Return to the Hot Topics Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Should schools supply iPads?

Posted by tobr24u z6 RI (My Page) on
Fri, Feb 15, 13 at 4:57

The wealthiest school system in RI is considering providing them to the few poor kids who don't already have them. It seems that probably 90% already do and thus have a big learning advantage.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

only if you want all children to have the same level playing field.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Quite right, as what is to make them do anything else but play games...


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

if you only knew how much educational software is available on ipads.....

Check out apps on yours to see!!!


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

tobr24u, maybe!
(The) parent(s) have a clear responsibility for their child(ren)'s education.
It is therefore their duty to provide the materials.
A responsibility is discharged only when a duty is performed.
It is human nature to place a higher value on things for which they have to pay money.
It will be a win/win/win situation when the parent has to purchase the item (on a payment plan?); (s)he will ensure that the item is put to good use thereby imbuing the student with a sense of accountability; the school system has one less thing to worry about.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Sure, why not. If it's going to advance their educational goals, sounds like a good idea.

My grandkids are much more proficient on our computers, iPads, eReaders and iPods than most of the people I work with (who can barely understand how to enter data or print an email), It can only be to their advantage in their future.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

But who will pay for the wireless connection in the home?


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Yes.

An ad agency near Columbus just donated 200 iPads to elementary schools in the area.

Those iPadder's are tomorrow's HT crowd. :)


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

You don't need an internet connection to use and learn from installed iPad apps.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

So you are willing to pay for their wireless connection?


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

They don't need a connection. Get a hearing exam. :)


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

So they would be limited to formal instruction? Good luck with that...


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Should schools supply text books?

Should schools supply iPads?

YES


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Richard,

Providing iPads for the children who can't afford them makes the classroom equal and fair.

I say, provide school owned iPads to all students, then nobody can chatter about who is too poor to afford one.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

You can't close the gap unless you take the poor kids out of their environment as going all the way back to Head Start has shown...


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Doesn't need to be an Ipad lots of choice out there that are just as functional for lots less money.

Times are changing, kids who do not have access to technology are seriously disadvantaged. Too bad we don't put as much money into education as we do into running elections........


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Too bad we don't put as much money into education as we do into running elections........

Or football.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Well said brush.....


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Well said brush.....


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Football or basketball may be the only hope for poor kids...


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

It shouldn't be!


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Brush I agree.

tobr there are so few kids that make it to the pros to take them out of poverty so sports are not helpful.

Given the right educational tools we will have more Bill Gates than Star Sports players. If they do not make it to the Gates status they at least will make it to the middle class employable tax payer citizen.

Investment in our young is going to be the best defense we have of not paying higher taxes to support jails, taking away Social Security, Medicare. We need wage earner population to contribute to run the country.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Education is pretty much a middle class value. I'm afraid that the iPad is not the magic wand that many hope it to be...


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Within a few short years, the gap in school quality is going to be determined by which districts can afford iPads and similar devices, and from 4th grade on, individual student computers and high speed internet.

And those schools who can't.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Lessons can be downloaded on snow days. Using a VPN type mode the school could control access.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

I agree David. I know some believe that its just a matter of making the right choices but for some children it will be about the choices that local governments make in terms of funding education......not the choices they make or even their parents make.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

I wonder...
Would it cost less to use iPads instead of textbooks? Hm.

And there is much more one could do. In band, there is an online metronome and tuners. If you wanted to hear how a Latin or French word was pronounced, you just look it up! It's what I do at work (and freetranslation.com too). I could think of endless possibilities. Right now, if son forgets his text book, he can access it online. Seems like one step away from an iPad! And, he has to check out books form the library. There are limited copies. That would end the problem of being last in line and having to find it from another source. This is sounding better all the time!


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

So you are willing to pay for their wireless connection?

My city has free WiFi hot spots. Some areas only allow 4 hours a day other areas no time frame.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Many, many of the apps that run on tablets don't require internet connections . Personally I believe the internet is like basic telephone service and should be part of the basic infrastructure available to all at reasonable prices.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

If they are to only be used in classroom settings for schoolwork the school can set up it's own Educational network & curriculum. Schools could use whatever texts they wished & would no longer be subject to Texas texts books or heavy back packs.
The problem then of royalties becomes a problem as Virtual Texts can be rented but never become as cheap as used text books.

