Return to the Growing under Lights Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Posted by hvander 5B ON (My Page) on
Tue, Dec 20, 05 at 20:53

Can anyone suggest a good resource for building a do-it-yourself indoor seed starting system? I plan to start approx. 2000 plants and will need an adequate structure.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Henry,

I originally considered building some shelves out of PVC plastic pipe, because there are several plans available for doing that and the PVC pipe, unlike wood, is waterproof. But I noticed that some people were having problems with the plastic shelves bending under the weight of the load. So I decided to try some inexpensive Chrome Steel Industrial Shelving from Sams Club. Our local Sams Club had them in stock, so I just bought them locally, but of course you could buy from the Internet stores as well. I think Costco has some very similar if not identical shelves.

I simply hung 4-foot fluorescent shoplights directly from the overhead shelves and that proved to be a very flexible. I used 1-inch S-hooks (also from Home Depot) to hook the chains to the shelves. By picking which link of the chain looped over the S-hooks I could easily vary the height of the fluorescent lights over the seedlings as the seedlings grew taller. I got the two-bulb shoplight fixtures from Home Depot for $8 each and I also got the 4-foot T-8 cool white fluorescent bulbs from Home Depot for $2 each in boxes of ten bulbs ($19.99 per box of ten bulbs). For extra light I used more than one shoplight per shelf. I had the lights on a timer, which I adjusted for about 16 hours of light and 8 hours of dark.

Those shelves were fully adjustable and on handy rollers, so that initial rig worked very well for me. The chrome shelves were waterproof and plenty strong to hold my seedling trays. I have since expanded and improved my fluorescent light growing setup, but that first setup let me grow a lot of seedlings that year for a little over $100. And it was much less expensive than comparable ready-made light stands.

MM


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Thanks MM. That sounds like a good start.


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Just did the exact same setup. Only difference was that I covered the sides with plastic covers attached with velcro and put a small computer fan at the bottom. This keeps the heat up inside (because the garage is cold) and keeps the air moving adequately.


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Ooh, ooh. I just got one of these units at Costco. I am so excited. Just have one of my shoplights sitting on a shelf right now (have to figure out where the chains are), with lots of plants tucked underneath. They are really heavy duty - can hold 150lb per shelf (more if you don't use the casters). And compared to the $800 unit someone else posted, what a deal!


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

A GW friend sent me this site. If your handy with a saw and screw gun, it is a pretty easy project. Also if you use industrial grade lumber it is fairly inexpensive. I plan to make it twice as deep. That shoud allow me to put five 72-cell flats per shelf. If I hang some lights from the ceiling over it, I figure it will have room for 1440 seedlings. Of course after studying another thread in this forum, I plan to put two 48" twin-tube "overdriven" shoplights per shelf. Thats gonna drive the cost up a few bucks. But I figure I can build the whole thing, including the "overdriven" lights and a timer for around $200-$250. The shelving unit alone should cost less than $100.

Here is a link that might be useful: Build It Yourself Seed Starting Rack


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

I have the metal rack from costco, actually I have 4 of them all set up with lights. This year I have them set up in my greenhouse. All on timers.Just started planting seeds. I think my heat mat may have fried some of my seedlings that I just planted on Saturday. I can't believe how fast seeds germinate when they have the bottom heat and well the heat from all the lights.............to warm. But yea the metal racks and floresents are great I had so many flowers last year. I think every seed grew and grew well!


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

After reading MaineMan's previous posts I started searching for the same chrome wire shelves. No Costco around, Sam's Club about 60 miles away, but I'm not a member. I located the same thing on line for $96 with $48 shipping. I tried on line with Sears, Home Depot, Lowes with no luck. I happened to be a member of B.J.'s Wholesale House and went there to check. They had the same one that Sam's Club had, 6 chrome wire shelves,for $69.95. You can convert it to two 3 shelves if you want too. Very easy to assemble with no tools. Roy


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

I have the wire shelves too. Very easy to put together, and my dad the engineer said they are just about strong enough to park a car on!! I love them - it's so easy to hang and rearrange the lights.


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

  • Posted by sanj Zone5 Denver (My Page) on
    Tue, Feb 7, 06 at 18:52

I bought one yesterday for around $80 in costco..very nice rack. Now I need to get some light supply, timers and fans. I am growing tomatoes, peppers and eggplants. Need some hints on what type of 48" lights to get...need some help for the newbie. Also how many lights per selve, 2 or, 4?


