JOIN NOW LOG IN
iVillage GardenWeb iVillage GardenWeb THE INTERNET'S GARDEN & HOME COMMUNITY ADVERTISEMENT
Blogs Forums Photo Galleries Ask The Experts Tools & Directories        
Return to the Salvia Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Rooting salvia cuttings

Posted by Gerris2 z6/7 Delaware (My Page) on
Sun, Jul 3, 05 at 22:12

I have tried all aspects of technique for rooting salvias, from dipping cut end in rooting hormone and putting in moist medium, putting cuttings in water, to the rooting gels, all to no avail. Then this spring I was transplanting a Salvia corrugata plant and it was a bit brittle and I broke off the leading tip. In frustration at my clumsiness, after planting the main plant, I put the broken off end into moist soil and let it be in the shade. A few days later it perked up and it must have rooted because it is growing quite nicely now. I guess I was just working too hard! I thought it was funny, and had to share.

Joseph


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

  • Posted by Cait1 VIC Aust (My Page) on
    Mon, Jul 4, 05 at 1:11

I bought S van houttii last year and worried about it surving the frosts we often get. That winter I took several cuttings. Only one managed to root. When I planted it, I, too, snapped a piece off. I was annoyed and just stuck it in the ground near the cutting. Both of these took off, bushed out, and look even better than the parent plant.

I've been advised that cuttings strike according to the seasons. I know someone who is experimenting with bottom heating and she says she's been taking cuttings out of season and rooting them successfully using this method. I know someone else who's taken many cuttings of Hot Lips and is really happy with how easy they root but I've yet to be successful! What strikes, what doesn't, when and how remains a mystery to me.
Cait


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

I seem to have had better luck getting sticks to root in the spring... perhaps less stress from our high summer heat.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

I turn my lights on in the basement when I'm rooting cuttings in the summer. Down there the rooting medium stays wetter and the temperatures are cooler.

Now I'll add a question. I had very mixed success with rooting some of my bush sages. Rasperry Delight seems to take ok, but Raspberry Royal has been almost a total failure. Has anyone noticed that cuttings from fatter stems seem to take quicker and better? Many of my cuttings were from wind broken stems from which I could take up to four or five cuttings. The lower fatter stems seemed to root quite well on the "Delight", while the thinner upper parts of the stems rooted slowly if they rooted at all. Perhaps it is not worth the trouble to root those thin cuttings?

The above being said, I took cuttings of all sizes from San Carlos Festival and Wild Watermelon over the weekend. I'm hoping for the best since I'll need those rooted plants next year.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

Joseph & Cait, I have long known that I couldn't root things in the house or if I paid any attention to them at all(read overwatering). Outdoors, I just tuck bits of plants into my pots in a shaded position & water every couple of days & like magic they root! In the house, it's the same scenario each time, they look great until one day they lose all their leaves(or they lose them one at a time). It seems that neglect works best for me!

wardw, I've never been able to figure out which part of the stem does best, so I try them all! I suspect it's more the time of the year that matters as Westelle pointed out.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

  • Posted by Cait1 VIC Aust (My Page) on
    Tue, Jul 5, 05 at 19:57

I agree with you, Rose. Often 'neglect' is the best rooting agent. I've had the most success by potting the cuttings then leaving them under my rosemary bush! The bush is about 4 ft high, 2 stakes on either side with a string attached. The string holds the stems upright in the middle but there's a kind of umbrella effect from the stems that fall over the string. I guess it works as a kind of cold frame.

I've also had success when rooting cuttings and leaving them in the house. I've only just started experimenting with taking cuttings in winter - it's winter for me now - and the winter-flowering salvias seem to strike ok. But I have more winter flowering species to experiment with while last year I only had the van houttii. The greggii cuttings I've taken seem to strike better when taken in spring and early summer. The same with buchananii.
As you said, I, too, have never been able to figure out which part of the stem does best when it comes to cuttings. And for me that's part of the fun - to just 'do it' and see what happens!
Cait


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

Thanks for the feedback folks. And certainly the unexpected is one of things that keep things interesting. These chat areas are still fairly new to me. In the old days you either had to buy a book, learn from gardening neighbors, or just go with the old trial and error method. If nothing else these sessions have steepened my learning curve.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

