Return to the Name That Rose Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Street Roses in New York City

Posted by weedwoman z6 NJ (My Page) on
Tue, Jun 5, 07 at 16:43

New York City sometimes does things right. When they finally finished replacing the West Side Highway in midtown, about 7 years ago, they planted roses in some of the dividers. While they look a little messy in the winter when windblown garbage gets caught in them, most of the year they look good and right now they are stunning. It's a pleasure to sit in traffic down there at the moment.

There are a couple different ones; can anybody ID this one? I know there isn't a much detail as I should have, I took the pictures out the car window waiting for the left turn signal at 50th street. They shear them back once a year, but that's about all the care I see them get.

WW


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
A little more info

I guess I should add that they're about 3 feet high, and while they bloom the most now (June), you get some flowers off an on all summer. The hips are round and smallish, as I recall. They never seem to show any sign of disease or damage, and they are in full sun.

WW


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

I think it is Carefree Wonder.


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

I don't know, the flowers are smaller than that. I should have said, the blooms are only about an inch and a half across. And I see that Carefree Wonder requires winter protection; really cold weather doesn't seem to bother these at all.

Thanks, though.

WW


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

Carefree Delight, then. It has smaller flowers and is a terrific park rose. Carefree Wonder would not be disease-free, though both are quite hardy in NYC.

Here is a link that might be useful: C. Delight


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

But it looks like Carefree Delight is single, and these pretty things are double?


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

They do have more than 5 petals. Is there a double version? And again, it says they need winter protection and these are down next to the Hudson River where it gets bitterly cold and windy in the winter.

You'd think there'd be someplace in the city you could call and ask what these things are. Maybe I should try calling 311. That's for non-emergency city information, I suppose this qualifies.

WW


 o
311 doesn't know

I just called 311. Guess that's not the kind of information they're talking about, they don't know.

WW


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

I've never seen the rose in person, but I've seen pictures of it. I bet it's "Soaring Spirits", named to honor the victims of 9-11.

I've included a link to the google images for you to compare.

Also, if you click on the web info the first hit is for the Weeks site that tells more about it and on down the page is a link to the "Remember Me Rose Garden". "Firefighter" and "Soaring Spirits" are apparently the first 2 of 9 roses to be named in honor of those who gave their lives.

This is the first time I've read about any of this.
Here's that address for anyone interested.
http://www.remember-me-rose.org/roses.asp

Here is a link that might be useful: Soaring Spirits rose images at google


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

  • Posted by hoovb z9 Southern CA (My Page) on
    Sat, Jun 9, 07 at 18:06

I've seen 'Soaring Spirits' in person, and that isn't it.


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

How about "Rasberry Ruffles"?


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

too bad, soaring spirits would have been such a beautiful gesture.


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

You can't tell much from "requires winter protection" on HMF. The main author is in upstate NY and suspicious of repeat-blooming roses.


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

Now now. No dissing HMF. The site owner isn't from New York or suspicious. Often the first source of hardiness info is from breeders, and we all know how reliable that is. If you have better info, post a comment and make the corrections.

About an ID. It isn't Carefree Delight, which I grow. Foliage is all wrong, blooms too nice.

This rose has a hand-painted look. Cherries n Cream by J & P? Doubt it's hardy enough.

Regensburg by McGredy IV? Seems too light. I'd post to the regular Roses forum.


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

Sorry, I didn't intend to diss-- HMF is a remarkable and generous gift to civilization. And on second thought I realize she's in, or was in, Pennsylvania. But many roses that I know to be cane-hardy to zero are flagged as "requires winter protection if temperatures drop below freezing." I call that unduly suspicious ;)


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

Definitely not Soaring Spirits, it is striped with frilly-edged blooms, more single form than double.

I'm sticking with Wonder, 'cause I do see it around here in a few public plantings. And it's crazy with water here with all of the rivers and inlets.

Maybe the streets department would know?


