Return to the Beans, Peas & Other Legumes Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

Posted by bella_trix z6b SE PA (My Page) on
Mon, Feb 12, 07 at 21:12

Could someone (gardenlad, zeedman, hint, hint) please clarify if I understand my cannellini beans correctly???
From what I understand, Runner Cannellini beans are very distinct in taste and appearance from regular Cannellini beans. They are still Phaseolus vulgaris, but larger and nuttier than Cannellini. Cannellini Gigande is yet another bean, but a white runnerbean from Phaseolus coccineus. Have I misunderstood? Are Cannellini Gigande and Runner Cannellini the same bean?

I am desperately (yes, desperately) trying to find some pure seed beans for runner cannellini. I accidentally ordered the eating runner cannellini beans from SSE, thinking they were seed stock. I wasn't particularly worried. I figured I'd eat those (yum) and just order seed stock from the yearbook. Much to my disapointment, the only runner cannellini beans were listed as Limited Quantity, which means, as a first year member, that I can't order them.

So, I emailed SSE to see if maybe the eating beans were grown in isolation and if could just plant them. I received a nice note back about how, no, they are not a hybrid so they could be planted.

O.K.

So, I tried again. After two more emails of "they aren't grown here, we don't know", I asked if maybe they could contact the grower. Yes, maybe I was asking them to go above and beyond the call of duty, but if I'm planning on offering these beans next year, I'd like to know if they're the real thing.

I get back an email about how if I would look on page 80, plenty of cannellini beans are offered and that two cannellini beans are offered under runnerbeans. I was under the impression that neither of these were Runner Cannellini beans. I'm really hoping that I'm the one that's confused, because if SSE is the one that's confused, that's pretty sad.

Sorry for the rant. Should I just plant the eating beans and hope for the best?

Thanks,
Bellatrix


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

Truly odd... this topic has come up fairly often lately; and having experienced some of the same frustration, Bellatrix, I know where you are coming from.

I think we are all confused.

All of the "runner cannellini" beans that I have thus far seen or read about, turned out to be P. coccineus, regardless of how they were identified. For some reason, the white runner beans from Europe are frequently misidentified; sometimes as limas, sometimes as P. vulgaris. I have also been sent white "runner beans" that upon examination & planting, turned out to be limas. Confusing indeed.

It may be a question of language; perhaps cannellini is a term used to describe many types of beans that are similar in appearance (white), or usage. Hopefully someone from "across the pond" could shed some light on this.

I have also been searching for the elusive "pole cannellini", so far unsuccessfully. "Gigande" seems to refer to both a runner bean & a lima; logical I suppose, given that both are large seeded. I grew the lima last year, obtained under one of its synonyms "Hija" (it did not mature for me). And I grew one of the white runner beans in 2005 - it is completely different, in terms of taste & texture, from the bush cannellini.

The search goes on... I will be watching this thread.

However, I have found white-seeded pole beans that were similar to cannellini. One that I grew last year, an heirloom called "Brita's Foot Long", had large white seeds of very fine quality... perhaps that is as close as I will come to the real thing.


 o
RE: Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

Hi there! I'm also very interested in this thread. I was sorely disappointed when I purchased what were labeled as "pole cannellini" from SSE a few years ago, and they turned out to be runner beans bellatrix seeks. I gave the extra seed away (sorry, bella!) They did not taste anything like the yummy, authentic cannellini bush beans I grow every year. I too seek the elusive pole version, as I want to give only two beds to bush beans ("Flagrano flageolet" and "Dutch Brown"). Zeedman, I'd be forever grateful if you let me know if you find them!


 o
RE: Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

Here is a possible clue. The Greek cooks at here and here state that the Greek "Gigantes" bean is a runner bean. This name is also protected by EU law so that people in Europe cannot label beans as "Gigantes" unless they are grown in a certain area in northern Greece where the growers are protected from competition.


 o
RE: Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

I speak from a position of total ignorance but I find myself doubting that Gigantes are runner beans ( Phaseolus coccineus)They look much more like what we refer to as butter beans, a variety we cannot grow here but do eat. I think they are nearest to what you call limas. I buy but cannot grow haricots and flageolets which both look like P vulgaris. When googling Gigantes I found this article which might be of interest. I have grown Borlotti beans which appear to be P vulgaris. For a sample of the runners (including white seeded) available in the UK look at this link http://www.nickys-nursery.co.uk/seeds/pages/veg1-runner-beans.htm

Here is a link that might be useful: A book of beans


 o
RE: Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

Oh great, now I have to buy another bean book. ;-) Thanks, Flora, for the reference, I'm sure it will be a good read.