DH broke off some Mulberry Jam, which I promptly took to the potting area and stuck in a new pot. I paid more attention to what I was doing because of this thread.
1. I agree that the larger cuttings seem to root better.
2. I always strip-off the lowest one or two sets of leaves; this seems to be where the new roots come from.
3. I make a tent out of a plastic bag held up off the cuttings with a stick. I leave that on for a week or so, or until the cuttings seem to not be wilty anymore.
4. Finally I put the pot in a shadier area.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

Joseph, that is the only way I have ever rooted a Salvia cutting -- accidently breaking a stem, sticking it in soil in semi-shade, and a few weeks later it perks up. Even the cuttings in the sunnier spots (even in pots that I forget to water) do the best.

Pelargoniums also root very easily in the same way.

Jen


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

I work at a nursery and we have several salvias that we grow from cuttings. It's really pretty easy, and of all of the plants we grow from cuttings, Salvias and Pelargoniums are probably some of the easiest. Here is how we do the cuts.

1. We take about a 3/4" cut from the tip. You want to get new growth that's healthy looking.
2. Strip off all but 2 or 3 sets of leaves. Take off all flowers. You want the plant to produce roots, not try to flower.
3. We don't usually use rooting hormone, but we do use heat mats.
4. We also use a seed/cutting starter mix. It's finer than regular potting soil.
5. They don't need to be covered, but do mist them a couple of times a day.

We have really good results this way. The only real stinker this year was Chiapensis. Maybe it's because the stems are thinner.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

I had thought of using bottom heat, but last year I had mixed results with that method. It looks like it is time to try it again. Anything that will get these things rooted so they can go out in the nursery bed. My second set of cuttings from San Carlos Festival and Wild Watermelon seem to have rooted, at least they don't yield to a gentle pull. The earlier June cuttings of Raspberry Delight are now ready for the nursery bed, that is once the temperatures quit being in the upper 90s late this week.

Thanks to everyone for their advice.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

  • Posted by Skrip z9/sun19/SoCal. (My Page) on
    Tue, Jul 12, 05 at 13:16

I finally successfully rooted 2 salvia guarantica Black & Blues! Both in small pots and only one had a clear plastic covering with holes. Just kept them moist for a few weeks and now they are about 3 times the size. I left them on my porch which gets full sun for about 3 hours of the hottest part of the day, but theyre mostly semi-shade. I would say it took over a month.

also stuck a Salvia Leucantha cutting that was about 6 inches long and stuck it in a full sun area. The thing is about a foot now.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

I have been rooting salvias for years now and have found them to be one of the easiest of all the things I root. I try to take a cutting with at least two nodes on it. I was told by a professional that you need at least two nodes so that the cutting will return the next year in the garden. I trim all of the leaves off except at the very top. If the leaves are large, I cut them in half. I stick the cuttings in a mixture of perlite and sand. I spritz with the hose twice a day and in about two weeks, they are rooted. They are in the shade but that is about all I do to them. If your cutting bends when you try to stick in your medium, it is too thin. Move a little further down the stem. It works for me. Trina


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

  • Posted by Cait1 VIC Aust (My Page) on
    Mon, Jul 18, 05 at 6:23

Hi, Trina and all,
I like the two node idea. I've taken some cuttings where there were a several nodes and try to get as many of them as possible under soil.
This reminded me of something that was said to me about planting salvias - that you can plant them deeper than they were in their original pot. Because I live in a windy area and have had plants blown over I try do this this whenever possible, especially with the taller growing salvias. Makes for a much sturdier plant.
Cait


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

This morning I moved all the rooted babies from their communal pots into individual pots. I trimmed them all back too so I would have denser plants.

Then I filled-up the big communal pots with fresh soil, striped the leaves off the prunings and stuck those in the ground too. We'll see how well they all take in the shade at 110º.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

For Salvia greggiis, try to get vegetative cuttings before they set flower. For Salvia nemerosas, they are very susceptible to variuos kinds of fungal diseases and root rots. It may not show up in the Mother plant, but the cuttings will wither and die. Surface disinfect them with hydrogen peroxide from the drugstore dilted 1:2 or household belach diluted 1:20. I prefer the hydrogen peroxide as it is easy to overdo it with the bleach. Also, the hydrogen peroxide doesn't need to be rinsed, which you should do with the bleach


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

I need to print this thread out for reference! Wow!


