Return to the Hot Topics Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

Posted by stinky-gardener 7/SouthEastern VA (My Page) on
Tue, Nov 20, 12 at 11:38

I thought it was wonderful! I would love to hear thoughts on the film from those here who have seen it.

I felt DD Lewis was Lincoln! A truly remarkable performance. Spielberg magically creates the 1860's world of heated politics, wheeling & dealing, spinning & compromise. Even though we know how things turn out, suspense nonetheless builds, & we feel the thrill of victory for Lincoln & the life-altering promise of the 13th amendment.

Lewis's nuanced performance offers the rich subtleties of Lincoln's presence- his (usually) quiet, thoughtful, but intensely engaged manner reveals a man who was not only a brilliant orator, but a truly gifted listener.

I left the film impressed (& refreshed) by how bereft of vanity & desire for self-aggrandizement Lincoln was, & how he lived very much in the moment, with a deep appreciation, even a child-like wonder, for the life that unfolded before him.

A crazy quilt patchwork of opportunities & obstacles, passion & steadiness, solitude & relationships, Lincoln is fascinating to catch a glimpse of.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

Thanks for the review; I hope to see it soon.


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

It's on my to see list. Spielberg was in our area yesterday at the Gettysburg cemetery where he was the featured speaker. .


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

I have heard great reviews. It is my must see this Holiday weekend.


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

We also saw it this weekend. An amazing performance by Daniel Day Lewis as Lincoln. Today's politicians wouldn't survive an hour in the rough & tumble House of Representatives of Lincoln's time. Also interesting how the Republicans & the Democrats have pretty much flipped roles since then. Much of the language & terms used were true to the time period so no politically correct, sensitive terminology in the movie.


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

  • Posted by vgkg 7-Va Tidewater (My Page) on
    Tue, Nov 20, 12 at 19:00

We plan to see the movie next week after the crowds settle down a bit, been sell outs here, a big part of which because it was filmed here in Richmond. Can't wait!...but must :(


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

Kicking myself for seeing Bond instead of Lincoln. Much as I love Craig as Bond (looooove it when he winks - might buy the movie just to watch that wink over and over).

Hope I get to see Lincoln. Figures, bunch of good movies out when I have a hard time getting out. Got to see Argo too. It was pretty good. Maybe Bennifer will start making more good stuff.


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

Loved both Argo and Bond. I'll see Lincoln when the crowds die back.


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

Anyone seen Anna Karenina?

I'm spending Thanksgiving with a good friend and she wants to go see it after everyone leaves her house--but so far it's not playing anywhere within driving distance for us.

I don't know about the acting but the visuals look delicious!

We may have to settle for Daniel Craig or hopefully, Daniel Day Lewis.


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

Lincoln was good... lots of awesome action, and a message or two. Expendables 2 was good... more awesome action. I'll have to wait for Bond, but I won't miss it! Bond is my favorite.


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

Anna Karenina has received some pretty bad reviews, e.g. if you loved the book you'll hate the movie (It's my favorite novel), the production is very overdone, and Keira Knightley and the actor who plays Vronsky are not up to their roles. So for us, back to the version with Vivien Leigh.


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

Anna Karenina is my all-time favorite book too. Have not seen either movie - seems few movies do a book justice. Although, Jaws is a favorite book and a favorite movie.


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

Well, Anna Karenina may be a bad movie, but it was a great Charades idea yesterday ... really stumped my neice and ran the other teams time all the way out.

Lincoln wasn't very hard at all though. A gesture indicating a beaver hat was made and it got guessed in like 15 seconds :).


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

I saw the Lincoln movie today and it is impressive in ways that people not sensitive to anachronism wont understand. Lewis was seriously impressive in his role but the supporting cast of congressmen and cabinet members was simply astonishing. The whole thing hung together-literally your were there for a moment in history that has all but been forgetten.


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

I enjoyed it so much, I watched it twice.


