Return to the Hoya Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
EA Hoya soil...

Posted by Drock 5 Boulder,CO (My Page) on
Mon, Nov 12, 12 at 2:56

Hi all,
Finally took the Hoya plunge when I saw a hanging basket of Carnosa at HD. Yes, it is an Exotic Angel. Sold as 'Rubra', which I believe is more correctly identified as 'Krimson Princess'.
I know that it had not been in the store for longer than a week, but I also know that my Home Depot horribly drowns their houseplants. So, the first thing I did upon getting her home was to pop off the hanging basket saucer. Sure enough about 1/4 cup of water came immediately out. Since so much water came out just by removing the saucer, I figured that I should try and dry it out further. I did the gravity trick -holding the pot at shoulder height and letting it "drop", abruptly reversing direction at ankle level. This succeeded in getting out a LOT more water. At the point I decided to knock it out of the pot and see how wet things really were. It was sopping. I set the root ball on paper towels. Thoroughly soaked the towels. Repeated this three times and put her back in her pot. I then twisted up some wicks and stuck them into the drain holes. These dripped overnight. Satisfied that I had done enough, I decided to not mess with it anymore and wait to water when needed. That was 22 days ago. I have been monitoring moisture with a wooden skewer. It is just now getting dry enough to water for the first time.
While doing research I saw mention of EA Hoya potting medium being the kiss of death. So, I started reading up on that. It seems that most of the negative mentions of EA soil was mostly back in 2005-2007.
Normally, I repot new houseplants in Al's Gritty Mix and have had great success with it. However, I understand that Hoya's do not like to have their roots disturbed. Also, I am not fond of repotting hanging/vining plants. Especially if it is a pot full of cuttings.
I get the impression that in that last few years that EA may have changed their mix. Possibly meaning the elimination of Water Retention Crystals that seemed to be eluded to years ago?
I have not seen any decline in the health of the plant as it has been drying out. Just not sure if the 22 days was because of gross over watering or the EA soil or my particular cultural conditions. The plant is near an east facing window. Supplemental lighting. Temps are pretty consistent 75�-77�. Humidity is kept at 45-50%.

So, any recommendations? Should I repot or not?
I am willing to keep her as-is and be careful about watering. If I repot I have on hand; Turface, Granite Grit, Pine Bark, Fir Bark, Perlite, Charcoal, Sphagnum Moss, Pea Gravel, Coco Fiber Chunks, and Growers Gold Potting Soil. Of course, I would be willing to pick up anything else that may be needed.
Sorry for the long post and thank you in advance for all advice.
-Derrick
My Photo


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: EA Hoya soil...

Hi Derrick,
Pretty plant!

After reading the negative remarks on the EA soil, I moved a few plants into the gritty mix. The repotting really set the plants back. So, I thought I'd just leave the rest in the EA soil. They've been doing well for the last several years. So, I think you're right. The EA soil isn't as bad as it once was.

Still, I think it holds a lot of peat. Every six or so months I drench my plants in the shower. Not only to give them a good watering, but to give them a cleaning. The leaves are so beautiful afterward.

I have moved a few plants into the 3-1-1. I think I like it better than the gritty mix for hoya. Of course, all of this is dependent on your treatment and conditions.

Gail


 o
RE: EA Hoya soil...

Thank you, Gail, for your response.
As much as I dislike growing in peat, I think that I will let things be. Continued research just keeps on bringing examples of new EA Hoyas suffering decline after changing the soil and stories of success just letting things be. I prefer to have as many of my plants in my own mix. Mainly for plant health, but also it makes caring for them easier when you have a large number in a consistent medium. I will just have to keep my Hoya in a special care category and monitor it a bit more closely than some of my other plants.


 o
RE: EA Hoya soil...

I still suffer once in a while from the soil of an EA Hoya & wish I'd give up already (I feel such an idiot thinking maybe next time'll be different). The last one I tried was a pretty & large hanging pot of some Lacunosa, Snow Caps I think. I got it, it was SOAKING wet, I took off the bottom drip trip & set it on a stack of newspapers to blot off some of the soaking.

This plant never dried out & I took cuttings which failed to root in water (which is quite uncommon for me). I was afraid to water it 'cause it never dried out, then finally I did & I think things were already rotting. I'm either going to trade it in for a Fish Tail Hoya (just blanked on its real name, oh Polyneura??).

Anyway, see, I'll still thinking I'll try again, really I should just get my money back & give up on that mix already. It may be true they have improved their mix in recent years, but I still can't make it work for me. Not for lack of trying, grrrrrrr!


 o
RE: EA Hoya soil...

Personally, I've never had any problems with EA soil...and they have improved the soil in the past couple of years. I find that the new soil requires that I soak the baskets in a bowl of water for half an hour or so. I do re-pot after around 3 years..and use a chunky mix...but, the hoyas never seem to flourish as well as in the EA mix. Years ago I disliked the EA soil. Derrick, I'd leave your plant as it is...it'll do fine...be careful not to over-water, as carnosa prefers to dry out between waterings. Fondly, Patrick


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Hoya Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here