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Sanj,

I recommend Home Depot's Commercial Electric shoplights, model 732-334. They sell for about $8. They hold two 48-inch bulbs and can accept either T8 or T12 bulbs. I recommend T8s because they are more efficient. Home Depot sells Philips T8 cool whites in boxes of 10 for $19.99. So they cost only $2 per bulb. Don't waste money on more expensive GroLite bulbs.

Since the 732-334 fixtures are just a bit less than 5 inches wide, you can easily hang three of those fixtures per 18-inch deep shelf, for a total of six bulbs per shelf. Of course you could hang just two fixtures or only one fixture if you prefer. I prefer to give my seedlings all the light they can use, so I usually use the maximum number of fixtures per shelf. I also overdrive my fixtures for the same reason.

I usually load the plant trays cross-ways to get four trays per shelf instead of the usual two trays. The trays jut out about 2 inches on each side of the shelf, but that works OK for me.

MM


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

maineman, I just built a very similar set-up. I used light fixtures that already had plugs on them, for $12.00 each, s-hooks ($1.50 for 6), a 5-shelf rack that holds 3 flat trays per shelf from Target that I got on sale for $30, a surge protector strip and an extension cord (because the setup is in a spare bedroom and an outlet wasn't easily reachable), total cost for the cord and strip $10.00, and then I splurged and got the fancy 9 dollar plant light bulbs (4' T-12 40-Watt jobs). Total cost under $150, and I can take the whole thing down if I decide to move it, move to a new house (not in the works, but ya never know...), or tire of compulsive gardening.

Lisa


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System (which bulbs are best?)

I'm just putting together my MaineMan setup- I got one of the shelving units from Sam's club, but I only used 5 of the six shelves. I wanted to have a little more space between shelves because I'm going to start the seeds in larger pots. It's probably less power-efficient, since I could make do with just one shelf of seedlings and then spread out as they get bigger.

But I've found that, life being what it is, if I plan on transplanting seedlings I'm not going to find time to do it. Last year I started 288, and gave most of them away. This year I'm going to raise about 30 plants and start about twice that many. AND I'm going to put them in pots they can grow in, so they've got a great root system at transplant time, not just a bunch of leaves growing out of a thimble.

Yesterday I picked up 18 of the Home Depot 732-334. I also picked up three different kinds of bulbs: Sylvania Cool White Octron Ecologic (12-pack at Lowe's, just under $3 per bulb), Phillips Cool White at Home Depot (2-pack, $2 per bulb) and Phillips Daylight Deluxe (2-pack, $3 per bulb).

So now I'm trying to figure out which bulb of the three is best for plants. If I need to make one more trip to return and replace bulbs, I'll do it. But just one more trip!

All put about 2800 Lumens. The Cool White bulbs are 4100K, the Daylight Deluxe is 6500K.

Are there any recent writeups on fluorescent bulbs?

I thought I'd buy the cheapest bulbs I could get, then I figured that I was dropping $18 plus 15 minutes for each overdriven fixture- it might be worth spending an extra buck or two on the bulbs.

I apologize if I'm hijacking the thread. Should I start a separate one?


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

I chose the more expensive ($9/bulb) "plant light" ones because they claim that they emit more of the red and blue wavelengths plants like. I was also seduced by the word "phosphor". I am SUCH a nerd... I justified my cost because the package also claims the bulbs will last for 9 years, so at a dollar a year I figure it's a "bargain". You should see the justifications I use to buy plants and seeds I don't have room for and don't need...

Lisa


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

  • Posted by zink 6a (My Page) on
    Sun, Feb 26, 06 at 16:31

Lisa,

All fluorescent bulb contain a phosphor. The term "phosphor" refers to the phosphorescent properties of the tube's chemical coating, not necessarily that it contains the element phosphorous.

What brand name is the bulb? Is it a GRO-LUX? Sylvania makes a GRO-LUX Standard, and a GRO-LUX Wide Spectrum. Both are good lights and are not mistakes. Yes, you could have bought a cheaper bulb, but don't sweat it.

If it is a GRO-LUX, I can tell you more info about it. I had a conversation with SYLVANIA's Senior Engineer in their Lighting Division, and got a brief history of the GRO-LUX's development. This guy's father, John Waymouth (both are PHD's) wrote the definitive book on electric arc discharge lamps, which includes fluorescent, metal halide and high pressure sodium lamps - all used for plant growth.

