Return to the Minnesota Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Climbing roses

Posted by jennypat Zone 3b NW MN (My Page) on
Fri, Sep 8, 06 at 12:07

Can anyone recommend a climbing rose that is hardy here in MN? Specifically zone 3 hardy. I have an old tv antennea tower in my yard, and would like to plant some clematis and roses on it.

Thanks!
Jenny P


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Climbing roses

How about John Davis? I have this one I just planted it this year it's growing really nice It will have flowers on it next season can't wait to see them.


 o
RE: Climbing roses

or William Baffin. Mine burned to the ground a couple of years ago (long story) and is back to 8 feet. I never cover or protect it in any way. Some people say it suckers too much, but mine never has.

Kevin


 o
RE: Climbing roses

  • Posted by john_w Z4a Minn, US (My Page) on
    Mon, Sep 11, 06 at 9:15

I just de-Baffinated my yard this spring and spent two hours Saturday vanquishing 'John Cabot.' These are really, big, lusty, shrub roses with long canes. They spread and sucker all over the place. Amazing spring (scentless) bloom with a few little flowers thereafter. If you attempt these for climbers, be assured they will pull you antenna out of the ground in five years. Be prepared for a lot of work with Baffin.

The recommendation for 'John Davis' is good. That one reblooms a lot and the canes are almost thornless. Even better is the old rose 'Lillian Gibson.' That one has such profuse flowers, long, supple, thornless canes. And Lillian has the added bonus of red canes and amazing fall foliage color (bright yellow).


 o
RE: Climbing roses

I've got a Baffin and it pretty much tore apart the trellis I had for it. I've let it grow into a massive shrub now instead of trying to get it to climb on something. It has a spectacular display, like a giant fountain of roses with a fairly long blooming season. I like it because all I have to do is cut out a few dead canes every once in a while.


 o
RE: Climbing roses

  • Posted by jel48 Z3/4 Minnesota (My Page) on
    Tue, Jan 2, 07 at 22:42

I have two Baffins, which I planted summer before last. I didn't get anything in place for them to climb last summer, but my intention is to add an arbor. I take it from your update, that I'd better not go with a flimsy trellis ;-)


 o
RE: Climbing roses

I think my Baffin has put out 1 sucker in 8 years. Still love the thing.


 o
RE: Climbing roses

I have had 'Ramblin Red' climbing shrub rose for two years now and think it's the best climber I have ever had. It is a zone 3, no die back, and absolutely best of all, blooms all summer. Got it at Gertens in Inver Grove Heights.


 o
RE: Climbing roses

Greetings All,

It's been awhile since I've had time to frequent this forum. I have several great climbers:

John Davis
John Cabot
Henry Kelsey
William Baffin
Lilian Gibson
Ramblin Red

I love all of them. The only one I can't seem to get to climb which I've had since it first came out is Ramblin Red. But we have had drought conditions which might be playing a big part of that.

I would really like to find more climbers that would survive up here. I am going to the National Rose Convention there in Minnesota this summer. I hope I can find some really nice hardy roses. Are any of you going?


 o
RE: Climbing roses

William Baffin is a great climber, very prolific. I don't have one myself, but a relative has it and its full of roses. I have the Ramblin Red. The horticulturist at Bachman's recommended it. Put it in last spring, and got several flushes. It was basically wanting to bloom toward the bottom and not on the tall canes. I'm going to stagger the cane's heights this summer so there will be more new growth. I was told it was a great bloomer / and it is everblooming / but I'm hold my blessings till summer's end.


 o
RE: Climbing roses

LOL Of all the roses that have been recommended here, the one I am most interested in is: Lilian Gibson I like the color of this one. I think it would look great with a jackmani Clematis.

Of course I can't find any where to purchase it! Any recommendations?

Jenny P


 o
RE: Climbing roses

I LOVE Ramblin Red! Climbers usually take 3 years to settle in and really show what they can do. Last summer was the third for my RR and all I can say is wow! Mine is well over 10 feet wide by easily 8 feet tall. Just for reference the fence in this picture is 6' high.

