Return to the Hummingbird Garden Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

Posted by suzyqute z4 WI (My Page) on
Wed, May 30, 07 at 13:56

my cat caught a male hummer last night, she has never acted interested enough to go after one before , just watched them,she got it at the low feeder,that feeder will be placed higher- my hubby took it away from her,and let it go,it flew away, so apparently was not hurt, at least hope not. so she will not be allowed outside in evening again (when they are real active) Hoping that the hummer doesn't tell his friends that its dangerous by us.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

"Hoping that the hummer doesn't tell his friends that its dangerous by us."

I hope the hummer does tell his friends that it is dangerous by you......because it IS


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

I'm curious as to how much of a problem people have had with cats catching hummingbirds. By the time my cat saw one, he was old enough that they were way out of his league. That cat is now chasing mice in kitty heaven (or perhaps running from dingos in kitty hell -- what do I know?), but there are several feral cats in the neighborhood, one of which I've seen catch a rabbit. Hope I'm not designing a cat recreation area and cafeteria....


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

Why is your cat outside?

A bird can die even from the smallest scratch from a cat.


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

My cat is outside as she lives at my house, you obviously didn't read the whole post - she won't be allowed out any more when the hummers are here . She does not have claws. she has never before shown interest in trying to catch one. I love the hummers as much as all of you people do. sorry I offended any of you , didn't post to get my butt kicked- just wanted to let people know that it is possible for a cat to catch them, even when they hadn't shown any interest - and do not have claws . If you want to be nasty - keep it at home to your spouse .


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

I did read the whole post. You admitted that it was dangerous "by you"......I was just agreeing with you.


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

I did read the whole post. You admitted that it was dangerous "by you"......I was just agreeing with you.


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

When I first read this I thought uh oh, she is going to get blasted, and unfortunatly you were. It is true, cats belong inside for many reasons, screen enclose porch for kitty maybe? Also, all feeders should be hung 5 ft or greater, your neighbors may have wandering kitties. The hummer your cat caught has a very good chance of dying from this contact. Cats deliver a deep puncture wound that hummer may have initially not appeared harmed by, but unfortunatly, will cause death to the hummer. There is so much knowledge on this forum, I have learned ten-fold what to do for my hummers, and we are all pretty passionate. Keep reading and you will be able to increase your knowledge of hummers needs, flowers, nectars, feeders, pests. This place is just great.


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

"My cat is outside as she lives at my house, you obviously didn't read the whole post - she won't be allowed out any more when the hummers are here . She does not have claws. she has never before shown interest in trying to catch one. I love the hummers as much as all of you people do. sorry I offended any of you , didn't post to get my butt kicked- just wanted to let people know that it is possible for a cat to catch them, even when they hadn't shown any interest - and do not have claws . If you want to be nasty - keep it at home to your spouse ."

I did read the entire post.

Outdoor cats are a sensitive subject here regardless of what time of day they are "let outside". It is dangerous for the cat, especially one without claws(!) as well as the birds. Not to mention dangerous for you, all the "stuff" that can be brought in on the cat's fur as well as possibilty of worms from mosquito bites and the like. We just want your cat, you and the birds to be safe and healthy.

And I'm sorry you thought we were being nasty. No one is here to fight, but to learn and to offer advice. The cat is not naughty, she is just doing what comes natural as a species.

And btw.. keep our spouses out of this. Now *THAT* was nasty.


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

Once a cat is used to being outside, keeping it in all the time is going to spoil the cat's life as it sees it, and it will make sure you share in the misery. (It was a miserable 2 weeks for both of us when I kept my last cat inside after a surgery! Though to his credit, I never knew him to go after birds, though there are a couple of feral cats in the neighborhood who are a menace to everything up to the size of a rabbit. And somehow they seem to have escaped the foxes and coyotes for all these years.)


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

My cat catches two or three hummingbirds every week. It is improving the gene pool since only the most wary and fastest flying hummers survive. Kinda like natural selection, and it keeps the hummers from becoming "tame".


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

Please tell me you're joking davemidohio.


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

Dakster, don't pay any attention to Dave in Ohio. He is just trying to get you going. I know no one could be that cruel.


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

*nods*

I was already going...heehee...*deep breaths*


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

Responsible owners keep their cats inside!

Here is a link that might be useful: The Effect of Cats on Wildlife


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

Wow, I only saw this post as a "generic want-to-share" post. I do hope the hummer made it.

We have an outside cat and an inside cat. We only have the outside cat as we were kind enough to take care of her as she came to our house pregnant, underfed and neglected, from my neighbor's house. Now I have 3 kittens the "no kill" rescue center is taking next week. The momma cat has been staying inside recovering from surgery, at our expense, so no more kitties for her!