Here is a link that might be useful: weighed down


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

If the school can afford to outfit every student with an Ipad, then yes... why not? It certainly would add to their educational experience.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

tablets don't require internet connections

They will need the connection to download the apps. The Apps could be pre-installed but the connection would be good for research.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

They can do all that at school or in libraries and use the down loaded apps at home.......or they can steal their neighbors wifi network !!!! LOL


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Within a few short years, the gap in school quality is going to be determined by which districts can afford iPads and similar devices, and from 4th grade on, individual student computers and high speed internet.

And those schools who can't.

Therein lies the discrimination and competition between school districts. Competition is okay for sports teams, but not district funds. All schools should receive an equal share. There are millions of smart poor kids who are neglected because they don't attend school in an affluent community.

Of course it's all their fault. :(

For example. The county I left has just invested $3.4 million dollars in a high school football stadium. Just 20 miles east of them, schools were closing due to no funds.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

The problem then of royalties becomes a problem as Virtual Texts can be rented but never become as cheap as used text books.

My DD did 3 years in middle school with a "21st Century" program, using lap tops and the internet. "virtual textbooks" may well exist, but they didn't use them for the very reason of cost - but there is so much other, free content out there that a teacher with reasonable skills can find all kinds of programs and sources.

Brushworks, Colorado continues to cut funding for K-12, and yesterday on the TV news was a segment about how charter schools were now starting to close because of the drop in funding. They used to get about $7,000 per pupil from the state, now its down to $6,500.

Of course, private high schools, with tuitions north of $25,000 a year, are doing fine.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

I do a lot of computer work in low income homes and for low income customers with school age children.

Some of the issues they face is that they're constantly selling their notebooks, netbooks, tablets, iPads, iPods, iPhones when they need cash, these items are often stolen, often damaged, plus not insured or covered by extended warranties.

Rather than using these devices for education, many use them for music, movies, games, chatting etc.

Many have no internet access, or they've had their internet shut-off due to not paying their broadband/cable/phone bill. Many subscribe to internet, phone, cable, satellite, DVR bundles, so their monthly bills are quite high, especially once teaser rates have expired.

Broadband is unavailable in some regions, plus expensive in many regions, especially those only served by DSL.

Many receive internet via prepaid iPhones, or Android phones, however they're often out of minutes, or they don't have the money to renew their plan.

On a positive note, many of the kids that don't have computers, tablets, handhelds and broadband tend to be more physically active and more into outdoor activities.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

If the school supplies the devise, who owns it? Is it a loaner or a gift? If it needs repair, who funds it? If lost or stolen (or sold for cash), who is responsible for replacing it?

Chase, stealing your neighbors wifi is not realistic, most have them locked down.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Mark has anyone ever told you that you could be the Grim Reaper?


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Mark has anyone ever told you that you could be the Grim Reaper?

LOL. No, however I often upset many people due to my strait shooting and/or knowledge of unintended consequences from hands on experience.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Speaking of WiFi leeching, we live, work and travel in few places where there aren't numerous APs that are unsecured, or secured with WEP which many school kids know how to crack.

Many of our relative's and their kids have never paid for internet. They surf the net, watch streaming movies, download movies, games and music, plus run VOIP phones off leeched/hacked or shared connections.

Many run an Alfa Repeater with an Alfa card and/or run Connectify to broadcast the leeched signal to their other notebooks, iPads, iPods, iPhones etc.

They even have some iPhone, iPod, iPad apps to crack WEP.

Many kids share their passwords with others as well.

Some of the war drivers are into more advanced cracking and attacks.

Recently I was working in a small village with 15 unsecured APs viewable with my Alfa USB adapter - 10 of them named Linksys - all on channel 6.

The customer had been connecting to a neighbor's AP for years. They thought Time Warner made a mistake and didn't turn off their internet a couple years ago.

In the cities it's pretty common to see literally dozens of unsecured APs at many locations.

Not only is WEP 100 percent crackable, but many residents use their phone numbers as security keys.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

The way the schools here did it with the 21st Century program was that the kids paid a non-refundable deposit/fee of $50 which would cover most wear-and-tear repairs, but if they broke it and it was obvious that it was the kids fault, the kid bought a new one. If it was abused, the computer had to stay at the school. And if you intentionally trashed one, you were out of the program.

