Return to the Hydroponics Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Question re Grow Lights for My Indoor Gardening.

Posted by KendraSchmidt none (My Page) on
Fri, Sep 21, 12 at 13:32

I would like to purchase a grow light for my plants.

I'm currently looking at a grow light that has florescent tubes. It allows me to choose between a two foot long and four foot long lamp.

Additionally, I can choose between four or eight florescent tubes (long light bulbs) in the lamp.

What is the difference between the amount of tubes? Does having more tubes make a difference? Does this mean that if I purchase the one with eight tubes, that I'll somehow have better plants/plant growth?

I'm trying to ensure a headstart for my short growing season and I grow a lot of peppers and greens. I want to experiment with growing them indoors...please tell me what is the difference between the amount of tubes you choose? Thank you.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Question re Grow Lights for My Indoor Gardening.

It sounds like you would get more light with more tubes, so you would cover a larger area efficiently. When the footprint of the light is not big enough, seedlings will get leggy and lean in the direction of the light source.

Fluorescent lights that are not labeled as "grow" lights will also work just fine. Often they are cheaper as well.


 o
RE: Question re Grow Lights for My Indoor Gardening.

Thanks Cole Robbie. So does that mean that my plants won't have to be directly under the lamp if I get additional tubes? Does that mean they can even be a foot away from the edge of lamp and still get light if I use the additional tubes?

Or does that mean that I'll have to cram all of the plants directly underneath the lamp for them to grow? This is my first time trying to grow with lamps.

I'm also wondering how much they can grow with a light? Can it grow until it produces fruit or seeds?


 o
RE: Question re Grow Lights for My Indoor Gardening.

It's more about the number of plants and square footage you have to cover. You still have to keep the tubes right above the seedlings for best results. Growing seedlings with fluorescent lights is popular, cheap, and works very well.

Trying to produce good-tasting fruit entirely under artificial lighting is another thing entirely. The problem is that the hps lighting you would need will use more electricity than the value of the tomatoes you would produce. I don't know about producing viable seed with fluoros - enough of them will make a fruit or two, but I doubt it would be anything you want to eat.


 o
RE: Question re Grow Lights for My Indoor Gardening.

Good day KendraSchmidt,

I'm a sales rep for a hydroponic store as well as an active Hydroponic Indoor gardener. T5 Florescence are the best option for seed starts, cloning, and vegetative growth. I'd absolutely recommend a t5 florescent for your needs. You'll be able to get very healthy and tall starts out of your light. There are two ways to look at your florecent light.

T5's work best when the light is 4-8" from the plants you are growing. They produce little heat. So whatever size light you buy, 4'x1.5' (a 4' 4 lamp system), that is the area you'll be covering very well. So lets go further...

A) Seed starting/cloning/basic veg: In this situation you can raise the light up and cover a larger area because you are not focused on super productive growth. You want your seeds to pop or clones to root and that doesn't require a lot of light. When your plants are growing up, meaning they have rooted, you can leave the light 12" or higher to cover more area but the downside is that your plants may stretch for the light. But that is ok if you plan on going outdoors or wanna just start a bunch of plants for cheap.

B) Productive growing/flowering: Ideally you want that light directly on top of the canopy, 2"-8". Now your light's footprint is as large as the light fixture, but the quality of light is significantly greater and that means the plants in this area will grow rapidly. Your yield will be much greater as well if you choose to flower indoors.

The more lamps, the more area you can cover.

I hope that helps. Sun Leaves Pioneer T5's are GREAT lights. Quantum's BadBoys are really nice too.


 o
RE: Question re Grow Lights for My Indoor Gardening.

T5 / T5 HO are awesome.

T8 for non-fruiting is maybe the most economical depending on the vertical growth of the plant. With greens and lettuce it is a great (and cheap) approach.

Add a little mylar and extend the photons a bit further.

Here is a link that might be useful: My Hydroponic Adventure and Journal


 o
RE: Question re Grow Lights for My Indoor Gardening.

Dennis, thank you very much for your detailed response. Does this mean that a t5 with 4 tubes and 4 feet of length can indeed be used for vegetative growth indoors? (I'm growing peppers mostly.)

Does this mean that I simply have to raise the height of the lamp above the plants and adjust the height of the lamp depending on what exactly I'd like to do with the plants? (e.g. have them flower, grow peppers, etc?)

And does this mean that the taste will be off because it's indoors and with a lamp?


 o
RE: Question re Grow Lights for My Indoor Gardening.

Kendra, try some ratcheing hangers. They allow very easy maneuvering of the lights.

With flouros, keeping them as close to the plants as possible is key since they lose penetrating power quickly compared to HPS and MH.

With T5's, about an inch to one and a half inches should be correct.
Changing bulb colors will allow flowering.

Here is a link that might be useful: My Hydroponic Adventure and Journal


 o
RE: Question re Grow Lights for My Indoor Gardening.

The more light (tubes/wattage) you give to your plant, the more potential your plant has to convert it into energy through photosynthesis i.e., more growth and production. With more wattage you will see faster growth in less time than if you had less wattage.

As for fluorescent fixtures, depending on the fixture style, they usually throw out a useable footprint 6" wider than the fixture is. E.g., if your fixture is 2'x2', then your footprint will be about 3'x3'.

I'm growing six jalapeno plants that are each about 3 ft tall in an ebb and flow system under 216w of flouorescent lighting in a 4' - 4 bulb fixture. It's working marvelously. Product I'm using in optional link URL.

Here is a link that might be useful: Quantum 4' 4 bulb


 o
RE: Question re Grow Lights for My Indoor Gardening.

HID lamps are more efficient than fluorescent lamps.


 o
RE: Question re Grow Lights for My Indoor Gardening.

willard3 is very right.

They are the most effcient. They put out more lumens per watt then even the best T5 lighting.


 o
RE: Question re Grow Lights for My Indoor Gardening.

The last three posts here are INCREDIBLY helpful and exactly what I wanted to know. Tremendous thanks to you all!


 o
RE: Question re Grow Lights for My Indoor Gardening.

I put together a web page that compares the different types of grow lights. I covers grow area, heat output, energy use, bulb life, and how high to have them above the plant.

link to it: http://www.tomorrowsgarden.net/node/5

Here is a link that might be useful: Grow light information


 o
RE: Question re Grow Lights for My Indoor Gardening.

Your charts confuse heat output with lamp temperature and it should be corrected.

Heat is measured in btu, temperature in degrees. The most efficient lamp has the lowest heat output, HID in this case. Lamp temp is higher, heat output is lower.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Hydroponics Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here