I used to see nothing wrong with outside pets, but I have changed my opinion in the last few years. This does not change the fact that MANY people here have outside cats and dogs. A lot of residents in our proximity have acreage and barns. They "use" the outside cats to catch mice and snakes. For us, however, we have buried too many cats that have been hit by cars and had one outside cat that had Aids and had to be put to sleep! This is when I said no more outside cats or dogs. I would love to give my outside dog away. He barks all the time and drives me crazy. He barks at deer or opossum. I never want another dog (just a personal matter here everyone, so don't be too hard on me.)

Our inside cat is a Siamese we adopted from the shelter and she hates other cats. That's fine with me, as this means no more inside cats, so no double the poop to scoop! Honestly, we did see a lot of adult cats at Petsmart that we could have brought home with us in a heartbeat, but our cat rules the house! The momma cat will be put outside tomorrow. I do hope she goes back to our neighbor's house and stays there, but I know this is only a dream. Why would you leave a gourmet feast for no food at all, LOL!


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

Just keep the hummer feeders out of kitties reach. My cat watches them, but knows he can't get them. He's more interested in those fat chipmunks.


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

The flies and moths and spiders that get in the house are fair game for my indoor cat. Otherwise I don't let him kill ANY kind of wildlife. And I also keep him indoors so the wildlife or the neighbor's pit bull or a car or whatever doesn't kill him. If you want to let your cat go outside, its safer for him and the wildlife if you build a "kennel" for him or leash train him like some people I know have done.

Here is a link that might be useful: Cats Indoors


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

My cats go out in a fenced yard with a special cat fence on top so they can't get out.

As far as 'wildlife', my neighbor has offered me $$ to let me have my cat hunt chipmunks in her yard. Trust me, they are not endangered.

All my bird feeders are high and in the open so the cats can't get the birds. They've never caught a bird.


 o
Hmm..

All you "outdoor cat" people can believe what you'd like, just as all of us "indoor cat" people will continue to do the same. Just makes me wonder how many of your cats you will scrape off the road before you change your minds.

I suppose it is a case of: agree to disagree.

However, just FYI, outdoor cats and red dye, are 2 *very* controversial subjects on these forums.


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

I normally don't bother to get into this type of discussion, however...here goes!!

To texanjana
You stated: Responsible owners keep their cats inside!

This comment is what really set me off!!

I consider myself a responsible cat owner and my cat does not stay indoors all of the time. He is current on shots, I keep his nails trimmed and he is allowed outdoors with his leash and harness but only when I am able to be outside with him to watch him. For the most part he is an indoor cat and we only take him out when the weather is nice. He never uses the bathroom outdoors either.

Do neighbors laugh at us when they see us tie him up, NO! They appreciate the fact that we watch him so close and keep him home. They are amazed that he doesn't mind at all being tied up to a leash. However, I do wish out neighbors would do the same with their cats.

Please do not assume that we cat owners are not responsible unless we keep out cats indoors all the time!

Sorry, just had to vent for a sec.

Cindi


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

Oh cool.. yours is on a leash..ok.. now you are the exception to the "no cats outside rule". That's neat.


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

You are probably correct when you state that our cat is the exception to the rule but we love him and try to take every precaution to protect him inside or outside.

I have also been an avid bird person for many years and I would never knowingly add to their daily struggles to survive along side of the human race.

Teaching a cat to be on a leash is not as hard as one may think. He knows when he sees the harness that he is going outside and he actually will place his head inside of it. He has used one since he was 3 months old and he is now 7 years old so he doesn't know any different.


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

I don't care if other people want to keep their cats indoor only. And I don't approve of free roaming cats. As I said, mine are in the fenced in yard that they can't get out of. One goes out front with me and rolls around on the walkway as I garden. He doesn't go off the property or in the street.

So you can allow your cats outside responsibly. My cats are my children so I do take very good care of them.

I also would never put dye in my hummer feeders :)


 o
RE: My naughty cat caught a hummer - But its ok.

Five feet is too low... hang your feeders 6 feet or more off the ground.

I watched my neighbor's fat lazy cat jump 5 feet straight up into the air from a crouched position to grab a hummer sitting on my feeder. ("Aw, see the silly kitty thinking it can reach the birdie... OH NO!"). I had no idea she could jump that high.

Felt awful about the bird but have to admit I was impressed with the athleticism of an animal I had relegated to FAT DOMESTIC FURBALL status. Don't under-estimate your kitties... they are fierce little predators.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Hummingbird Garden Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here