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

Does salvia roemeriana root easily? I just transplanted it, and a few stems broke off, argh! So I've put them into pots with a mix of my horrid CA clay soil, and planting mix... I've had some luck rooting salvias just in water.

Boy, I guess this salvia is delicate!! It's my first time growing it. I put it in a spot that is bright shade half the day, sunny the rest.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

While the stems can be rather brittle, it sets seed rather well and will volunteer. It won't root well in water. You will need actively growing, supple stems struck in a sterile medium like vermiculite.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

Salvia roemeraina easily grown from seed, treat it as an annual.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

Thanks, guys. I potted a few more "cuttings" (more like breakings) today... s. Bee's Bliss and s. chameleagnus got assaulted by my 4 year old's soccer ball. sigh! LOL

Yeah, the lazy water method has only worked for rooting s. greggii and microphylla. Those break all the time, presumably due to same ball. Although, the way my resident hummingbirds go after s. blepharophylla, I wouldn't be surprised if they break a few stems as well!


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

Lately I have had pretty fair luck with cuttings Ive tried and I also believe time of year makes a big difference, although my last try at david verity cutting didnt take at all. I have some nice cuttings going of sal greggii autumn sage that is in a pot. Im certainly a bit hesitant about putting them in the ground at this late date, should I leave them in the pot and overwinter in my garage or should I plant these, suggestions please.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

help! I just broke a long piece of my new salvia iodantha plant (Note to self: do not garden while sick...). What are the chances it will root in potting mix, no hormone? I cut the piece in two, as it was several inches long. This was a small plant (4" pot), so there isn't much of the original left. SIGH.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

If it is well established and there is at least one intact node, you should get axillary growth. I always take cuttings with one node under the surface, do I can get axillary growth from underground. The axil will develop its own root system, so it will no longer need the old system after it has grown out.

I hope you have at least one cutting with supple (not stiff or limp) stem in the rooting medium. If your plant was growing rapidly, you will have a new plant in a few weeks.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

Thank you, Rich. Yes, there are a few/ several nodes on each cutting, and I made sure the lowest was under the soil. The plant was indeed growing very rapidly. I suppose I could call Annie's and see if she will replace it, since I've spent so much money with her and want to place another order...

Do leaf cuttings of salvias ever take? I decided to try a few with this iodantha (but figuring they won't root). I don't exactly know what I'm doing there... I have a green thumb, but am not very scientific about it.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

Leaf cuttings won't work with members of the mint family, including sages.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

Will my fancy "wrap it in a damp paper towel and ignore it" technique work for salvia?


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

I wouldn't bank on it! I find salvias very easy to take cuttings from (though have not tried the guarantitca tribe), and I do them all the same way, but seeing how much trouble other people have it is probably to do with the climate/ambience. I do them any time from April to August, which are the nicest months here; can be dry, in which case I do remember to water, but rarely very hot. I use new pots (in theory: in fact I quite often use old ones, unwashed; doesn't seem to make much difference!) and a mixture about 3:2:1 of bagged potting compost, sand and grit or perlite. I use rooting hormone if I look round and can see it, otherwise don't bother. I do choose shoots with several nodes and I pull off all but 4 leaves (and halve them if they are big). I stuff the cuttings in the pots and stand them in a tray of water for 24 hours; then put in the shade (under the bench in the greenhouse if cool outside; in a cold frame or under a tree, out of the wind, if warm) and don't water again till the surface has dried out, then as needed. I never use bottom heat and I never put plastic bags over the pots (makes the cuttings rot) but I do sometimes put the pots into a seed tray that has a tall plastic lid, especially in dry weather, i.e. when the ambient humidity is low (but this is rare, it's usually very high). I get near 100% success rates with most varieties I've tried, but I don't bother with the ones that seed easily (except S scabra, which once rooted 4 broken-off cuttings stuck round the edge of the parent plant's pot in December, out of doors!). I would divide up the sylvestris/nemorosa types in spring rather than do cuttings, though they do take, and I agree that Raspberry Royale is not the easiest - I would expect around a 60% success rate with this.