Are there enough blooms????


 o
RE: Climbing roses

That looks great! To bad I don't want a red rose. I already have 2 red roses in my gardens. I really want something different.

Jenny P


 o
RE: Climbing roses

  • Posted by john_w Z4a Minn, US (My Page) on
    Thu, Feb 22, 07 at 11:49

North Creek Farm sells Lillian via mail order. The place is run by Suzy Verrier, the author of the famous rose books, 'Rosa Gallica' and 'Rosa Rugosa'

http://www.northcreekfarm.org/Rose-2.html

A similar rose to 'Lillian Gibson' is '"Victorian Memory' ('Isabella Skinner') only this one repeat blooms and is scented. Has fuller flowers than Lillian, too. I have no experience with this one, but will probably order this one from High Country Roses.

Here is a link that might be useful: Link to High Country Roses


 o
RE: Climbing roses

I have quite a few Lillian Gibsons. They are my easiest rose to propagateI've had cuttings root in ten daysand they grow fast as well. They are a blessing for Minnesota rose lovers. The only problem, if it IS a problem, is that it blooms only once, in mid-spring, but then on long arching and (as someone noted above) beautiful canes. GaryStPaul


 o
RE: Climbing roses

If you're not opposed to mailorder, this is a great website. http://www.heirloomroses.com/index.htm

They have a section specifically for hardy roses, as well as a section for climbing roses, and any other type of rose you might want. I'm thinking of getting New Dawn for the side of my dilapidated garage. It's described as a silvery blush pink, but it only goes to zone 4.

Here is a link that might be useful: Heirloom roses


 o
RE: Climbing roses

I am not opposed to mail order but cannot find Lillian Gibson at the Heirloom site. And the North Creek Farm web site has the rose listed. But they don't have any contact information! A really nice list, but no way to order! That could be a problem.

Jenny P


 o
RE: Climbing roses

Jenny P: Here's an address for A North Creek Farm.

I wonder if a zone 4 would come back for you if it was mulched?

Heirloom Roses has the John Davis and William Baffin, but as you said it doesn't have Lillian Gibson.

Here is a link that might be useful: North Creek Farm


 o
RE: Climbing roses

Okay, one more posting and I'll leave you be! I just love to research on the web.

This website has a way to search for roses by zone. Just click on catalog, then zone, then your zone number. They have the Lillian Gibson.

Here is a link that might be useful: Rosefarm


 o
RE: Climbing roses

HMM I swear I answered this yesterday, but I must not have posted it or something.

Anyway, I am on the border of zone 3&4 and have a lot of zone 4 plants in my garden. I think a zone 4 rose will work.

I keep thinking I want a climber, and that I don't want a red one. But as I look more, I see lots of other choices!

Now I am just confusing myself!

Jenny P


 o
RE: Climbing roses

Hey Twohuskies! That is a lovely Ramblin Red. Any special care? Mine will start year two this spring & I would love to be so successful with it. I composted it good late last fall & give it a good rose food from Bachman's. Your picture gives me hope, I already had no luck with a Clematis in the same spot, don't want to flunk out with this one too. So far the roses like to stay close to the ground. Any suggestions?


 o
RE: Climbing roses

Does John Cabot have a fragrance? I've been contemplating getting this rose for years and it's always described as being fairly fragrant yet every posting I've read on it says it has no scent.... The same thing about William Baffin, it's always described as having a scent but the few I've come across in nurseries have absolutely no fragrance.

Does Rambin Red have a fragrance?

It's an idiosyncrasy of mine that I won't have a rose that does not have a fragrance.


 o
RE: Climbing roses

  • Posted by john_w Z4a Minn, US (My Page) on
    Fri, Mar 9, 07 at 17:10

Cabot and Baffin are scent-free. None. Nein. Niether does 'Ramblin Red.' The last one is a beautiful rose, however. I share your opinion of 'numb' roses.

