Return to the Midwest Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

Posted by jamlover z4 Iowa (My Page) on
Tue, Jan 11, 05 at 11:52

I am just getting into shrubs. Have lots of perennials and would like to add shrubs to the beds. Am interested in knowing your best fragrant shrubs for zone 5 or colder.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

It's hard for most Midwesterners not to think of lilacs, and they're among my favorites too, but for that first hit of spring perfume, I really like my viburnum. I used to have a star magnolia I really liked the scent of too, and while mock oranges smell divine later in the season, I've never found them to be the world's most dependable bloomers. People keep saying that witchhazel smells nice, but I'm never all that interested in tromping through the snow to sniff them up.


 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

I like my:

- Buddleia fallowiana 'Lochinch' (considered the most fragrant butterfly bush by many posters in another forum).

-Syringa meyerii 'Pallibin' (small leaved Lilac, no problem with powdery mildew).

-Viburnum juddii is considered the most fragrant. Mine is still too small. Has not bloomed yet.

-Forthegilla gardenii 'Mt. Airy' (sp?) has slight fragrance, but beautiful fall foliage.

I also planted other non fragrant shrubs that give long fall/winter interest like Redtwig dogwood, Red/orange/yellow twig dogwood, Viburnum with red berries, snowberry, Beautyberry, forsythia, Pussy willow, Curly willow, Coral Embers willow.

If I had room, I would plant more varieties of Viburnum with berries, winterberries & witch hazel as well as winter honeysuckle (Lonicera fragrantissima)..... but those are only on my wish list as I no longer have room in my garden. :-(

Happy gardening.


 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

Pitimpinai, What color is that buddleia? Hope it is also one of the more hardy ones!! And a lilac without mildew!! Bring it on. Color?
Stinkypink, any particular mock orange or viburnum? I'm really on the line between zone 4 and 5 so not so far removed.


 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

I love lilacs. I have two wonderful varieties: Miss Kim and Donald Wyman. Both are disease free and have a great fragrance.


 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

I wish I knew which viburnum I have--it's been at this house much longer than I have, and I imagine it's some really common variety that's been sold for 20 years or more. It's next to a very lovely, old, floriferous kolkwitzia/beauty bush, which I'm also very fond of despite its lack of fragrance. My viburnum doesn't have the great berries or fall color that many currently in-favor varieties boast, but it is loaded with sweet, blushed flowers at just about the time in the year you want to start opening windows. The only mock orange I have right now is a variegated one--very attractive, and so far it's flowered lightly though it's still young. A place like Forest Farm or other exhaustive catalog can give rundowns on different varieties.


 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

Buddleia 'Lochinch' has sky blue flowers with an orange eye. The flowers are not as big as others, say 'Black Knight', but bloom continuously until hard frost. I don't think it dies back either.

The small leaved lilac has dark pink flowers. It blooms later than Syringa vulgaris. It blooms very young. I got mine as 6" cuttings from a friend and the little cuttings bloomed the very next spring!


 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

Butterfly bush...um, wish it was blooming now. Toni


 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

Azalea " Rosy Lights" or "Jane Abbott" when in Bloom-

Korean Spice Viburnum "Carlesii".


 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

Vinurnum carlesii
Viburnum carlcephalum
Viburnum x burkwoodii
Daphne x burkwoodii
Calycanthis 'Athens'


 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

Kevin;

Viburnums?? could you expand on:
Which one has the strongest scent, and so on; Reading Dirr's does not shed a light as to which one I want to buy.

thks.


 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

tadeusz,

There's a thread in the shrubs forum called 'Fragrant Viburnum Sniff-Off' where the scent of various viburnums
was discussed. It appears that's there was a tie between Korean Spice carlesii and judii.


 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

Does anyone know ___is the compact v.carlesii compacta with a mature height of only 4 foot as fragrant as the foot taller Korean Spice?


 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

Tad:

The V. carlesii hybrids duke it out with the V. x burkwoodii group for fragrance. Even the V. carlesii 'Compactum' packs a huge fragrant wallop for a small plant. I like my V. x burkwoodii 'Chenaultii' the best among the cultivars in these two groups. V. x juddii is also excellent. For best fragrance, and unfortunately the worst form, V. x carlcephalum is the absolute best to my nose. Any of these related types, though, is a pleasure to sniff. Pick your plant on size and overall form.


 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

Gotta be Korean Spice Viburnum for a 'knock your socks off' fragrance! We've had one at our last two houses ... one in Omaha where it can get as cold as -25 (if that's zone 4, I'd hate to be in zone 2 or 3!) and it never missed a year in blooming profusely. It will perform well, even in shade or partial shade!


 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

Clethra alnifolia and its named varieties for July-August fragrant blooms.


 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

Jamlover: Don't forget mock orange; the scent is heavenly. I recommend Phildelphus coronaria variegata, which can be found at Arrowhead Alpines.


 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

Jamlover: A picture can be found below.

Here is a link that might be useful: Philadelphus coronaria variegata


 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

mysteryrose, thanks for posting the link. Gorgeous mockorange. I planted a variegated one last year. Forgot now if it is the same cultivar. Hope it is as pretty.


 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

Korean Spice Viburnum "Carlesii" is by far my favorite, and currently blooming right now in front of my house! I am wondering why of the 4 Carlesii I have in front, 3 have lots of blooms, and 1 of them is sporting just one small bloom!?! If I recall, that same shrub had 1 or no blooms last year. Is there anything I can do to encourage more blooms in the V.Carlesii for next year?


 o
RE: Favorite best scented shrubs for zone 5 or colder

Lilacs, Peonies, and of course, Roses~


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Midwest Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here