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

Hi. It reminds me of the Hybrid Musk "Belinda" It has been some years since I have seen the rose, though.

Here is a link that might be useful: HMF Belinda


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

One last thought is one of the Medilands (there is a planting of Scarlet in one of the traffic berms on Rt 35), maybe Fucshia?


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

  • Posted by belmont Z4 Pennsylvania (My Page) on
    Sun, Jun 17, 07 at 10:59

Down in the West Village section of the highway there are alternating blocks of white roses and a lighter pink version. For some reason I thought they were from the "pavement" series----I might have seen a tag when they were being planted...but it might be a wild guess.

You can smell them from a block away sometimes. Yes, they did this one right!
By the way, it's a state road so the city probably wouldn't be the ones to ask.


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

You zeroed on one of my pet peeves, Michael. That winter protection warning is on my To Do list. Crafting a sentence suggesting that a rose may need winter protection is not that easy, since hardiness is regional and has less to do with temperature than with temperature fluctuations in many parts of the USA. Even though I'm a warm climate gardener, I routinely have temperatures in the teens and do no winter protection. My roses suffer no damage and most don't even go dormant. So I'd like to see the winter protection trigger dropped lower, say 10 or 15 degrees Fahrenheit. Of course there's alway the case of the garden dolt who goes into the rare hard freeze with dry roses. I'll work on it.


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

2010 update-
I saw a tag poking out of the ground a couple days agao and managed to jump out of the car and look at it before the light changed this morning. It said 'Meidiland Fuchsia'.

I imagine the others in that area are probably Meidiland roses too.

WW


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

Not sure of the id but I have to admit that when I saw that they were planting roses in those median strips of the WSH I thought they were crazy. Boy was I wrong they have done really well and add a nice touch to the urban environment.

Here is a link that might be useful: Daily Flower Blog


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

To digitalflower -- advertising one's business is not allowed on the GardenWeb forums.

Weedwoman -- I'm happy you finally identified the mystery rose and I will put a link below to the HelpMeFind description. Click on the photos tab to see a few pictures:

Here is a link that might be useful: Fuchsia Meidiland


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

I'm so happy we know the name, they are so pretty! Thank you for jumping out of the car to see the tag.


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

Digitalflower, I'm glad I'm not the only one looking at that stuff. Some things work, some don't. The daylilies they planted on the Riverside Drive medians lasted about 2 weeks. But if I were the Meilland people I'd be putting signs in these rose beds - what an advertisement for them.

It took about a week before I got up the nerve to jump out of the car and look - it's not a pedestrian friendly place, to say the least. But I've been trying to figure out what these are for a couple years now.

WW


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

I always spell "Meidiland" incorrectly, but I was close!


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

You were right on the money, Diane. I only spelled it right because I looked it up. I still don't think the pictures on line look exactly like these, but there don't seem to be that many pictures on line. And I'm no expert when it comes to roses anyway.

WW


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

I went to Home Depot today and they had many Resenburg rose bushes for sale, they looked exactly like the pictures above in New York. I wonder if the rose has 2 names because there isn't much information under the name Resunburg? I purchased one of the bushes, when it gets new blooms I will post a picture, the petals were white on the outside and pink and white on the inside, very striking, it looks like it is going to have a lot of blooms soon.


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

Sweetmichelia, I'm pretty sure the rose you bought is Regensberg, and I agree that the blooms do look a lot like Fuchsia Meidiland.

Here is a link that might be useful: Regensberg listing on HelpMeFind


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

  • Posted by roselvr 6B Lower S.Jersey (My Page) on
    Thu, May 27, 10 at 16:36

Weedwoman; so glad you found a tag! My 1st guess was going to be Regensberg; but the flowers in your photo look too small.

You should upload your photos to HelpMeFind.


 o
RE: Street Roses in New York City

Well I am in Jersey City and I would appreciate it if my city would buy something other than cherry red knock outs.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Name That Rose Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here