skip to main content

No odor in Illicium floridanum?

13 years ago

I have one established and two new (still in pots) I. floridanum. They were bought from different sources and at different times.

None of the flowers have an offensive odor. Why not? It's an important question because I want to plant the new ones next to the house. Does the amount of sun, fertilizer, temp, anything affect the presence of the odor that is reported?

Should I cross-post this question on another forum?

Thanks for any help.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

sarahbn
13 years ago
They don't have a bad odor it's more like a mild anise odor I have two plants
Iris GW
13 years ago
Lucky! They can be very stinky, according to my sense of smell.
Related Discussions
Illicium Floridanum
Q
Comments (1)
I, too, love the smell of my floridanum's leaves, and it's been a very tough, forgiving plant -- I never brought mine inside all winter, just covered it in its container -- but I don't try to smell the flowers either! Nice picture! Jim
...See More
Illicium floridanum
Q
Comments (0)
I would be very grateful, if someone,could send me some seeds ,or better cuttings,of this little gem named "Illicium floridanum " (the red or the white one)! Thank you in advance phil
...See More
Illicium simonsii - anyone have experience with it?
Q
Comments (6)
Well it had to be Behnkes or American Plant Food (or whatever they are called these days?) So which is it? IIRC I've seen this listed as 8-9 only somewhere. You'd think a local nursery of that type (aimin' to be high falutin' LOL) would want to avoid a bunch of returns, so maybe they know something the rest of us don't. I'm only moderately interested: I think Illicium henryi satisfies most of my Asian anise tree needs and it is known to be rock hardy for a BLE. (survived in central PA at Barry Yinger's garden) The wan flower color of this one looks like it would be hard to spot from a distance. High elevation from China is tricky - depends where in China. Really far to the SW like Yunnan province, you can go pretty high and it's still zone 9 or even 10. Somewhere I've seen pictures of some ridiculously tropical looking palms at over 5000' on the border with Myanmar.
...See More
Illiciums are struggling in my garden
Q
Comments (14)
pH of 7.4 is just a little above neutral, so not bad for many plant species. BTW, if compost from an area having more or less neutral pH soil is tested for its pH, it will generally be right around the same range as the area's soil. Some folks think compost is always highly acidic. In fact, it rarely is, and then only if strongly acidic feedstocks were used in its prep. +oM
...See More
Phylla
13 years ago
Good question. The leaves of Illicium floridatum have an appealling anise scent to most noses, except deer, hurray! The maroon flowers, however, have a divided consensus. I use it, when in bloom on garden walks, as an illustration of how scent can be quite subjective. I ask participants to smell the flower, and weigh in on it's appeal. It is unfailingly about half and half with people who find it attractive vs "Yeccchhhh!".

I find it attractive, kind of salty and citrusy, "like the beach", and others concur. The other half, including Dr. Dirr, find it stinky like wet dogs or old socks.

I'd guess you'd have to find which half you're in to determine where to plant it. Beyond that, it's an incredibly useful plant for evergreen shady screening, and should be used more.
canishel
Original Author
13 years ago
Thanks to all of you.
I can smell the anise leaves and like it. The flowers have almost no odor.
I went ahead and planted them at a corner next to the house. We'll see what happens.

Related Stories

GARDENING GUIDES 10 Top Native Plants for the U.S. Southeast

By Falon Mihalic

For a low-maintenance and wildlife-friendly landscape, use Southern natives that withstand heat and humidity

GARDENING GUIDES 10 Solutions for Soggy Soil

By Steve Asbell

If a too-wet garden is raining on your parade, try these water-loving plants and other ideas for handling all of that H2O

Sponsored