I found improved top growth but am now wondering whether I should relocate it in the fall. I seem to remember that franknjim had success with tree root competition and that he watered his hostas even when it was raining.

HH, how big were the roots on the hostas that you dug out?


 o
RE: Demo of tree root strangulation invasion

That picture is really worth a thousand words! It shows a real cutaway not a drawing. If even grass has a hard time finding a hold, not just because of shade but root competition, what chance do plants have with more top growth to sustain!! Wow. Nice one.


 o
RE: Demo of tree root strangulation invasion

irawon, the roots were, as usual, about the same size as the above ground foliage, though sometimes much, much larger, as in the size the plant originally attained.

Earlier today I managed to find the time to find yet another 'red-flagged' plant and took this picture:
RootBoundSilverbowl2012-06-28_13-04-03_766

Besides that it has shrunk for the past couple of years (photographically documented), Note the following:

The color is much paler than normal for this plant.

Observe the asymmetric leaf pattern: the size of some leaves are notably wider on one side of the center rib. This is VERY characteristic of this problem!

Often, and this is a perfect example (see HL), the plant bears little (and in this case NO) resemblance to a healthy one.

Finally, note the tip of the leaves curling back under the leaf.

BTW, this is (was for the time being) H. Silver Bowl.

hth,

hh


 o
RE: Demo of tree root strangulation invasion

Thanks for the lesson, HH. Very helpful.

Steve


 o
RE: Demo of tree root strangulation invasion

Yes, hh, this thread, and especially that last picture, was very, very helpful.


 o
RE: Demo of tree root strangulation invasion

HH, thanks for the info. I know now what to look for in hostas I have planted in an area with a lot of root competition.


 o
RE: Demo of tree root strangulation invasion

Came across another dramatic example of tree root strangulation invasion found here amongst the Red Pine Trees.

H. 'Beauty Substance' before:
BeautySubstance2012-06-30_12-36-34_183

after:
RootBoundBeautySubstance2012-06-30_12-30-55_653

I'm embarrassed that I let it get this far, but we have enough of this cultivar elsewhere that I decided there were more pressing matters.

Those leaf tips are not cut off. They're curled under themselves, a symptom I noted earlier.

fwiw,

hh


 o
RE: Demo of tree root strangulation invasion

Myrle has had the same experience with roots but from Cedar trees. She has had the expense of purchasing grow bags after all the work of digging them out and getting the roots separated , Not a nice job. We were at our daughter's place in Arizona where they had just purchased a home and all the sewage lines had to be dug up and replaced and these were from the black popular,
They travel to where the water is the most plentiful, i guess.


 o
RE: Demo of tree root strangulation invasion

I have killed at least a dozen Hostas from tree root strangulation before I finally figured out what the problem was....Neighbors behind have mature Douglas Fir trees and both sides have arborvitae hedges. Both will grow roots up into newly worked and amended topsoil.

Clematis and Oriental lilies will both dwindle and die too though there are plants that will live with the trees...

The roots spread at least ten feet for the hedges and twenty or more for the trees :( basically they take up our entire back yard. I had no idea when we bought the house.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Hosta Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here