RATING FINGERLING POTATOES

i'm considering raising fingerling potatoes. would like to get your impressions on which are the best ones. could you please rate the following varieties for taste on a 1[poor] to 5 [excellent] basis, with 3 being average:

austrian crescent

french fingerling

russian banana

laratte

ozette

purple peruvian

peanut [swedish peanut,butterfinger]

red thumb

rose finn/fir apple [ruby crescent]

ALSO: please feel free to comment on:

ease of growing

shelf life

disease

do they come back year after year

and other considerations

thanks,

dean