Return to the Name That Rose Forum
| Post a Follow-Up
not Felicite Perpetue - any suggestions?
| | |
Posted by kiwi_fiona Dunedin, NZ (My Page) on Mon, Oct 30, 06 at 3:49
| This is an old rose that has been in a family for generations. It looks and behaves like Felicite Perpetue, but the flowers are a little bigger, and are not pompoms, and are quite distinctly different from the back. Any suggestions? |
Image link: not Felicite Perpetue - any suggestions? (57 k)
Follow-Up Postings:
RE: not Felicite Perpetue - any suggestions?
| | |
| Can you post a larger photo so we can get a better look at the leaves and hips (or are those buds)? Some more info would help - for starters: Is your rose fragrant - if so, what does it smell like? You say it looks and behaves like Felicite Perpetue - do you mean that it is a once-blooming rambler? It's very pretty! Just how long has it been in your family? |
RE: not Felicite Perpetue - any suggestions?
| | |
Hi Cecilia,
This is a rose that grows at one end of the country, and I'm at the other end. It has been in that family for at least 70 years, very possibly longer. It looks and behaves... it's growing way up a tree, and at first glance can pass for FP. The back appearance is very distinctive - I've posted another picture of that, though I keep running into the size restriction when I load the pictures. Scent? some I think. |
RE: not Felicite Perpetue - any suggestions?
| | |
| Have managed to attach a better picture! |
Here is a link that might be useful: Olive's white rose
RE: not Felicite Perpetue - any suggestions?
| | |
| Wow, what a beauty. The branch in the photo has very few thorns/prickles - is this true for the rest of the plant? Is it warm in the parts of NZ where this rose has been grown? Knowing the rose's hardiness might narrow the search down. I hope trosepro sees your post - he's really good at identifying older roses. Of course, maybe your rose was only available in NZ and/or Australia and we've never seen it in the US! |
RE: not Felicite Perpetue - any suggestions?
| | |
| This rose grows in frost-free Northland, in a garden along with Fortunes Double Yellow, Rosa roxburghii, Rosa multiflora carnea and other roses that the early missionaries/settlers had in their gardens. It's a real treasure trove. The rose was up in a tree, and I should have gone up after it, but there was only limited time. |
RE: not Felicite Perpetue - any suggestions?
| | |
- Posted by roselvr Burlington Coun (My Page) on
Fri, Nov 10, 06 at 8:05
| Not sure, but it reminds me of my Madame Pierre Oger - link below. Yours is a little pinker, but it's possible they come from the same parents. Also see La Reine Victoria From memory, both of these roses have the pink splotches on the back. |
Here is a link that might be useful: Madame Pierre Oger
RE: not Felicite Perpetue - any suggestions?
| | |
| Many thanks for the suggestion, but this rose is too small for Mme Pierre Oger. I've been leaning towards Blush Noisette after reading Mrs Keays articles. |
RE: not Felicite Perpetue - any suggestions?
| | |
| Hello, if your rose grows quite tall and repeats (moderately), this should be 'Aimée Vibert', a noisette climber or 'Blush Noisette' as itself in his climbing form. 'Aimée Vibert' has musk fragrance and 'Blush Nosette' smells more like clover. |
|
|
|
|