As long as it wasn't an incandescent plant lamp, you have a decent plant light. Don't worry. Keep reading posts here and you'll know what to buy next.

Zink


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Zink, I know that all fluorescent bulbs contain phosphors, but I'm that kind of a nerd who gets all thrilled by technical words. I use a phosphorimager in my work sometimes, and it's fun. Therefore "phosphor" on the bulb wrapper meant "fun" to me.

I bought GE plant/aquarium bulbs, which supposedly have relatively more of the wavelengths that plants (or, more specifically chlorophyll) like. I know my little cactus seedlings greened up within hours and that they are growing like crazy.

Even though I know my setup isn't THE most energy-efficient rig, I'm planning to add another light to another shelf this weekend, because now I have too many things that will want the light. I also don't begrudge the money, even if misspent, because gardening is my chief weakness/hobby.


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

I had the most wonderful time combing the GE, Sylvania and Philips/Osram websites looking for data on fluorescent plant lights. I read up on rare earths, the difference between wide-spectrum and "regular" plant lights, looked at the graphs of wavelength distributions, and was also happy to realize that I chose the correct sort of bulb for seed-starting.

Lisa


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

While everyone is getting their lights and shelves set up, may I suggest you go to Wal-Mart and pick up a few of the silver mylar 'emergency blanket/wraps' they sell. These are what runners put on after a marathon, etc. Hang them over the rack and you'll keep light and heat inside the box. Couple of bucks each, and unlike the bulbs, these will last forever.

Andrew


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

thebard (or anyone else), could you please describe how you set up the little computer fan inside your seed-starting shelf unit? i found some small computer fans on american science and surplus (www.sciplus.com), but i'm not sure what you'd plug it into. i'm a little limited in the techie department, so if it doesn't plug into a normal 2-3 prong wall outlet i'm at a loss. thanks!


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Here's a seed-starting rack similar to the one posted by angelstiger. Re Andrew's idea (space blankets), just make sure you vent them or leave an opening so you don't bake the plants.

Here is a link that might be useful: Seed starting rack


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

I got a second light installed on my shelves this weekend. I'd planned to do it sooner, but then I went and injured my wrist and couldn't do it. My wrist is all better (well, better enough to stand up to pounding on shelves with a rubber mallet to move and re-seat them, and better enough to balance the shoplight fixture with one hand while I attached the chains and s-hooks).

Lisa


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Would it be necessary to cover the rack with some sort of insulating
material if I am planning on using a heated seed starting mat? I am
interested in starting my seeds in a rather cool basement and keeping them
there until they are ready for hardening off.

Any help would be appreciated!

Thanks,

Manfred


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Manfred,

I probably wouldn't cover the rack with insulating material, at least not for any period of time, because after the plants come up, they need some air circulation for health and to avoid damping off.

I use small electric fans to provide a little artificial breeze. That makes the seedlings sturdier. I mount several overdriven fluorescent fixtures rather close to my plants to give them a lot of light and the fixtures themselves provide some warmth.

Your nighttime temperature is another question. Do you have a thermometer in your basement and what does it read at night?

MM


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

I don't have a thermometer, but I don't think the basement is lower than 58 or 59 at night.

Thanks!


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

58 should be OK for a nighttime temp. It's a little cool. Just set your timer for no more than an 8-hour "night". And try to keep your fluorescent bulbs no farther than a couple of inches from the upper leaves. If you have a lot of fluorescent lights going, they will tend to take the chill off of your basement.

MM


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

The one thing I'm still curious about is an electric seed starting mat. Do you think I should shut this off once the seeds have sprouted or keep this on to keep the plants warm?


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Manfred,

Until you learn otherwise, leave the heat mat(s) in place and on until such time as you transplant the seedlings to larger containers. You are growing in a rather cool basement, and the heating mats might be helpful for an extended time, depending on the type of seedlings you are growing.

If I were in your place, I would get an inexpensive thermometer and place it near your seedlings to get some idea about their thermal environment, both day and night. If either temperature is significantly below the preferences of the particular seedlings you are growing, then sustained use of the heating mat could be helpful.

Look up the temperature preferences of the seedlings you are starting. Some like it warm while others prefer cooler temperatures and might find your basement to their liking without any extra warmth.