At this point, I am beginning to doubt that there is a true "pole cannellini". I think that it falls in that area of ambiguity occupied by white-seeded runner beans. Every time I track down a pole bean with large white seeds, it turns out to be a runner bean. Like "Pole Cannellini", "Greek Giant Lima" appears to be a white-seeded runner bean.

And still, I continue to get "runner beans" that turn out to be other species. My own research agrees with Flora; "Gigante" (or Gigande, or Hija) is a very large pole lima. And two years back, I received a "runner bean" which proved to be epigeal (the cotyledons emerged). Since runner beans are hypogeal like English peas, I destroyed the plants then... but I am growing it this year in isolation. Having observed the flowers & thin yellow(!) pods (and how it set them in hot weather) I would classify it as P. vulgaris.

Part of the problem, I think, is the bean lexicon (I hear echoes of Gardenlad whenever I say that). Runner beans are a species... but runner bean is also the general term for any bean with pole habit. IMO, this leads to too much confusion.


 o
RE: Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

Maybe it is a lima. The climate around Kastoria would appear to be good for limas.

On the other hand, the EU regulation states that it is P. coccineus that originated in Mexico.


 o
RE: Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

I think I may have some of these Gigante beans in my garden this year. Someone sent them to me as a bonus, saying they came from Greece. They were labeled "Cannellini".

All of them grew with the cotyledons below ground. I kind of forgot about them before reading this thread, so I'll have to check for flowers and pods.

Gary


 o
RE: Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

I am going to make the assumption that the Gigande beans I have are the "Hija" or the lima bean version of the large white beans (I am growing three more that I know are runners). I will keep an eye on the epigeal/hypogeal feature as they sprout to tell if it is still another runner bean.

If I do indeed have the lima version, any idea if it will be a bush or a pole lima?

Will be on the lookout for a large podded white bean of the P vulgaris species, since P. vulgaris do the best here and produce the longest. Any luck with that anyone?


 o
RE: Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

OK, cancel my question - I see that in another lima bean thread zeedman mentioned the Gigande lima being a pole lima. I guess I better plant them soon and trellis.


 o
RE: Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

If your "Gigande" proves to be identical/similar to the "Hija" that I grew, it will require a very long season. Fortunately, Cabrita, you have that (says this Wisconsinite wistfully).

I've seen a very large lima sold in some ethnic food stores, I believe under the brand name Goya. It would be interesting to find out how similar they are to "Gigandes". If I can find them way out here, that would make them "widely available". ;-)

I trialed another good white-seeded pole bean last year, "Tetovac", a Serbian bean sent to me in trade. They are sold in bulk there commercially. Rather unusual, flat white seeds the size & shape of "Sieva" limas... but it is P. vulgaris. Very vigorous vines, and a decent yield. Haven't tried them in soup yet, so don't know how well they hold up; but they were easy to shell, and very good as shellies.

This year I will be growing a very large-seeded white bush bean (an heirloom, "Clem & Sarah's Big Bean", from Drloyd), but the search for a true "pole Cannellini" continues. Either of the two varieties I've mentioned might be acceptable substitutes.


 o
RE: Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

Thanks for telling us about 'Tetovac' zeedman. I have lots of latin stores around so I will look for the large lima from Goya. Please do tell us if you find the elusive 'true' pole cannellini. As much as I like to try other legume species, the P. vulgaris do so well here and produce the longest. Peas do quite well too but in the winter, or whatever passes for winter around here (no complaints!).

