Return to the Northwestern Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Best methods to control slugs

Posted by GGardens 8 (My Page) on
Mon, Apr 15, 13 at 18:20

How can slugs be controlled/eliminated? Commercial slug bait products say not to irrigate for 48 hrs after application; but in this area's (Olympic pennisula) on-off rainy weather, 48 hrs with no rain is weeks away. So slug bait seems to be a waste of time and money.

I've surrounded my huechera and hosta plants with crushed egg shells, so far it seems to be working. Are there other methods besides search and destroy?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

what kind of slug bait tells you that???

I use sluggo and have not been aware of that caution.


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

I just keep hammering them with Metaldehyde, regardless of weather. I'm growing some very challenging and slow plants, and will not tolerate big losses to slugs. The Metaldehyde works fine for me. Occasionally, I'll throw some Sluggo out there, but I'm not sure how effective it is.

The coarser your mulch is, the worse the slugs will be. That's my experience anyway.

After a couple of years of persistent baiting, you will notice a big dropoff in the slug population. But you will never get rid of them completely. At this time of year, you have to apply fresh bait every couple of weeks, as the eggs hatch.

There is a restricted product called Mesurol which will annihilate the slug population, but it annihilates just about everything else too. I wouldn't use it, even if I had the license.

Here is a link that might be useful: slug info from OSU


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

To plantknitter--to answer your question--it's Ortho Bug-getta. Haven't tried Sluggo--yet.


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

Ortho Bug-Geta Plus has a lot of carbaryl in it.

From the link that I posted previously: "Both carbaryl and methiocarb in a bait greatly reduces populations of earthworms and predatory beetles."

Here is a link that might be useful: bug-geta plus


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

  • Posted by corrine1 7b Pacific Northwest (My Page) on
    Wed, Apr 17, 13 at 0:43

Search & destroy takes time, but is effective. A bucket of soapy water works well if you prefer to just scoop & plop. I use a biodegradable soap & dump it in an out of the way place in the garden after a few days. I've also reused the soapy water bucket after washing the car. I find the bucket method easier than making, filling, & dumping bait stations homemade or purchased.

I've had good results with this method from Easy Answers for Great Gardens by Marianne Binetti page 188:
"Mix one part ammonia & two parts water in a trigger spray bottle...and it's cheap! Aim & fire on small slugs. This solution dissolves those hard to get baby slugs that hide... Large slugs may be able to survive by shedding their skin... The ammonia spray that hits the plants converts to nitrogen, so you are feeding the plants while ridding them of slugs.... Although the ammonia and water mix may damage the leaves of some ferns and plants, it is still safer than many slug baits or salt."

I have even diluted it further with 4 or 5 parts water and it still works. I think the key is to get out there & get 'em regularly. The spray method is really quick if you have the mixture already made.


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

Oh, yikes!
Those ortho, corry's etc. products kill the good beetles ( who eat the slug eggs by the way) and they will also kill ( or likely kill) the other amphibians salamanders, newts etcs.

Get thee some sluggo, Worry free, escargo etc.-- the slug bait with iron phosphate that is not ( or at least less) toxic ( so far as we know so far) to the other good critters we need.

Use a little ( LITTLE!) Deadline cautiously around the most important and susceptible plants as occasionally needed if needed.


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

If you use Sluggo (which is what I use), make sure you do NOT get Sluggo Plus. Sluggo Plus has insecticide (spinosad) that you don't need added to it. You're trying to kill slugs, not insects. Iron phosphate will take care of that.


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

Sluggo is great. If you don't mind high maintanance, you can drown them by putting out bowls of beer at night. Old margarine tubs work great... Set them into the soil to almost the rim. Slugs can't resist the beer. If you don't have beer, I think you can use a yeast/sugar/water mixture too. They are attracted to the yeasty fermentation smell.


