Return to the New England Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
allergy free garden?

Posted by blaketaylore (My Page) on
Sun, Aug 14, 11 at 12:17

Hello All,

My allergies have been really combatant this season. This morning I went out to pick yet ANother basket of summer sqaush, tomatoes, string beans, and one cumcumber and one egglant, when suddenly I could not stop sneezing. It was really bad. I couldn't get in the house fast enough. In that particular bed that I was weeding and harvesting from had my nicotina plants in it. That was the only difference I could see. So I came in and searched allergies to Nicotinia plants and came across this:

The Asthma Friendly Garden

By: Tom Ogren

One of the main keys with asthma prevention is avoidance.

When you have asthma the typical garden is not a very friendly place at all. There are mold spores to contend with and worst of all is the pollen. Typical gardens and landscapes have pollen producing male trees and male shrubs and other plants that can provoke asthma attacks. Almost anyone with asthma will tell you that their asthma can be triggered by a good number of things, but pollen is often number one for causing an attack. Garden allergies are very common, but they need not be. Allergies from gardening could largely be a thing of the past�but only if we are willing to make some simple changes.

In fall of 1999 in Richmond, Virginia the American Lung Association of Virginia (ALAV) built a new Breathe Easy office and headquarters. They had this entire large building constructed with the latest innovations in green construction and sustainable design. No construction materials were used that would off-gas any harmful or toxic chemicals, no materials were used that would trigger asthma or allergies. Every attempt was made to build something that would be pleasant and healthy. I have given lectures at this office and the people who work there now will tell you that they all notice what a great improvement it is. Their previous headquarters had sick building syndrome issues and was surrounded by a typical high pollen landscape. But all that is changed now. Their office is a healthy building.

The ALA decided it made perfect sense to landscape their new healthy building (in many states these are now called Health Houses) with an allergy free landscape. OPALS (the plant/allergy 1-10 numerical ranking system) was used to select only plant materials that were either very low pollen, low allergy, or that were totally pollen free, allergy free. In effect they created the first true asthma friendly garden in the US.

Health Houses in other states are now also adding pollen free landscapes to their green construction, green buildings. A new Health House is about to be built in Pennsylvania, and the PA Association of Landscapers and Nurserymen is helping to landscape it with asthma friendly plant materials. Schools too are getting into the clean air act, and in the city of Visalia, California, the Tulare County Asthma Coalition recently directed the asthma friendly landscaping of a newly built elementary school.

Twelve keys to building your own asthma friendly garden:

1. Plant lots of female trees and female shrubs. Not only will these not shed any pollen, they will also trap a good deal of pollen that may stay in from somewhere else. Think of these female plants as nature's air cleaners.

2. Use only low pollen or no-pollen lawns. There are types of lawns now that are pretty well pollen free and these are a big improvement over some of the older lawn varieties. In southern states, if you have a common Bermuda grass lawn, consider replacing it with a newer, more asthma friendly hybrid Bermuda grass. 'Princess 77' is a new Bermuda grass hybrid that can be planted from seed. It is next to pollen free, grows very low and tight, and is especially good looking. There are also a good number of other pollen free Bermuda grass hybrids that can only be planted as sod. '609' buffalo grass is a new, all-female, pollen free native grass (now available as sod or plugs) that is low growing, attractive, and drought tolerant. In addition, most types of tall fescue sod will remain pollen free if mowed on a regular basis.

3. With OPALS 1 is best, 10 is worst. Use only plants with rankings of 1-5. The more plants in your gardens that have rankings ranging from 1-3, the friendlier your place will be for anyone with allergies or asthma. This plant-allergy scale is now used by many organizations for pollen reduction. OPALS has been used since 1999 by the USDA urban foresters in urban pollen projection models.

4. Remove any trees or shrubs with rankings over OPALS #7. The woody landscape plants with rankings of 8-10 are all sure-fire asthma-allergy triggering plants and you can live (better!) without them.

5. Replace any removed high pollen, asthma triggering plants with their opposite, female trees or female shrubs. Almost all ash, red maple, silver maple, box elder, yew, holly, mulberry, cedar, or juniper that produce seed, fruit or berries is a female plant. Also good as replacements are perfect flowered plants that are known to be very low pollen producers. Examples of low pollen, perfect flowered plants are plum, apricot, peach, camellia, hawthorn, and pomegranate trees. These will all have good (low) OPALS rankings.