One of the reasons I like salvias so much is that they are so easy to propagate - they are a doddle from seed as well. The challenge comes in trying to keep the blighters alive through a long, dark, wet and chilly N Wales winter!


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

The best time to do cuttings is when the plants are in vigorous growth. Cuttings taken from slowly growing plants take forever to root.

If you have a difficult to root sage, grow it in a mix with worm castings. This soil amendment is to plants what spinach is to Popeye. You can make a worm-casting rich compost by using coffee grounds with freshly fallen deciduous leaves. Catch them before the leaves have the residual sugars washed out of them to give the leaf molds a head start. Maple leaves are terrific for this.

Salvia blepharophylla, especially Dulces Nombres, can be very resistant to rooting. This hard to find form does have its uses, and I am trying to get it reintroduced. It will get the worm casting treatment.

Don't forget that the optimal rooting treatment involves your weather conditions. This related to the vigor of the plants.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

We had a major storm yesterday, and I am now running damage control...

The S. microphylla UCB Pink did not fare as well as the other salvias; large woody branches broke off. So I guess it's cuttings time... should I only take the new growth at the tips, or try to root the woody stems as well?

Leucantha was tough; one bush even survived a strawberry guava tree falling on it. S. elegans also held up remarkably well. It was the saddest thing to see my hummingbirds feeding from it in the torrential rains and wind!

I've got broken S. coccinea and blepharophylla as well... all the other stuff (e.g. felled trees, flooding) is for the Calif. forum, I guess. :)

thanks


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

Drusilla, you are so right about cuttings between April and August. Here it is October and the usual panic sets in. If all my cutting had been done by mid Augusts the lights and heat cables would not have had to go on in the basement. Some salvias like greggii can be a bit of a problem in fall. They are so anxious to bloom that they only grow few sets of leaves on short stems before they produce a flowers, not exactly ideal.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

For me, growing Calif. salvias in Calif., time of collection of cuttings has been critical. For S. clevelandii, late Feb thru early Apr have been best. Maybe it's my inexperience that I've had poor success with cuttings from other times. S. eremostachya taken in Apr had no success. S. apiana taken in Jun worked, but it took a very long time. Growing from seed is easier, and in my area seed is readily available in mid-summer. I haven't tried S. mellifera from cuttings, because seed is so easily obtained and germinates readily in winter. I worked with S. cleve. cuttings because I wanted to propagate plants with particularly attractive flowers (translation: deep blue).


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

I have taken cuttings in October for the last couple of years (thats when I think about overwintering my plants) with virtually 100% success.

I use a slightly unconventional method. I put the cuttings in a heated propagator inside a light box. I then flood the floor of the propagator with water, having put the pots on pieces of wood to keep their base above the water line. So the cuttings have light and bottom heat with a temperature of about 80F. As the inside of the propagator has 100% humidity, the cuttings cannot lose any moisture so I leave as many as 20 leaves on the cutting material. This way I can get well rooted cuttings in 7 days, but I usually leave them for 10 to 14 days. There is usually no sign of roots for 4 or 5 days or more, but once they start to grow it only takes a very short time to get well rooted specimens. I often take the pots out and pull them apart to see the progress of the roots, and then repot them and put them back. They don't seem to mind - and its all in the interest of science!

The biggest problem I had last year was with the tall red splendens. The parent plant was in flower when I took the cuttings. I cut off all the flower buds that I could see, but the buds kept growing back faster than I could cut them off. So my pot of 10 day old cuttings was in full flower, and has continued to be in full flower to this day nearly 12 months later.

I know this could be a recipe for rot, but so far I have never had it. I have done splendens, 'Mystic Spires', leucantha and involucrata, and they all do equally well.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

peterls, I suspect your method will work mostly with the subtropical sages, but not with the xeric (desert) sages. Please let us know if you have success with these as well.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

I am sure you are right Rich. It seems to work with a range of sun loving things - Argyranthemums, Osteopermum, Verbena etc. But I have no doubt that Pelargoniums would hate it! I haven't even bothered to try them.