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

I have a lot of slugs in my yard. Last year I tested a number of control methods and these were my results:

Hand picking, going out at night with a flashlight (a futile fight against an infinity of slugs which had nil effect in the grand scheme of things)

Beer in saucers (I caught horrendous numbers of them but also missed many. Then there were gross saucers of dead slugs rotting in beer to clean up and refuel, which I didn't enjoy. And the beer also traps ground beetles)

Metaldahyde (I applied it to my sweet woodruff bed and the next day all the sweet woodruff had turned black and died)

Corn meal (I read they are supposed to eat it until they burst. Well, they love it and eat a LOT of it but there was no bursting going on, just big healthy slugs)

Sluggo- Sluggo wins, hands-down! After I started the sluggo, I finally noticed a huge difference in the number of slugs. I hardly found any more of them on my nightly forays with a flashlight, and most damage to plants stopped. And it gets extra points for being safe and organic, and super easy to apply.

YMMV


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

I have had best luck with hand picking in the early AMs. Keep a gallon plastic bucket with high concentration of salt and a bit of water. I glove up on the picking hand so I can avoid being slimmed for life.

Salt is so cheap as to nearly be free. Everything else exceeds my budget.


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

  • Posted by laurell 8 - Washington (My Page) on
    Tue, Apr 30, 13 at 13:44

I've heard ringing the beds or special plants in copper works. I personally don't have enough of a slug problem to spend the cash on a bunch of copper that may or may not fix the problem. Sluggo works reasonably well, but I've also had limited success watering things with a mixture of water and cheap coffee grounds from a can that I've let steep in an old trash can all day. Caffeine is supposed to hurt the slugs, and the coffee/grounds seem to be an effective fertilizer for the plants. That's what I prefer to use on my veggie beds.


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

Bluewillow, the only thing that will turn plants black overnight is a fire.


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

I wouldn't mind at all if my sweet woodruff all turned black overnight.

Sluggo works great for me. I apply it every two weeks, very, very sparsely by pinching a few grains at a time and flinging into all corners of my garden and a few pinches over the fence into the neighbors' jungles. About 1/3 cup covers my entire 1/4 acre. I use so little, it doesn't cost me much. I see very few slugs around unless I stop applying it.


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

Putting some newspaper, cardboard, or boards down near plants can draw some slugs for a nice cool shelter so I just look underneath and kill the slugs once in a while. I also use Sluggo, which seems to work well, I like to use it under my tunnels so it is protected from water.


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

The slugs in my yard are gourmets, so I have to change their diet on occasion. Something that seems to work well is to mix some frozen apple juice concentrate into the bait, whether it's Metaldehyde or Sluggo.


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

Lilydude, it most definitely did turn to black mush overnight. I was stunned and broken hearted. I can't be sure the metaldehyde did it but I don't want to experiment and find out.


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

Since relocating here the advice I have heard the most is to open a bottle of beer, bury it so the top is still showing and in the morning, your beer bottle will be full of them. I've also heard pouring beer into an old bucket, burying it so they can climb in and in the morning you will have a bucket full. I'm guessing slugs love their beer in Washington!


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

I'm a Sluggo girl but I'll be happy to buy some Corry's if it will kill sweet woodruff....I've been trying to do that for years....


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

  • Posted by botann z8 SEof Seattle (My Page) on
    Sat, Jun 1, 13 at 11:00

Bluewillow, try metaldahyde again and see if it kills Sweet Woodruff. I think your cause and effect is wrong. Report back.
I don't grow veggies or ornamental plants that slugs particularly like so I don't have any metaldahyde on hand.
In the past I have taken an empty soda bottle, cut the top 1/4 off and invert it into the bottom 3/4s of the bottle and poured stale beer or bait into it and placed in an inconspicuous part of the garden. Slugs crawl in, but can't find their way out. No gloves required. After a few days the bottle is dumped into the garbage, slugs and all.
Mike


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

Deadline has always worked great for me. Around foundation and around outer edges of garden.


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

  • Posted by botann z8 SEof Seattle (My Page) on
    Tue, Jun 4, 13 at 1:14

Why around the foundation?
Are they going to come in your house?
Just trying to save you money.
Mike


 o
RE: Best methods to control slugs

I also use Bug-Getta and similar stuff. But I also pick them( at night ,cloudy and , drizzley days). Get a bamboo skewer . When you see one , turn it up side down and skew it.. do the next one . You can get a dozen of the on one skewer ...when done, just throw it away(while on skewer)

Yet there is another method than can work better for rows of small seedling: Cover them with nylon tulle (get it from any fabric store. it is inexpensive)


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Northwestern Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here