There was a waiting list of 200 kids to get into the program which had space for 100. Due to budget cuts, they had to cut the program in half, down to 50.

There certainly is the risk of kids at home just wasting time on the things. DD15, now in high school, currently has her laptop confiscated due to way too much of that.....


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

I've tried to help many low income customers and relatives by giving them decent newer used notebooks, or netbooks, but the majority of the time they're damaged, stolen or sold.

iPads, iPods and iPhones have an incredibly good resale/barter value in comparison to other electronics, so they're often stolen or sold. These units would last less than a week in many poor urban households.

Many are better off with an older desktop and CRT monitor.

Even many thieves won't steal these units, plus they have a very poor resale value.

They're also less likely to be damaged by dropping, crushing, liquid spills etc.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Kind of hard to carry to & from school!


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Kind of hard to carry to & from school!

It wasn't too long ago that students in a relative's school system could sign out desktops and LCD monitors to take home - Dell Optiplex Slim Towers and Mini Towers with 15 inch LCD Monitors.

Many students had a monitor and peripherals at home, so they only needed the tower.

Many of the computers were sold cheaply, or given to households with needy students.

Many of these units are still in service. I just worked on two in the last month alone that still had the school district tags on them. Someone took a Sharpie and wrote on the inside of the tower "This PC Sucks Donkey Balls".

They used to be pretty slow since they shipped with 128MB Ram.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

  • Posted by RpR_ 3-4 (My Page) on
    Fri, Feb 15, 13 at 15:28

Well about a month ago I went to a store with a younger clerk.

I gave him a half-dollar.

He said, "I have never seen one of these. What is it worth?"

I think it goes way beyond ipads.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

I gave him a half-dollar.
He said, "I have never seen one of these. What is it worth?"

Yet when Preschool is suggested we think the kids need more me time.

Our kids do not need anymore me time. They need education.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

tobr24u, marquest posted "Given the right educational tools we will have more Bill Gates ..."
My question is, what educational tools did Bill Gates have?
His mind.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Bill Gates did not act alone.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Many of the computers were sold cheaply, or given to households with needy students.

Many of these units are still in service. I just worked on two in the last month alone that still had the school district tags on them. Someone took a Sharpie and wrote on the inside of the tower "This PC Sucks Donkey Balls".

*

It may have been an accurate statement, but that's gratitude from the "needy" for you.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

Vandalism, abuse and misuse of PCs were some of the reasons the take-home program was ended.

Besides coming back with damage, many units would come back with porn, illegal music, movies, games, software etc.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

The laptops that they used for the 21st Century program did not have a hard drive or CD/DVD drive, just a usb plug. So no porn, games, or viruses.

So they pretty much did all their work "in da cloud" using Google docs as the main way to save and present their work.

My college going kids also save and back up their work in the cloud as well.

I should also mention that this middle school program made a special effort to enroll the under-served, poor family background, minority kids in the district. They did fine with them as well. The 2 or 3 kids who were trashing the computers and were thrown out had other issues than poverty.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

My question is, what educational tools did Bill Gates have?

The best education money could buy. and....

Wikipedia........
When he was in the eighth grade, the Mothers Club at the school used proceeds from Lakeside School's rummage sale to buy a Teletype Model 33 ASR terminal and a block of computer time on a General Electric (GE) computer for the school's students.[21] Gates took an interest in programming the GE system in BASIC, and was excused from math classes to pursue his interest. He wrote his first computer program on this machine: an implementation of tic-tac-toe that allowed users to play games against the computer.


 o
RE: Should schools supply iPads?

My question is, what educational tools did Bill Gates have?

The best education money could buy. and....

Wikipedia........
When he was in the eighth grade, the Mothers Club at the school used proceeds from Lakeside School's rummage sale to buy a Teletype Model 33 ASR terminal and a block of computer time on a General Electric (GE) computer for the school's students.[21] Gates took an interest in programming the GE system in BASIC, and was excused from math classes to pursue his interest. He wrote his first computer program on this machine: an implementation of tic-tac-toe that allowed users to play games against the computer.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Hot Topics Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here