Return to the Hot Topics Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

Posted by labrea 7NYC (My Page) on
Mon, Feb 27, 12 at 9:41

The Old man is at it again!

The pope is pressing for a ban on artificial procreation and called on science and fertility experts to resist “easy income, or even worse the arrogance of taking the place of the Creator.”

Here is a link that might be useful: Lets Play House


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

Easy income? Taking the place of the Creator? How bizarre. In addition to reproductive organs and a biological drive to have kids, the Creator gave us a brain to figure out stuff. Yet another decree for Catholics to completely ignore.


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

Regretting some life choices, perhaps?

He's old and approaching senility... what does he know. Modern fertility techniques can be awesome.


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

Still, when it comes to the shear lack of common sense, I vote for denouncing the use of condoms in the fight against AIDS in sub-saharan Africa.


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

I have been predicting in my neck of the woods that these sorts of procedures would be next on the right wing radar-there are lots of things doctors do to help women get pregnant and stay pregnant thus interfering with god's intentions-just wait-it wont be just the pope.


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

Now they've totally lost me.

It says this:
"On Saturday, the Pope did offer hope for couples who are struggling to become parents: He said the church encourages medical research on infertility."

Medical reasearch to do what, exactly? If you cannot do anything with the cards you've been dealt (not able to get pregnant without help), what does he mean by that? Medical research to do what???

Totally crazy and ridiculous!


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

Senility..dementia?


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

I'd say more, Lily, but I'd be accused of Christian bashing.

Since when does the Pope rule the world?


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

Medical reasearch to do what, exactly? If you cannot do anything with the cards you've been dealt (not able to get pregnant without help), what does he mean by that? Medical research to do what???

jill in nj,

In answer to your question, the Catholic prohibition is on artificial insemination, in other words the fertilization of an egg outside of a woman's body or delivery of sperm through artificial means. It is not a ban on seeking medical help for infertility.

In other words, the Catholic church supports medical research on raising sperm counts or surgeries to unblock fallopian tubes, that sort of thing. Something that will facilitate fertilization through "natural" methods.

Hope that helps clear things up.


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

Actually, it doesn't mean a thing... unless you follow the dogma. And there's something a little off about a group of males of our species, claiming celibacy, yet dictating the reproductive actions of others.

For a group that can't even keep their own "employees" under control without paying out huge out-of-court settlements to traumatized parishioner families, all the while sweeping madly under rugs and moving their workers all over the planet while in denial... well, something just doesn't sit right.


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

Actually, it doesn't mean a thing... unless you follow the dogma. And there's something a little off about a group of males of our species, claiming celibacy, yet dictating the reproductive actions of others.

I know it doesn't mean anything. I think most people know that I'm not a religious believer of any kind.

I was just clearing up the meaning and intent in Catholic dogma concerning fertility treatments and research... in what jill was asking.

Their prohibition of artificial insemination does not mean a ban seeking help with conceiving a child. It's the methods used which they are concerned with.


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

Not in the dish!


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

  • Posted by vgkg 7-Va Tidewater (My Page) on
    Mon, Feb 27, 12 at 17:08

"The pope is pressing for a ban on artificial procreation"

Tell that to the aliens ;)

Is the Pope competing with Santorum?....maybe the Pope show up at the brokered convention!? Wow what a Show!


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

Thanks for the explanation, hamiltongardener. That does help me understand that at least some methods are ok, in their view.

I just find it amazing that the church can tell a couple that badly wants to have a baby that option 1 and 2 are ok, but option 3 - which may be the only option that works for that couple - is not ok. The church is telling that couple that you cannot use a medical procedure that has proven to work. They are attempting to prevent that couple from bringing a baby into the world that will undoubtably be very loved. I'll just never understand it.


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

I don't get it either, jill.

But I know a number of women who, in spite of being Catholic, have pursued IVF. I know an even larger number of them who use birth control... most of them really.

I don't agree with the church's stance on fertility treatments but just wanted to make sure that people were arguing the matter from an informed stance, not one based on flawed information. There are plenty of reasons to disagree with the dogma without the incorrect info.

Oh, and since I don't think we've met... welcome! Nice to meet you.


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

  • Posted by natal Louisiana 8b (My Page) on
    Mon, Feb 27, 12 at 19:09

From what I understand the majority of Catholic women use some form of birth control.

The leaders are so out of touch with reality. Their parishioners do as they please and ignore the dogma.


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

The politicians utilize the dogma to cherry pick that which they hold sacred & that which they conveniently sidestep!