MM


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Another thing you could try, which someone mentioned on another topic, is to have the plants' period of darkness during the day, so that they'll have the warming benefit of the lights at night. Or you could stagger the "nights" for the seeds, so that one shelf is dark from 10 pm to 6 am and the other is dark from 10 am to 6 pm.


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

What about taking that Emergency Blanket and just velcroing it to the backside of the wire-shelving unit? I suppose doing the sides as well would be good too but I want to know what you think.

Then you will have the front open but have the great reflective properties of the blankets shining light back on the plants.

If you then did some kind of screening on the front it would keep out any bugs

I am a TOTAL nube at this and want to start something in my office and this forum has the best ideas Ive found yet!


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Hello,
I want to start my seeds in my garage, but it is cold at night right now, (about 40 deg). Anyone have suggestions on how to keep the seeds warm? I was thinking of a heat mat, but not sure.
Thanks,
Chris


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

  • Posted by rokal LongIsland/z6b (My Page) on
    Sun, Jan 6, 08 at 9:02

gardentech,

You could run the lights at night and turn them off during the day. The heat from the lights will add extra warmth.

Regards,

Rokal


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

My 2 cents regarding heat mats is use an electric blanket instead of an expensive heat mat. I use an electric blanket and love it. I start around 1500 pepper seeds each season and the electric blanket is the best (cheap) investment I have made as far as soil heat.

Again, just my 2 cents!


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Chris,

"Anyone have suggestions on how to keep the seeds warm? I was thinking of a heat mat, but not sure."

I use heating mats and I also got a thermostat to turn off the heat mats in case it gets too warm. As Rokal said, your fluorescent lights can produce quite a bit of heat themselves, particularly if you use humidity domes to keep the seed trays moist. The heat from the fluorescent lights can "build up" under the humidity domes. I discovered that the temperature got as high as 95 F under tall humidity domes that were under overdriven fluorescents, so I used some of my normally driven fluorescent fixtures instead, and the temperature dropped to about 80. As soon as your seedlings get their "true leaves" you probably should remove the humidity domes, but then you will need to keep a much closer watch to make sure they don't run short of water.

I personally wouldn't recommend using an electric blanket, because it isn't designed for operating in a seed starting environment. If something went wrong, like an electrical short or a fire, the electric blanket could be a false economy.

MM


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Thank you all for sharing this information here! I am looking into getting a seedling shelf set up for my husbands birthday. One question, though: what about the danger of electrocution? How do you safely water your plants without also watering the various lights and heating pads beneath them? (I assume the plants are on trays, and are either taken off the shelves for watering, or are just watered veeery carefully?) Thanks!


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Stoloniferous,

"...what about the danger of electrocution?"

It's a legitimate concern. I am careful to water my plants so that overflow doesn't drip down onto the shoplights below. And I do use trays to catch any overflow or seepage. And I do seal any holes in the top of my shoplights with white electrical tape (white just for appearance) to keep any water coming from above out of them.

But if you feel uneasy about this, you might want to invest in a commercial plant stand. They do, however, cost considerably more than the units we have discussed here.

16 Tray, 4 Tier Light Stand, w/ Timer

Ultimate 16 Tray Light Stand Combo

MM


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Thank you for the information maineman!

Oy, every one of those commercial plant stands I've looked at has been more expensive than the last.


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

  • Posted by yster Minneapolis, MN (My Page) on
    Sat, Feb 16, 08 at 13:52

Thanks for the insight provided by this thread. As a grower wanting to start some special seedlings for the salsa crop this year, I can't express how incredible you all are for coming up with the best logical solutions to otherwise expensive problems.

Thanks again!


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Hi, I currently have an old flourecetlight on a wire shelf too. Did u getyour fixtures for just 8 dollars...everywere i see they are at least 30 buck for a double tube.

Where did u get the fixtures?

Thanks


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

seedsavr,

I get my Commercial Electric Shoplights (model 732-334) from Home Depot. So far, they have cost about $8 each.

MM


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

To save costs I bought two heating pads to use under my seedling tray...I couldnt find the ones that continually run, these have an automatic two hour shut off.
I was thinking of cutting out the switch and splice the wires together. Is there a safer way to disable the automatic shut off?
I also built the seed starting rack as posted by nygardener. $35.00 worth of material.. 6 2x4's ripped in half then cut to length, left over stain from a previous project and half a day constructing it and it looks awesome...I can't wait to use it.