6. Use only plants that are well adapted to your own area. If you can find natives that have low allergy rankings, consider using them. Look around your own neighborhood, and see for yourself, which kinds of plants seem to be flourishing there already. For almost every kind of plant used in landscaping, there is now a pollen-free or low pollen version of it, if you know what to look for.

7. Use a wide variety of plant materials; diversity is good. Biodiversity always makes sense. The more diverse our gardens are the fewer problems we'll have with insects and molds.

8. Avoid plants with strong fragrances or odors, as they can trigger asthma. Don't plant jasmines or similar strong-smelling vines next to entrances or exits and certainly don't use them underneath bedroom windows.

9. For mulch, use rock or gravel instead of bark to cut down on toxic mold spores in the garden. Flat stones or cement pavers also make excellent, mold free mulching materials.

10. To further eliminate mold spores, encourage wild birds in your garden. Virtually all wild birds eat insects, and insect damage triggers outbreaks of mold. Even the tiny hummingbirds actually eat a large number of insects. Put up a hummingbird feeder! Suet feeders in particular attract insect eating wild birds.

11. Keep your plants healthy. This too will cut down on both pollen and mold. When it is hot and windy, give your gardens a good deep soaking. Fertilize everything in your gardens both spring and fall. In the springtime nitrogen fertilizers are most needed. In late fall applications of fertilizer with ample amounts of potassium will aid in winter hardiness. If plants are crowding each other too much, thin them out. If tree branches overhead are putting your entire yard in deep shade, consider having the trees thinned hard to let in more light. Fresh air and light are the enemies of molds.

12. If a tree, shrub, vine or any other plant always looks sickly, looks dirty, or always attracts bugs, then shovel prune it. Dig it up and get rid of it. Replace it with something easier to grow. Don't get caught up in having to spray insecticides all the time, as they too can easily cause asthma and allergies. All too often asthma is initially triggered by exposure to a chemical insecticide or fungicide. If you must spray, try using a simple, safe mix of 3 tablespoons of vegetable oil, 2 tablespoons of dish soap, and two tablespoons of baking soda to a gallon of water. This spray will kill insects and it is an effective fungicide.

Make your garden a fun, stress free zone. Be sure to have a few comfortable garden chairs to sit in, and a little table of some sort is always good too. Wind chimes, bird feeders, and birdbaths are all stress-busters and can add greatly to your enjoyment. A beautiful, pollen free, allergy free, asthma friendly garden can be just the place for healthy children, and a great place for anyone to relax and enjoy the great outdoors. For more advice on low allergen gardening, look up allergy free gardening on the Internet, or go to your local library and read some books on this new important subject.

Webmaster: Bradshaw Web Design Updated 2009: Jerry Stanley

Copyright � 2009 Allergy

Does anyone have any expereince in making their gardens allergy free? I think I am going to have to rethink carefully what I can and cannot plant and I don't think I will plant nicotina again. I planted them becasue they are suppose to be a natural insectidine but obviously they have a very bad affect on me too!

Blake


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: allergy free garden?

I can sympathize with your predicament since I've had severe allergies since I was a kid, although not asthma. I would take some of the article above with a grain of salt, since for instance some maple trees have both male and female flowers, so would have seeds and pollen, or he treats all mold as one, but your allergies won't. I can't deal with mildew or penicillin, but have no issues with using organic mulches such as woodchips. You have to figure out what you react to and avoid it. In my case, DH waits to mow the lawn until I will be out of the house for several hours and he makes sure that all windows and doors are closed since grass is a major trigger for me. I have adjusted my life to avoid triggers and learned to jump in the shower and change clothes if I get into something by accident that makes me sneeze and itch. I would recommend allergy shots since my list of triggers is much shorter after a bunch of years of them and my quality of life much nicer. My view is that allergy-free gardening is an oxymoron, especially given that wind will blow microscopic allergens quite far, but that I can make choices that will reduce the impact of my allergies on my life.