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

The politicians utilize the dogma to cherry pick that which they hold sacred & that which they conveniently sidestep!

True.

Politicians who trumpet Catholic stance against birth control are the same ones who conveniently forget that the Chuch is also against the death penalty and war.


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

hamiltongardener - thank you for the nice welcome! I've been around GW for a long time, but don't post much over here on HT. Read a lot, but haven't posted much. Thanks again.


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

Welcome Jill!

I don't understand the stand the Catholic church takes on this issue. After all, it is a live child, a child in every biological way, a new little soldier of Christ I would presume, so does the Church look upon the child itself as having a lacking? I don't think so, really. So have the parents committed a Mortal Sin if the Child is accepted and baptised as a Catholic?

It could get confusing. I first heard of the church's stand when a friend of mine (one of the first handful having I.V. in the country in the very early 80's) talked about how awful it really was as a means to having a child, a real emotional roller coaster, but how worth it it all was in the end. She was a Catholic, and after she left, another woman who is a Fundamentalist Catholic (I swear, cultish in nature, won't attend Mass if it's not said in Latin, will not go at all! and years ago, had the fundamentalist priest regularly perform some sort of exorcism over her child (a few words) because the child is very hard to handle. I swear.) Anyway, since she knew I was also a non-practicing Catholic she told me in hushed terms that the child really wasn't considered having a soul by the church because they had the child created instead of making it the natural way.

That was the ickiest conversation I ever had. How I kept a straight face I will never know, but I did my best to divert her attention to 'something shiny' to get her OUT of my face.


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

Wow, Mylab... talk about an uncomfortable conversation. I would have to say the child is fine... but I'm not so sure about the mother...

Yes... welcome, Jill... and anyone else who has recently joined us out in the open! ;-)

Maybe it's just media hype to distract, but it sure seems like every religious wackadoodle on the planet suddenly has the spotlight.

And I would wholeheartedly agree with Labrea... though I don't understand it one bit... cherry picking, indeed! What's the point if you're only going to follow the parts you like and throw out the rest?


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

But wait-in vitro (IVF) and artificial insemination are not the same thing-artificial insemination is the insertion of sperm into the woman artificially( sans penis) and conception takes place inside the woman where as IVF is done in a petrie dish. With AI the sperm can be donor sperm so not the sperm of the married couple..as I have always understood the Catholic church has always been against this procedure as well??


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

But wait-in vitro (IVF) and artificial insemination are not the same thing-artificial insemination is the insertion of sperm into the woman artificially( sans penis) and conception takes place inside the woman where as IVF is done in a petrie dish. With AI the sperm can be donor sperm so not the sperm of the married couple..as I have always understood the Catholic church has always been against this procedure as well??

I'll copy what I posted above...

the Catholic prohibition is on artificial insemination, in other words the fertilization of an egg outside of a woman's body or delivery of sperm through artificial means.

That includes both IVF and AI.

So which part were you unsure of?


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

Sorry HG...I am having connection problems and it is affecting my ability to scroll. I apparently did not read the whole post. I am continually preplexed by the stand of the Catholic church on fertility. I suspect like geocentrism they will find themselves appologizing some day for taking archaic stances on things.


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

I suspect like geocentrism they will find themselves appologizing some day for taking archaic stances on things.

Most likely, yes. And I suspect sometime soon.

Like most religions, Catholic attendance (and therefore donations) is dropping. They will need to start connecting to their congregations more or face losing them.

Adapt or die.


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

O.T. but - I was reading a blog yesterday, written by a self-described conservative Catholic priest about contraception, trying to get an understanding of the Catholic church's prohibitions. (I didn't.) This priest said that, according to Pope Pius VI in 1968 (I believe this is the correct pope) in his encyclical (can't remember nor spell the Latin name), infertile married couples are forbidden from using a condom to prevent a STD. This is insane. No wonder I run into so many "recovering Catholics". The church would prefer that a person get a disease, usually incurable, from their spouse rather than "interfering" with the natural process of sexual intercourse.


 o
RE: Papa Says fertility Treatments Arrogant

I believe that 99 percent of religions have the circus in the background that is hidden from view if possible. It's why the nutty side of the Mormon churchthat has been uncovered dosn't bother me a bit.

What's new about that Name me a church that doesn't have it's circus going on in the background.....just dig long enough, you will find it.

The Catholic church makes the Mormon church sound boring, childish and completely unoriginal in their nutty stuff.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Hot Topics Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here