We picked up our barrels for less than $10 at Rural King. Now, we're in Muncie and not Indy, but I think you probably have a Rural King somewhere in the area. Might want to check them out. If you can't find one, a Tractor Supply or similar farm supply-type store would probably carry them. Good luck, I love my rain barrel!

Thanks! Looks like the closest Rural Kings to Indy are in Columbus, New Castle & Martinsville. Their website shows 55 gal barrels for $9.99. Groovy. (Weirdly the TSC website didn't show these, I was kinda surprised.)

Also got an email from Indyrose that I can also find them for $15-20 at
B & B Box & Drum Inc
1527 Miller Street, Indianapolis, IN 46221

Thanks for the help!

I have some I'm selling - see this posting: http://indianapolis.backpage.com/MiscForSale/_60_rain_barrel/classifieds/ViewAd?oid=1462991