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Hi, and thanks. I found the light and am thrilled... now ill have even more space for seedlings.

One quick question (Im not sure if this is a correct post...) I dont have enough room under my lights for all the plants i attended on growing. What plants are tolerant of lower light (from a window)? thanx


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Thanks so much for this cheap setup. I want to do it. I have a question: If I grow seedlings under these lights, do they even need to be next to a window, or will there be enough light just from the artificial lights alone?


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Several years ago I made a set up from stuff I had lying around and scrounged up. You can get quite inventive with old wood pallets. Most grocery stores in my area have stacks of these out back. Ask and you can usually get a couple. Half pallets work fantastic as these fit flats perfectly.

As for heating the set up. I put my shelves in the corner of the basement and hung some old blankets up to make a small room. I then just put a small ceramic heater in there. It had a thermostat built right into it. With just a bit of experimentation I was able to keep the entire area at a comfy 80 degrees all sprouting season. I even got the shop lites second hand from Craigs list. Built the whole thing for under $50. Started several hundred plants that way.

I've moved since then but plan on starting this back up again next spring and selling some seedlings at the local farmers market. Our new house has plenty more space and I've got a cool new idea on free (or nearly) organic pots to try too.


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Sorry to sound so dumb, but WHAT does "overdriven" mean?


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Pushing more watts through the bulbs. Type overdriven in the search box toward the bottom of the growing under lights forum page for more info. That search box will have a search in this forum option.
Well I hate being an enabler but here's the search results

Here is a link that might be useful: overdriven search


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Hi - Two questions
1. There are several references to the Home Depot Model732-334 fluorescent light. Any idea of the updated model number? I can't find any 732-334.

2. Someone mentioned a seed starter rack posted by "nygardener". Any idea where I can find that posting? Or any other good home made wooden racks?

Any help would be appreciated. The snow is melting up here in Maine and thoughts turn to gardens.

Al


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

I'm thinking of getting some lights for my seedling that are in my basement. They do get some natural light from a window but not much.

I like this set up

The question I have is will there be a big difference between using the homedepot lights (gro=lux) or not, compared to a t5 sunblaster with 4 bulbs in it.

The cost for that light/fixture alone is approx 150 cdn.

I'm trying to grow annuals and will move them to the greenhouse in april.

Or.. will I be fine with the homedepot setup?

Thanks


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

GoGoJuice

There is no need to spend $150.00 for a light fixture to grow your plants.

Since you're in Canada, if you want, you could head over to Rona, and get yourself some shoplights for about $27.00 each. The ones I bought already have T8 cool whites in them.

Also, you'll probably want a timer so you don't have to turn them off every night. =:)

Because I like to experiment, I also bought grow light tubes which I'm going to use. Then I can see for myself if there's any difference between T8 cool whites, and what they sell as grow lights for a lot more money.

Good luck with your plants =:)


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System . . .

GoGo Juice

Oops. I see from another post you already bought lights.


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

If you have a florescent tube fixture (old fashion shop lights that hold two tubes) just make sure you have a cool light tube and a warm light tube. These will emit light rays from both ends of the color spectrum (like the sun).


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

No need to mix bulbs. They're all full spectrum and you wont see any change in growth over the slight difference. Get any cheap bulbs that are 4100-6500k in color.


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

As far as shop lights go, do you prefer the ones with reflectors or not? Because the ones with reflectors/chains with which to hang them are NOT $8 and I've been all over my area going to every sort of hardware store I can think of to compare prices. It is either inflation at work or stores no longer carry whatever shop lights everyone has talked about in the past lol

The only "shop lights" for uber-cheap that I've seen are the ones that need to be drilled into the wall, i.e. "under cabinet" lighting.

But, since I shall have nothing to do today I'm going to try to purchase a cheap set of wire shelving and one shop light and bulbs. I was thinking of waiting two weeks (basically, until my next check) but some of my plants are growing very well and will need to be transplanted and have more space than what I currently have set up.


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

My $10 fixtures have reflectors. They're small but they do work. Chain is cheap enough to buy separately. You may want longer chains than what they supply anyway.


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

For managing all the plugs (lights, heat mats, fan), I mounted this vertically. I've found it very useful for a tall setup.

Here is a link that might be useful: Power Strip


 o
RE: Inexpensive Seed Starting System

Looks like another way to overload a socket to me. I use 2 smaller ones ($20) in 2 separate sockets.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Growing under Lights Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here