I didn't take Latin...but refer to Latin names for perennials to ensure I get the right one....I thought when there are two ii's together in a word e.g. Paniculata 'Davidii'... they are pronounced separately ... one short, the other long....is that correct, Jadie?
Totally right, Jo! at the end of a word ii denotes a plural, and the i's are pronounced as you said. The tricky thing is that in the middle of a word, two i's together are both short, but they break syllables. Its that a after the ii that throws me off though...usually you'd see another consonant, which makes the syllable break easier to say.
One thing for sure, I would never have guessed this was the name of a hosta! :)
Totally right, Jo! At the end of a word ii denotes a plural, and the i's are pronounced as you said. The tricky thing is that in the middle of a word, two i's together are both short, but they break syllables. Its that a after the ii that throws me off though...usually you'd see another consonant, which makes the syllable break easier to say.
One thing for sure, I would never have guessed this was the name of a hosta! :)
Ohigan Giboshi is it's Japanese name, might be able to find it by that. I looked briefly but didn't see a source. I'm busy, got boxes with hostas in them to open!
As long as you are not pronouncing latin names in American English, you are correct. I often get in trouble when I pronounce a latin conifer name like I think it should be (coming from Europe) in an American nursery. Bernd
Stopped by OBrien's Hosta gardens in North Granby, CT today to view some of his mature hostas and he has this plant for sale. It's listed on the website too. www.obrienhosta.com.
Would never have noticed it except for this interesting post about the plant.
We have to take all Latin pronounciation rules with a bit of salt. In fact, since Latin is a dead language, no one actually knows how it was originally pronounced. We have lots of hints, but the rules were created by scholars.
Unfortunately, more than one set of rules exists. The proper pronounciation is simply whatever a group of people agree to - so groups that use Latin regularly agree on a set of rules.
My brother is a pharmacist. He routinely "mispronounces" Latin when we walk the garden - because the pronounciation the medical community has agreed upon is quite different from the pronounciation used by horticulturalists.
Try Huechera... a Latin professor gave me three alternative pronounciations, all correct depending on who was doing the speaking... and then said a native-Latin speaking Roman would probably look questioningly at all three!
Now Sagae - that's Japanese and there really are rules for how to pronounce that... and yet we refuse to use them... so I've given up on the Latin.
Sometimes common usage rules--even if it isn't technically correct. Like Forsythia--For-seye-thia (after the discoverer, Forsythe)-- or Kalanchoe--Ka-lan-ko-ee, to be correct. But who ever says it that way? Or, who wants to correct anybody, that says it "wrong", lol!
Is it Pee-oh-nee, or Pe-a-ney, or Pie-nee, as my grandmother called it? I think the pronounciation of peony might be regional.
It's interesting to untangle the roots of a Latin or botanical (or any language, for that matter) to see why it's named that (like equinoc-thiana), and to see how the pronounciations and spellings have changed through the years. Sometimes words have startling roots!
Sandy
This post was edited by mosswitch on Sat, Aug 17, 13 at 10:05
josephines167 z5 ON Canada
jadie88
Related Professionals
Tempe Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Birmingham Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Ilchester Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Canyon Lake Landscape Contractors · Mission Bend Landscape Contractors · Pleasant Prairie Landscape Contractors · Reedley Landscape Contractors · Suitland Landscape Contractors · Northlake Landscape Contractors · Campbell Driveway Installation & Maintenance · Albany Fence Contractors · El Monte Fence Contractors · Norwich Solar Energy Systems · Ramsey Solar Energy Systems · Alum Rock Solar Energy Systemsbkay2000
josephines167 z5 ON Canada
jadie88
ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5Original Author
jadie88
mosswitch
ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5Original Author
mosswitch
mosswitch
in ny zone5
bragu_DSM 5
plp1950
idiothe
mosswitch