I need help deciding! The oil technician maimed one of my rose bushes... as a result they are buying me a rose bush (of my choice).

I feel like it's too late to order.. so I went to my local nursery and here's what looks good:

Rouge Royale, Liv Tyler, Eden, Pink Traviata, Belinda's Dream, Colette...

These are roses I'm considering. I can only buy one. I already have one Eden--- but it is a much smaller bush than what the nursery is selling (the ones at the nursery looked huge!). I also technically have a Belinda's Dream... but it is from Summerstone Nursery and it's DEAD-- they are supposed to replace it... but you know how it is with them. . .

I have an Ebb Tide & Steven's Big Purple...

Anyway's, I'm really leaning towards getting another Eden or Rough Royale... or if I hear Liv Tyler is awesome I might get her! I just need to know more about these guys! I'm so indecisive! I live in PA-- 6b...