Return to the Name That Rose Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

Posted by silver_wlf 6 Ontario (My Page) on
Sun, Jun 3, 07 at 11:14

Hi!

Please help me identify this rose. It's own root and suckers prolifically. It only blooms once in the spring. It's susceptible to powdery mildew but not to black spot. It's REALLY thorny.

The flowers smell STRONGLY of rose. Kind of like some peonies with that roses & sugar smell. You can smell the bush from the sidewalk (4-5' away).


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

I should mention that the canes normally stand, but we've had a couple really good storms in the past 24 hours and it's looking a little beaten. The canes are at least 6' and it's cane-hardy right to the tips.


 o
RE: Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

Kind of reminds me of the Damask rose La Ville de Bruxelles.

Here is a link that might be useful: La Ville de Bruxelles


 o
RE: Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

Heres a good link for Gallica shots

Here is a link that might be useful: Gallicas


 o
RE: Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

Hi;
I became fascinated by this thread because I have the same Mystery Rose growing in my bed. In fact, It's now three roses, we renovated the garden and had a new spot planned for her, but this hardy belle's woody root stock was enormous, so we went with the flow, divided her, and now three plants are happily climbing up the garage wall!
I thought she could be Charles Lawton (check out http://www.rdrop.com/~paul/bourbons/lawson.html) but that would not fit with my Edmonton Alberta zone 4, in which she is currently thriving.
Then I thought maybe the ancient damask Kazanlik... http://www.amityheritageroses.com/WWWgraphics/Kazanlik.JPG which would fit as her perfume is amazing. http://woodlandrosegarden.com/american gardens/SJHRG 2002/thumb/kazanlik 3_thmb.jpg

The blooms retain their scent and most of their light pink color, even with drying. The bush is kind of awkward, sprawling.
Excluded:
Baltimore Belle (http://woodlandrosegarden.netfirms.com/american gardens/lynchburg cemetery 2003/baltimore belle 19_f.jpg) crossed my mind but was excluded due to the glossier leaf of the Belle.
She's not a rugosa (leaves are finer), a moss, or an alba (foliage color is dark yellowgreen).
LA VILLE DE BRUXELLES- blooms are too small to be La Ville. Also not Terese Bugnet- which was a popular rose when this probably was planted probably 30 years ago, the leaves are wrong, and doesn't have striking red colored canes in winter.
http://users.uniserve.ca/~tillyer/images/Therese Bugnet 2.jpg

So..Kazanlik? Some sport of a Kazanlik- wild rose cross?


 o
RE: Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

I'm not experienced enough to be considered by any means an expert, but you are describing the flowering behavior of a "Gallica". That doesn't mean it must be so since Rosa gallica's genes are in most of the garden roses, but it probably is either a Gallica, or one of the descendants that shows strong Gallica influence. (I think some of the "Damasks" show that, but I'm not sure.)


 o
RE: Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

This looks identical to one I have growing here which I found along a roadside near an abondoned homestead. That and another rose (which I believe to be Tuscany) had suckered themselves across the old yard right up to and into the gravel road. I didn't have to trespass one tiny bit to rustle this rose, just opened the car door and scooped up a piece, LOL!
I, too, have thought there might be some damask here as it is a bit different than most of my other gallicas, and a tad more tender (getting tip damage in winter here in zone 4.)


 o
RE: Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

I'm trying to identify a mystery rose, too, that I think may be 'Kazanlik.' I'm pretty sure it's a damask of some kind! It's supposed to be 'York and Lancaster' but it's never done the two-colors-on-one-flower thing. Would you folks mind taking a look at my photos over on 'Name That Rose' forum, and let me know what you think? (York_rose, thanks so much for your comments on my other post, concerning semi-plena!)

Here is a link that might be useful: Kazanlik? York and Lancaster?


 o
RE: Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

Mine is definitely not Charles Lawson as the page says "the lithe canes are nearly thornless" - mine is ridiculously thorny. So bad that even with welding gloves it's not pleasant to work with... :o(

Kazanlik isn't an option either as it seems to have centres that are much larger than the ones on mine.

Mine's blooms look like La Ville (swirled and really tight) but the flowers are small - maybe 1.5-2". They open flat and fade to a lighter pink as they age.

I didn't notice any hips or cane colour-changes...

I'm glad I'm not the only one searching!! :o)


 o
rosa centifolia

Could your rose be rosa centifolia, "the cabbage rose"?

Here is a link that might be useful: r. centifolia at helpmefind


 o
RE: Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

I am sure this rose is neither Kazanlik nor La Ville. It is either Ispahan or Blush Damask. Ispahan is a rose which has the longest blooming period of all damask. For how long does your rose bloom?


 o
RE: Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

Maybe Belle Isis?


 o
RE: Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

I'm interested in this rose... so have you managed to find the name of this rose, yet silver_wl?


 o
RE: Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

This rose reminds me of :

'Reine des Centfeuilles'

Am I right????

Here's the link to Helpmefindrose:

Here is a link that might be useful: rosa: 'Reine des Centfeuilles'


 o
RE: Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

Hi, has anyone figured out what rose this is? It sounds like something I am interested in if I can find out what kind it is. thanks


 o
RE: Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

The rose could be "Banshee". If you can find a few hips (it doesn't make many) they will be acorn shaped.
Good luck.


 o
RE: Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

I have a rose very similar to the La Ville de Bruxelles or Ispahan. It was planted in 1930 in memory of a family member and again on a cemetery in 1944. Spreads by underground roots. A little hard to transplant. Petals are very full over 40. Single color of pink but goes to white at the center of the petal and white on the back of the petal . Shape is open cupped. Petal shape is reflexed. The leaf surface is Matt and color is light to med-green. It flowers in W. PA. once mid-June into July. Slightly fragrant to fragrant. It flowers in clusters of 3 usually. (Florabunda ??). Size is 3 inches across. I have books upon books trying to figure it out. I'll have to wait until summer to post a picture, but wondered if by the description you can help. Thanks. Connie


 o
RE: Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

I was kind of thinking it might be banshee as well. I have several but they are young plants and the ones that I got from pickering had a whiter bloom on them this last spring.


 o
RE: Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

i have some that are very similar to that also except mine are white with a pink tinge, also very thorny very hardy and this may not help much but it is at least 30 years old as the bush was there when my grandfather bought the place over 30 years ago. mine are against the house and sheltered so they stand 6ft (a solid 5.5 at least) tall. we don't water them and they flower once in july (sometimes end of june, but are usually done by august) also smell very rosy, a little spicy, blooms are the same size.

we also have dark pink ones that grow wild and sporadically around the house and they bloom about the same time and are very small plants and smell like apples instead of rose.

i would love to know what this one is as mine is likely the same.


 o
RE: Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

Its not 'Banshee', I can guarantee you that. It is a Gallica, however, and if blooms are on the small side (IE: under 3") then it is most likely 'Belle Isis'.

Regards,
Paul


 o
RE: Old Garden Rose? Once bloomer ... pink...

  • Posted by bboy z8 WA USA (My Page) on
    Thu, Apr 16, 09 at 1:27

Flower stems appear to have some moss on them.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Name That Rose Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here