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

stinky-gardener, my take-away from the film was Mr. Lincoln's justification for a portrait of George Washington hanging in a bathroom!
PS. At a personal level, as a horticulturist, I find your nom de plume mildly contradictory. There must be a good story behind it. Care to share?


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

I just returned home from seeing Lincoln.

Surprisingly, when leaving I asked my twenty-three year old daughter what she thought of it and she was not particularly impressed.

I felt the same, although the last twenty minutes were better than the first few hours in my opinion.

We agreed that the issues and personalities were much more complex than as presented and the predictable "gotcha"humor" was pandering to the masses.

That being said, I think Mr. Lewis gave an outstanding performance--as did the actor that portrayed General Grant.


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

Please explain"the predictable "gotcha"humor"'.


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

I was wondering about the 'gotcha humor' as well. Me, I was mesmerized by the wallpaper.


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

the predictable "gotcha"humor"'.

*

I was referring to the predicable scenes when the Democrat leaders were "shocked" and outraged when some of their party members voted differently than they anticipated and the predictable smug reactions from the Republicans.

The villian always gets his comeuppance and it's that "gotcha" that seems to be presented the same way in most every film.


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

I'm glad Tony wasn't heavy handed with his 6 year wrangle with the script.
I'll see it on Christmas eve!


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

I did not see the outrage as humor-given the politics of the time and what politics are you would certainly be outraged if a member of your caucus has been 'bought' by the other side. An interesting historical point to me was seeing how that system could be used. The eventual result of all the outrage was the passage of legislation that resulted in taking most federal jobs out of the patronage system. I think it is a weird point that most jobs being taken out of the patronage system was the result of corruption on the part of the office givers-a job could be removed from the system by the president giving someone a life interest in the job so as to prevent the next administration from using it to buy support.

I was amazed by the filming of the interior scenes-rooms and the way people lived in them has changed so much. The background was astonishingly real to the time and would have been very difficult to film.


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

We saw Lincoln this afternoon. Utterly atmospheric...you can practically smell the cigar smoke and the tobacco juice! And the lighting...it's something to see how little indoor light people death with as a matter of course back in those days.
Superb performances! My only complaint: too few scenes with Jared Harris (General Grant.)


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

I haven't seen the movie yet but heard rave reviews. I am interested in seeing how the time period is reflected. I live in a pre -civil war house with pre -civil war furnishings. I want to check for inaccuracies, but I'm sure they had many consultants on this movie to get it right.

The owner of my house was shot as he stood by the town pump which is in my front yard by rebel snipers from a passing train on their way to Gettysburg. I heard a speaker say there were many rebel scouts in my town , and they mentioned the locations. Cool to think they may have walked by my house.


 o
RE: Anyone seen Lincoln the movie?

Wow, what a treat to check back in & read your responses! Sounds like most enjoyed the movie & appreciated the rich historical details.

Lily316, your historic house & furnishings sound charming & wonderful! I love old houses & old things. Thanks for sharing the fate of the original owner...yikes! What stories your whole neighborhood can tell, I'm sure.

Ronalawn, I enjoyed that little story about Washington's portrait too! Very cute. You are a horticulturist? What an amazing profession. Your work must be very rewarding. I adore plants...learning about them, working with them, & of course, they bring such beauty & grace into our lives. Lawns are another story. I've worked my caboose off on this lawn for the 6.5 years we've been here. What a challenge! Especially a Fescue lawn in my neck of the woods, between July & September (as you can imagine, I'm sure!)

As for my screen name...well it's a double entendre, I suppose. A triple one, really. (Depends on the day as to which meaning would be most fitting!) In addition to "stinky" in reference to a disagreeable odor, or to a task poorly executed, in our house, it is a term of endearment.

One may hear me say, "Come give me a kiss, you stinky man!" or, "What are you doing now, you stinky cat?" When I asked my husband what he thought of the new tree I recently bought & decorated, he replied, "It just looks stinky." So, I knew I'd done a good job! LOL!


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Hot Topics Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here