I am giving a presentation on roses at tomorrow's MN State Horticultural Society's Seventh District Spring Fling. I'll be talking about the choices and trade offs we must make for roses, and then I'll show pictures of good roses, some of where have it all (scent, hardiness, repeat bloom, color). I'm on deck at 2:00

Specifically:


7th District East Metro Spring Fling
Saturday, Mar. 10, 8:30 a.m. to 3 p.m.
Oakland Junior High School, 820 Manning Ave. E., Lake Elmo.
$30 fee includes gardening seminars and hot lunch.

651-653-7371, 651-779-7826 or crabbysister4@gmail.com.

Here is a link that might be useful: MSHS calendar of events (Spring)


 o
RE: Climbing roses

Drat! Everything is either to far south for me, or happens when I have to be out of town on business! John what would you recommend for a rose, with a scent, one that could be trained on a trellis, preferably not red, but more towards apricot(or yellow, I looking for the complimentary color for a Jackmani clematis) for zone 3b. Full sun all day long!

Jenny P


 o
RE: Climbing roses

  • Posted by john_w Z4a Minn, US (My Page) on
    Fri, Mar 9, 07 at 22:16

Clematis 'Jackmanii' can go with a lot of colors: clear pink, white, warm yellows and oranges. Red, maybe, but probably not. Certainly not magenta.

Okay, I'll be right up front and tell you there are no warm colored, hardy, scented roses, for a trellis in zone 3 unless you were willing to take the rose down and bury it each fall. If you can to do this, than I would recommend 'Autumn Sunset' or its sport-sibling 'Westerland.' These are great, fragrant roses that are hardier than most tender roses, but even so, will die to the ground in a zone 4 winter unless buried.

A substitute may be the hybrid rugosa 'Agnes.' This one is really a twiggy, arching shrub with fragrant flowers of pale amber. Hardy in zone 3 and healthy too, but there are two catches: its rebloom is scattered if it happens at all; and it's a really shrub you must train (read: fight) into a short climber. There's a method to this, but it is a lot of work and vigilance to force a rose into a corset, so to speak. I have a friend in Milwaukee who does grow Agnes this way and his does do an autumn encore. I grew it for a few years as a shrub that bloomed once a year.

I grow 'Graham Thomas' as a perennial rose. It repeats a lot and meets all your requirements, but it is a five footer by the end of the season. In zone 6 and points south, it is a hardy climber.

Another option is to use a pink or white rose as is mentioned above. I'll vote again for 'Vctorian Memories' as a good repeater and true climber habit with nice scent.

Warm colored, hardy, repeat climbing roses are the holy grail of nothern rosarians. God and science have yet to deliver one. I have hunted down and rooted what I hope is a cutting of the near-extinct hardy yellow climber, 'Doubloons.' It's resting in a pot for the winter. This spring it goes into the ground. Check back in three years and I'll tell you how it does.


 o
RE: Climbing roses

Cosmo- regarding Ramblin Red, no I don't give it any special care. It's in the back corner of my yard behind 4 foot chicken wire (to keep the dogs out!) and next to very aggressive raspberry bushes. Basically it's a nightmare to get back there to it. I don't do anything at all for winter protection and it's fine. I also don't spray for diseases since it's next to the berry patch and it does fine. I will admit though that RR gets sun the entire day and 7 years ago there was a huge elm tree removed from my yard in that corner so there is a large amound of decomposing tree roots back there. I think that has made for some very happy soil and most likely a very happy rose...

As a comparison I have Henry Kelsey, one of RR's parents, planted on the other side of the yard and after 3 years he looks nowhere near as nice. With HK I've only gotten a few 5 foot canes and he's had plenty of time to settle in. In this case a slightly less than ideal location may be to blame.


 o
RE: Climbing roses

I went to Bachmans over the weekend and inside their greenhouse area they already had a bunch of potted roses... They had Ramblin Rose, John Cabot and Henry Kelsey...they were $21.99 each.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Minnesota Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here