Return to the Palms & Cycads Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Winter-damaged Trachycarpus Nainital...Need Help

Posted by islandbreeze 6b MI (My Page) on
Sun, Mar 24, 13 at 11:30

I have a small Nainital, about 5" of trunk, beat up by winter. When I uncovered it, the leaves were burnt and the spear pulled. But the petioles are still green.

Can I cut the green petioles off? Should I trunk cut? Like I mentioned, it doesn't have much of a trunk as it is. I already treated the spear pull with peroxide.

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: Winter-damaged Trachycarpus Nainital...Need Help

Post a picture of it first-my Nainital is the same dark
green variety as yours and pulled almost every year
early on-look at the newest leaves after the part that
pulled and see if the fans are open or closed.....
treat it now with dry copper fungicide powder.

Don't operate just yet-it is the warmer temps that will
speed up the fungal growth-lets see how the other leaves
are first...

RE: Winter-damaged Trachycarpus Nainital...Need Help

I wouldn't take anything off that's green. My pindo palm has the same problem this year but the petioles are still green and the center is still green (as well as one random frond) so I have a little bit of hope that it will pull through (but this weather has to warm up!). Trachys are a lot more tolerable of damage than pindo palms and a lot more willing to give up (and recover from) spear pull. I left a small potted trachy seedling out this winter in the middle of my deck with no protection and it was almost completely burnt and the spear pulled but it looks like a new one is popping up now.

Good luck and keep us updated!

RE: Winter-damaged Trachycarpus Nainital...Need Help

Here are a few pics...tell me what u guys think.

RE: Winter-damaged Trachycarpus Nainital...Need Help

And another....

RE: Winter-damaged Trachycarpus Nainital...Need Help

And another

RE: Winter-damaged Trachycarpus Nainital...Need Help

And the last one...

RE: Winter-damaged Trachycarpus Nainital...Need Help

Its hard to tell with the leaf damage if the core is affected/ or soon will be when temps warm.
Try to keep it as dry as possible in the center area without increasing the heat around it-it may take a while to come back as we need some warm weather to warm up the soil.

You will just have to trust your own instincts in regard to trunk cutting,try removing all the dead tissue off it for starters and then take a closer look at the leaves to see if the fans are open or closed near the center-this will be harder to observe with the amount of leaf damage.

Heres is what to look for-

 photo WinterDamage1-12-10010.jpg

Notice the leaf at 2 o'clock has blades that are closing up and the one in the upper left has the blades open?

When they start to close like that you know where the petioles connect to the trunk is dead,watch very closely and if you are not sure you can always begin cutting down on the trunk a little at a time at an angle to the sun to see if there is live tissue down there.

Here it is later in the spring.

 photo 4-2-10003.jpg

You may be able to see the fans blades are starting to close up on this leaf.

I thought this one was o.k. but the spear pulled here too.

 photo 4-9-10008.jpg

I ended up having to go this far down(next picture) to find live tissue....
the warmer weather will cause the fungal infection to speed up so watch it closely-keep it dry and use(preferably)a dry fungicide treatment as you really don't want more moisture in there-good luck..

 photo Updateon4-15-15003.jpg

RE: Winter-damaged Trachycarpus Nainital...Need Help

Thanks guys.

I ended up leaving the green petioles, but cutting off the browned leaves. I gave it another dose of peroxide and covered it with a trash can while we had some rain. Now it's supposed to be dry for the next few days, with highs around 50, so I'm leaving it uncovered to let it dry out.

Hope this works. I've been growing this thing for several years and would hate to have to start over, especially with a palm as promising as a Nainital.

RE: Winter-damaged Trachycarpus Nainital...Need Help

Hey Islandbreeze!

I gave MikeTropic a home-made formula which seemed to revive his palm. I can tell you what to get, how to prepare and apply it if you are interested. Mike seemed happy with the results. Let me know, I'm happy to help.

RE: Winter-damaged Trachycarpus Nainital...Need Help

Hi Kokomo, any helpful recipes or remedies would be appreciated. I don't have much to lose. Thanks

RE: Winter-damaged Trachycarpus Nainital...Need Help

I found this to work in the past on other tropical flowers. It is a simple formula that contains a multitude of vitamins and minerals that plants need for all aspects of it's life processes.

Once again, it seems to have worked for MikeTropic and maybe it's his opinion you want to also seek. While it has yielded positive results-I promise nothing but hope at this point...and can't guaranty any outcomes.

Go to the supermarket and buy:

1 Can of "Sliced Beets"
2 Bananas

This is the proportion, if you need to make more in one shot, add proportionately IE: 2 cans of Sliced Beets/4 Bananas

Put it all in a blender as set it for "Puree". This stuff truly needs to come out as liquified as possible.

Take any container/cup that you would use for watering. Pour in 1/3 mixture to 2/3 very warm water and mix well. Keep unused mix in refrigerator as you will need to repeat this process everyday for 5-7 days.

Pour it all over the soil so that it spreads out to reach the entire root system.

Depending on the condition of the roots, you should see it perk up in a day or 2.

Good Luck and let me know what happens.

RE: Winter-damaged Trachycarpus Nainital...Need Help

Just Checking in...did you try it?

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Palms & Cycads Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here