I would tend to doubt that Nicotiana is the culprit for you. Most of the flowers that shed lots of pollen are wind pollenated, not insect or bird pollenated and have unobtusive flowers. In the spring much of the pollen is from trees (in my area oak, maple, and pine) in the summer, it's grasses, and now it's various herbaceous perennials. A flower like Nicotiana with its showy blossoms is insect and bird pollenated, while the wind pollenated blossoms tend to be small and greenish since they don't need to attract attention. Thus, many folks think that they are allergic to goldenrod (with showy blooms) while they are in fact allergic to ragweed which blooms while the goldenrod is blooming but with virtually invisible tiny green flowers, but lots of pollen. The other frequent allergen blooming right now is plantain, also having tiny green flowers. I have learned to wear gloves (and I wear long pants all summer since skin contact with grass, among other plants, gives me an allergic reaction) to pull these plants in my yard early in the season before they start blooming. I wouldn't be surprised if you look around the Nicotiana bed and find either ragweed or plantain nearby in bloom. Out of the growing season I rarely work in the garden on windy days since I've found that fungal spores like mildew are flying around more.

My best recommendation is to keep track of what seems to bother you and at what time of year and then do your best to avoid those things. Shower and change clothes if you find yourself sneezing or itching (to remove allergens) and don't handle the clothes after your shower - put them right into the washer. Have allergy testing done if it gets too bad, and/or talk to your doctor about medication if you feel the need. I've managed to accomodate, but if it gets too bad, find a different pasttime that will be healthier for you.


 o
RE: allergy free garden?

Hi nhbabs,

Thanks for the feedback. It will take some detective work. I do have plaintain in the yard. I will go through that bed again and see what else I can find in it.

Blake


 o
RE: allergy free garden?

I don't have to worry much about an allergy garden since I will never intentionally plant ragweed in my garden, hayfever being my only allergy. But, I just wanted to post that I regularly patrol my grounds for ragweed, and I swear when it's bloom time that stuff must be able to sprout a plant, complete with blooms, in a week.

nhbabs is right. Plants with completely unimpressive, if not almost invisible, flowers, like ragweed, compensate for their lack of attractiveness to bees and birds by creating thousands of spores to be spread by wind. Just one ragweed plant can be heinous. Look for weeds with boring flowers! Ragweed flowers are so boring they look like buds unless you look very closely, which I'm not fond of doing. But, I am thankful for that goldenrod because they start blooming at the same time, if not a hair earlier, than the ragweed. When I see the goldenrod I know it's time to bring out the heavy artillery in the ragweed hunt. It also tends to grow only in the sunny areas of my yard, which means there are none in the woods in hiding. YEA!!!

I have nothing to help you with, Blake, but I just wanted to vent about that ragweed. I found TWO huge patches in the yard today, and I swear they popped up in about three days! Even the little babies are making flowers now.


 o
RE: allergy free garden?

I actually do have some experience with allergy free gardens, unlike some of these other posters here. My mom had really bad allergies every spring, but 3 years ago I got Thomas Ogren's cool book (Allergy Free Gardening) and re-landscaped her whole yard. I dug out all her junipers, they were males; I removed an acacia tree and planted an apricot tree instead...I used the book and went over the whole yard. Made a huge difference, too...she's been off the antihistimines for 2 years now.
As for pollen traveling so far....not true really...just walk down any city street in spring, and under some trees, like birch, or alders or male deodar cedars, you can see all kinds of pollen, right on the sidewalk under the tree....go 50 feet or less away, and you don't see any.
Do a Google search for what they call "proximity pollinosis."

If you have allergies, you've got nothing to lose by going allergy free...no side effects, except you'll probably feel better. As for ragweed, it only blooms in the fall...if you have allergies in spring or summer, it isn't from weeds....it's probably from the bushes and trees right in your own yard.
As for the comment about maple trees...actually most red maples, silver maples, and box elder maples are all separate sexed trees, and female trees have no pollen....and the males always do. There are lots of plants like this.
Take a look at the very good article by Ogren in an op-ed for the New York Times last year, called Allergy_Free New York I think. It's an eye opener.

Allergy free gardens are for real.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the New England Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here