Return to the Meadows & Prairies Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Wildflowers that compete best with Grasses

Posted by johnstaci Z5 SmithvilleMO (My Page) on
Thu, Dec 30, 04 at 21:51

Which wildflowers compete best with grasses? Coneflowers, Daisies, others????

I am planting a large meadow and want to plant the most grass tolerant wildflowers I can. The more agressive the better. My budget is very limited, so I need to get a lot of bang for my buck.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Wildflowers that compete best with Grasses

Sorry, but a wildflower meadow without grasses will quickly turn into a mass of weeds. Try to find a natural wildflower meadow (outside of deserts) that doesn't have an abundance of supporting grasses. There aren't any. In short, grasses are required to fill in spaces between the forbs (proper name for meadow wildflowers) and keep out the weeds. The grasses alwo support the forbs.

The only aggressive non-grasses that can aggressively compete with grasses are things like Canada thistle, queen anne's lace, and some other undesirables.

I'm afraid that you'll have to rethink your project. What's on the site now? How do plan to get rid of existing vegetation?

Sorry for the bad news.


 o
RE: Wildflowers that compete best with Grasses

  • Posted by dbarron Z6/7 (Oklahoma) (My Page) on
    Fri, Dec 31, 04 at 11:21

As John (somewhat bluntly) explained, prairies are communities of native grasses and wildflowers. Depending on what grasses you're talking about...a prairie may be easy (or not) for you.
Mine is now 5 years old and filled with spots of color from March till November. The grasses and forbs are settling in nicely and both reseeding and spreading well.


 o
RE: Wildflowers that compete best with Grasses

I've seen people plant small strips or squares of a mix of native forbs and grasses throughout a larger area they wanted to convert. The idea is that the native grasses and forbs seed themselves into the adjacent areas. It's a way to save money on seed. I've seen it work, albeit slowly. April


 o
RE: Wildflowers that compete best with Grasses

I think people may be giving you the wrong impression. Prairies are naturally very colorful, with a mix of grasses and showy flowers. The difficulty is getting them established, since annual weeds tend to outcompete the more conservative plants early on, and these are the ones found in more stable prairies with native grasses. Once the desirable flowers and grasses get established, they do a pretty good job of keeping out weeds.

A short list might include yellow coneflower, purple coneflower, rigid goldenrod, new england aster, blazing star, mountain mint, compass plant, shooting star, Monarda fistulosa, butterflyweed, purple prairie clover, rattlesnake master, hoary vervain. These will give you lots of flowers and will grow in concert with grasses throughout the year. For earlier blooms you might add prairie smoke, blue-eyed grass, prairie violet, ohio spiderwort.

You could probably use black-eyed susan and false sunflower and get lots of blooms for a year or two but then they will disappear and the site will probably revert to weeds.


 o
RE: Wildflowers that compete best with Grasses

I must have given the impression that I wasn't planning on planting grass with the wildflowers. Rather, the majority of the seed will be grass. I plan to plant a low growing inexpensive grass such as creeping red fescue with the wildflowers.

The site is currently 20 acres of bare land - cropland. Will plant next spring. Will plant approx 25 lbs of grass and 2 lbs of wildflowers per acre.

I would love to go with a low growing native grass such as buffalo grass, but it is way out of my price range for a project this large. I don't want grasses that grow over 12 inches tall. Creeping red is the only alternative I've found that is inexpensive and doesn't grow over 12 inches. I will probably mix in some white clover to help produce nitrogen (maybe 2lbs per acre).

I know creeping red fescue is somewhat agressive, that is why I want to plant agressive wildflowers.


 o
RE: Wildflowers that compete best with Grasses

I'd stay away from the white clover. That's my biggest problem right now. It grows VERY early in cold weather and inhibits germination of the desirable plants. It's listed in every prairie book you can find as a serious problem. I'd suggest you pick up a book like "The Tallgrass Restoration Handbook" before getting started. The book's a little pricey but blowing a bunch of dough and having to start over will cost even more!


 o
RE: Wildflowers that compete best with Grasses

Buffalo grass has a low germination rate, sure, but blue grama sounds perfect for you. It's low growing, and germinated readily. Cute seed heads, too.

CJ


 o
RE: Wildflowers that compete best with Grasses

John - Since I'm in Missouri too, I'm curious whether you've gotten any financial assistance from MDC. Is there a grant or cost share program that could help you? It seems like you should qualify for SOMETHING with such a large project. Have you already looked through these?

Here is a link that might be useful: Incentives for Using Natives on Your Farm (Missouri)


 o
RE: Wildflowers that compete best with Grasses

Yes I am in a gov program, but not for the wildflowers. I signed this land up for a CRP-type program that is aimed at reducing soil erosion and sedimentation in public water supply reservoirs. I am planting 6500 tree seedlings in April and will be using the wildflowers to mix in with my cover crop. There is no extra payment for the wildflowers as I am already getting payment for the tree planting. I realize the wildflowers will eventually be shaded out, but that will be 15 yrs down the road. Purple coneflower and maybe some others may be able to tolerate the shade for awhile.

Anyone know of other wildflowers that can grow in both sun and shade?


 o
RE: Wildflowers that compete best with Grasses

There are lots that will grow in both sun and shade..what kind of trees? It matters because some trees produce dense shade...others produce dappled shade, and most wildflowers require a bit of sun. Within your creeping red fescue, please put an ounce or two of little bluestem....c'mon, just for me? LOL ! April


 o
RE: Wildflowers that compete best with Grasses

Dozens of varieties of trees will be planted. I'll have deciduous areas (many oaks) and conifer areas. Trees will be spaced 10' apart. Eventually most shade will be dense, but it will take awhile. Anything thats tolerant to some shade will last a couple years longer than those that one do well in full sun. I do have a small quantity of little bluestem that I'll add along with some indian grass. Happy? :)


 o
RE: Wildflowers that compete best with Grasses

I planted false indigo (baptisia australis) in a spot that's full sun now and will be in shade later for the same reason. You need to get a second opinion though in case I wrong. I know it's tolerating full sun (absolutely no shade) just fine but not sure how much shade it can take. Hope I was right. I really like that plant. The foliage is pretty even when it's not flowering.


 o
RE: Wildflowers that compete best with Grasses

Very happy.


 o
RE: Wildflowers that compete best with Grasses

There are lots of things you could plant in your oak savannah...but it will take decades because, unless I've heard wrong(a distinct possibility)oaks grow slowly.

So, for quite some while you could still go with your original scenario. I have white oaks that have volunteered here that are only 8 inches high, and they're 4 years old.

Try to avoid Norway Maples and Autumn and Russian Olives! There are lots of natives you can use, instead. Just FYI.

Please keep us posted...and have fun planting ALL THOSE TREES! April


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Meadows & Prairies Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here