SHOP PRODUCTS
Houzz Logo Print
midwesternerr

Understanding Resistance to Native landscaping

midwesternerr
15 years ago

One can plant single speciman native plants without raising any eyebrows. However, the problem occurs when one restores a plant community back to health. I've done some qualitative thinking on the subject, and I think I have come to a basic understanding of the reasons some wish to( and often successfully do) oppress those would-be restorationists.

There is a non-conscious ideology at work. People with conventional landscapes do not realize the environment(community) is hostile, because the environment is not hostile to them. Imagine a fish, it doesn't even think about being in water until it is thrown out of the water. As the most progressive towns begin to restrict chemical applications, suddenly these lawn loving fish find themselves thrown out of water. It seems that only then may they understand the oppression that many (if not most) restorationists have experienced. EVen when oppression is aknowledged, it is often confused.

Conflation occurs when looking at restorations. That is the landscape design may not be rejected for its own sake, but for what it is confused to mean about its creator. Restorations may be associated with drug-using hippies who "want to be one with the flowers and animals, man". The landscape choice may be seen as an attack on traditional American, flag-waiving, Eurocentric & Christian values which have all been wrapped up in the visions of white picket fences and mown lawns. Thus, there is an othering effect to any landscape choice that departs from this traditional style that automatically makes restorationists suspect of supporting changes to the dominant culture.

A major problem also occurs from a lack of education. Some may legitimately object to restorations due to a lack of ecological understanding. They see any plant community as "out of control" and "negligent". In cases where invasive and noxious weeds grow willy nilly this even makes sense to wish to suppress these seed sources. However, a restored plant community is anything but negligent. Due to habitat alteration, most restorations will require great planning and initial maintennance. There will also likely be considerable cost involved even if one does the physical labor herself. The reeducation of suburbia will have to involve discussion on what is truly more damaging to the community, chemical runoff from lawns and neatly mulched exotic plants or groups of plants that are allowed to grow where they are best suited.

Comments (8)

Sponsored
Industry Leading Landscape Contractors in Franklin County, OH