How long is long? If I plant them this weekend do you think they will produce by November? We do have a long season, but not a long "hot" season.


 o
RE: Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

If I am not mistaken, Cabrita, the coastal fogs should be burning off just about now, so this would be a good time to plant your limas. They should still have plenty of time to mature in your climate.


 o
White beans we have known and loved

Adding to the white bean confusion:

"Cannellini" is a specific bush common bean also known as "white kidney bean" that I grow as a shelly.

"Cannellini" is also unfortunately is used to describe most any large white seeded bean except possibly Lima beans. Therefore the concept of a "pole cannellini" will forever remain elusive or even meaningless. I know that is a dismal view, but it seems to be the way it is. ;-)

"Brita's Foot Long" is a very fine pole shelly or dry bean that could be renamed "pole cannellini" so we could have a pole cannellini. ;D

"Monteges del Gaxnet" is favorite in Spain. It has more of a curve that kidney types. I am trialing it this year, a year even more difficult here than 2008 was. Our spring has been incredibly wet and colder than parts of Siberia and Alaska. So it is not really getting a fair trial.

More confusion:

"Bond's Orcas Lima" is a very early pole runner with large seeds and good eating quality. It easily produced mature seed here in the PNW even in a very difficult year like 2008.

"Bianco di Spagna" or "Italian Butter Bean" is sold by seed companies as a common bean but it is a runner with huge shellies up to 1-3/4 inches long. It is fairly late but does produce mature seed here in the PNW.

"Cannellini Gigante" is a pole runner with very large seeds that will produce dry seed here. Good shellies.

"Delucci Cannellini" is a pole runner that will produce dry seed here. Very large and good quality shellies.

"Gigantes" is a very large seeded pole runner bean that is only grown in a specific region in Greece. The name is protected by EU law so if you grow these in other parts of the EU, you have to call them something else.

"Gigandes" is a large seeded Lima that is sold by that name by Purcell Mountain Farms. It makes an outstanding bean soup with little added to it besides onion and salt. I have about 2 gallons of it on cooking this morning. I would love to be able to grow that one.- Dick


 o
RE: Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

""Brita's Foot Long" is a very fine pole shelly or dry bean that could be renamed "pole cannellini" so we could have a pole cannellini. ;D"

I second the motion. It's probably as close as we are likely to get to the bush variety. The fact that it is tasty & highly productive doesn't hurt either. Tip o' the hat to Salt Spring Seeds in Canada for introducing it, too bad they no longer ship to the States.


 o
RE: Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

Hmmmmmm, I alway buy my garlic from Salt Spring Seeds, I'll be sending Dan some of my Italian beans to trial this fall sooooo maybe I should order some Brita's :).

Annette


 o
RE: Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

I love it when some of these old threads get linked to, as this just was. It provides a chance to update them with new info.

One other bean has surfaced as a good "pole Cannellini" substitute - "Tarbais". Like "Gigandes", it is a geographically-protected name in the E.U. This is another good white-seeded P. vulgaris pole bean. There is a GW thread on it, link below.

Here is a link that might be useful: Tarbais


 o
RE: Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

  • Posted by jolj 7b/8a-S.C.USA (My Page) on
    Fri, Feb 17, 12 at 12:51

Where would a Southern bean collector get Gigantes?
zeedman,
It would be wonderful if you could list your 10 best types of bean & a source to buy them for us beginners( on a new thread).
I have raised beans/peas all my live, but only the common types.
Thank you for all that you do for the bean world.


 o
RE: Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

Jolj, you would get Gigantes on ebay right now. Just put this in the search string:
(gigantes,yigandes,gigandes)

Include the parenthesis

DarJones


 o
RE: Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

Now 2 years later, just received some Cannellini Runner Pole beans from Mandy's Greenhouse, business closing May 2014. Will grow out and report. Think it will be interesting because in the description, "Not to be confused with other lima varieties". Other comments, Plants to 6' plus, 90 days, said to have come originally from Argentina. Seeds are large, white, slightly elongated.

Frances

Here is a link that might be useful: Mandy's Greenhouse Beans Page


 o
RE: Runner Cannellini vs Cannellini vs Cannellini Gigande - help!

'Cannellini White Runner' from Mandy's Greenhouse. Not the best pic but it will give you an idea of what the seed looks like.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Beans, Peas & Other Legumes Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here