Return to the Hydroponics Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
river gravel for flood/drain

Posted by stuii Melbourne (My Page) on
Mon, Mar 9, 09 at 23:44

Hi Guys,

I was considering usnig river gravdel for my next system to save some money,

my next system will either be a drip from above and drain or a flood then drain system

Does anyone have any experiences growing outdoors using river gravel as a medium?

Regards,
S


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

I used river gravel about 35 years ago in an Ebb-&-Flow system. I found out two things:

First off, it's very heavy. Make sure whatever you fill with it can support its weight wet!

Second: You get more than you bargained for if it has not been cleaned first with live steam. The steam kills all the little "wee-beasties" hiding in the nooks and crannies of the rock. If you use it without cleaning it somehow, your major crop will be algae! It comes on rather fast, by the way, since it holds nutrient-laden water on the surface exposed to light.


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

The medium should retain some moisture. So, mix the gravel with saw dust on a 1:1 volume basis. Beware! saw dust compacts a lot.
My mixture is wood shavings (I just buy a suitable plank, then stick it through the motorised planer and collect all the shavings)
First I let the shavings soak a few days replacing the water every day, then I cover them with a layer of gravel to keep the shavings in place, and away we go!


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

thanks for the feedback guys..

perhaps before I go and get the river graevl then... can anyone think of a cheap effective re-useable alternative to hydroton (clay beads) for this kind of system?

Regards,
S


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

I have used chopped-up baked clay bricks, but its one heck of a mission to make.
They work well though.


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

"Perlite"
It comes in three grades; stay away from the fine, powdery one. It's cheap (I pay $14 for a 5 cu. ft. bag) and it's reusable. I soak mine in 30% hydrogen peroxide when I reuse it.


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

I've used river gravel by itself without any problems.
I've also used landscape lava rock and perlite.
With flood and drain I had problems with the perlite getting into the reservoir even with screens covering all points of egress. stick with the gravel or lava rock. you don't have to add anything else, but you may need to increase the frequency of flood cycles.


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

thanks guys - I might try to see if there are any good cheap sources of perlite nearby


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

Try a farm supply store. They sell it as a soil additive to increase the soils porosity. Be sure to ask which grade it is. Like I said earlier; stay away from the fine, powdery stuff as it will just clog things up. I pay $14 for a 5 cubic foot bag in California.


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

thanks freemangreens
I think there is a farm supply shop near me actually

one final question - roughly how heavy and harsh edged is the landscaping lava rocks?


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

Other similar options include aquarium (fish tank) gravel, marbles, and stuff like that. A mix of perlite and vermiculite works well, as does straight perlite.

My only dislike of perlite is how light it is - it practically floats. That and you have to be really careful about dust. The dust off that stuff can be murder on the lungs.


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

garysgarden

Just a quick note of encouragement here: My perlite comes with an MSDS attached and it says pretty much what you said about murdering your lungs, but the other side of that coin is, there is nothing else harmful in it.

Perlite does contain a modicum of phosphorus, fyi.

stuii:

"one final question - roughly how heavy and harsh edged is the landscaping lava rocks?"
Just hop down to Home Depot and take a look. It's lighter than gravel and sharp enough that you wouldn't want to walk barefoot on it, but other than that it's pretty subjective.

As far as it floating away, I water/feed ONLY what the plants use. If you "puddle" as you water, perlite is a nightmare!


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

I'm currently building an Ebb and Flood system using 55 gallon plastic barrels cut into three (and discarding the middle section and using the top/bottom pieces as separate hoppers for the medium. Another smaller barrel acts as the reservoir, etc.)

For the medium I'm using recycled lava rock from an old fast food restaurant garden bed. That stuff is very light in comparison to river gravel (with maybe 5% of it floating as it soaks it in bleach solution - I've still got a few cleaning cycles to go through). I like working with it as it's got a lot of surface area, retains a good deal of water and is light enough to work with without the need for industrial strength supports for the hydroponics.


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

Commercially available expanded clay pellets are not that expensive and fit the bill for hydro to a tee which is why they are used so much.

Check your supplier's prices on the web. Even the high-priced stuff id $1.50/lb and it lasts forever.


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

Good point willard. It's a bit of an up-front expense but so is most everything else in the hydroponics world.

And like you say, it's not really that expensive. I've got hydroton I've had forever that's still just as good as when I bought it. Buy the best you can afford and you'll rarely be disappointed, that's my philosophy.


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

In case anyone's curious why one fine-grained thing, like asbestos, can be so harmful, while another, like perlite, can be irritating but otherwise inert, check out their microscopic structures:

Asbestos:

Perlite:

Perlite has a fascinating look to it under the microscope, doesn't it? :) The fine-grained flakes at the bottom of the picture are bentonite clay, and the roughly spherical shape is an undamaged grain of perlite, while the rest are all broken perlite particles.


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

Thanks for the pic, that is cool. I have a question and some feedback, is there any truth to the "rumour" that vermiculite may contain asbestos?

Also, I have had problems with perlite and vermiculite mixtures, they break down until they inhibit flow/draining, vermiculite more so but perlite does it too. Does anyone else find this? The lava rocks are three bucks for 2'x2'x2" coverage at hd/lowes!


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

is there any truth to the "rumour" that vermiculite may contain asbestos?

There's some truth to it. Vermiculite is often (although not always) found with another mineral called diopside. In the right geological conditions, diopside can turn to asbestos. So, in some mines, the vermiculite is mixed in with harmless diopside, and in some of those mines, the diopside is partially or fully converted to asbestos. In the olden days, they didn't use to check much for asbestos, and some significantly asbestos-contaminated vermiculite products were on the market -- the classic example being vermiculite from the Libby mine that's led to so many lawsuits (sold under the brand name Zonolite). Nowadays, though, it's all checked; the EPA mandates a 1% cap on maximum asbestos content, and it's generally an immeasurably small quantity in vermiculite (esp. in non-dusty vermiculite products). Plus, asbestos is mostly inert when wet anyways; it's when it's aerosolized that it's a problem.

There's risk in almost everything in this world, but the risk from modern vermiculite is pretty low.


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

Guys thanks for all of the info - I found a local perlite supplier $20 for 100L

I'm giving that a go in one of by beds...

But for future reference - does anyone know where I can get clay pellets for cheap? the only place I know near(ish) to me is $40 for 45L


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

I know that perlite can damage the lungs. It's not as bad as asbestos but if memory serves it's definitely more insidious than merely being an irritant.

Whatever the case, it's simple to avoid. Wet it down and there's no danger.

Not sure on cheap clay pellets. I don't use very much myself and since it's pretty much endlessly reusable I don't buy it often. I also don't need enough to concern myself that much with finding the rock-bottom price.


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

I know that perlite can damage the lungs. It's not as bad as asbestos but if memory serves it's definitely more insidious than merely being an irritant.

Perlite is federally classified as a "nuisance dust". Nothing more. It's a lung and eye irritant, but isn't carcinogenic or cause degenerative conditions, as does asbestos. Studies of even perlite *workers* show no evidence of silicosis or other lung disease.


 o
RE: river gravel for flood/drain

Looks like I was wrong. Cool. Good to know.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Hydroponics Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here