I will have a try with other Salvia species.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

  • Posted by wcgypsy 10 / Sunset 23 (My Page) on
    Sun, Oct 18, 09 at 18:14

For all of the tropical salvias I root them in small pots or styrofoam cups (with drainage holes punched)filled with perlite, watered, then put into plastic storage bins with about 1/2 inch water with a bit of h2o2 added to the water, pop the lid on (arid conditions here)and stack the storage boxes in the shade...then check them in a week


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

If I am reading this right wcgypsy - you are doing a similar thing, but in perlite (no soil or compost at all) in a sealed container with hydrogen peroxide to prevent mould. I assume that the small pots are above the water so that the roots can never be in contact with the hydrogen peroxide itself. I check mine every day - so that they a fresh dose of carbon dioxide daily. But you don't even do that.

What is to stop you putting cuttings in a sealed, flat, damp polythene bag, with no soil? You could actually see the roots growing. You might have to breathe into the bag daily to provide carbon dioxide.

I germinated seeds that way, a couple of years ago. When they germinated I removed them, but I purposely left one seed in this sealed bag. With no nutrient other than from the seed itself, it grew several sets of leaves and lived for about three months - which surprised me.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

  • Posted by wcgypsy 10 / Sunset 23 (My Page) on
    Sun, Oct 18, 09 at 19:34

I suppose the h2o2 prevents mold, but I use it to supply oxygen. The pots, or styrofoam, cups sit in contact with the water in the storage bins. I've found that many, many salvias root in water, which most will tell you is not the way to do it, but it works well for me. Especially s. Anthony Parker. This last year I rooted all of my Parkers in water, more than 300 of them. Not the right way to do it, not the wrong way, just 'another' way.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

I have never tried rooting Salvias in water. I always understood they wouldn't. But the fact that some are that tolerant of water helps to explain their willingness to root in 100% humidity. As you say there are no right or wrong ways.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

  • Posted by wcgypsy 10 / Sunset 23 (My Page) on
    Mon, Oct 19, 09 at 11:21

Salvias that I have rooted in water include (amongst others):
s. Anthony Parker
s. canariensis
s. chamaedryoides
s. chamaedryoides x microphylla
s. coahuilensis
s. confertiflora
s. darcyi
s. elegans Tangerine
s. Jean's Purple Passion
s. guaranitica Costa Rica Blue
s. guaranitica Omaha Gold
s. involucrata x Kathy
s. involucrata x pulchella
s. lemmonii
s. madrensis
s. mexicanas
s. microphylla var. neurepia
s. Purple Majesty
Many others...


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

The water method would probably explain why I've had a very good success rate with my method, which is to mix my clay soil with potting soil. My thinking was that this would keep the cuttings wet (it does). Initially, I let the pot sit in a tray of water for a day or more, then I put in on my potting/ cuttings shelves, which are on the north side of the house, shaded nearly all day long. I also often leave the cuttings in water in my kitchen for a few days before potting them up. I am still rooting cuttings, as CA autumn tends to be warm.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

wcgypsy,

What is involucrata x pulchella? As far as I know, 2 or 3 Salvias which were thought to be pulchella were mis-named. The species from Chiapas has now been given the name of S. univerticillata. Involucrata can hybridise with several other species, in particular karwinskii and microphylla. Do you have a photo?


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

  • Posted by wcgypsy 10 / Sunset 23 (My Page) on
    Mon, Oct 19, 09 at 14:29

Robin, my s. pulchella and s. involucrata x pulchella both came from Cabrillo several years ago. I'll see what I can do about a photo....


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

S. involucrata x pulchella is indeed on the Cabrillo list, but no picture.

Here is a link that might be useful: Cabrillo salvia collection


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

Thanks! Just wish that Cabrillo would update their site.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

The Cabrillo S. involucrata x pulchella is probably involucrata x univerticillata. August 2008, when I was at the Salvia Summit, their huge plant was not yet in bloom.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

In light of the last few posts here, Annie's now has Salvia pulchella x involucrata in stock. I think I've seen this in a local botanical garden... was trying to figure out what it was. Is S. wagneriana similar?

Here is a link that might be useful: Salvia pulchella x involucrata


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

They will have to change the name to Salvia univerticillata x involucrata. Pulchella forms from Strybing (Dennis Breedlove's accessions) are now recognized as a new species.


 o
RE: Rooting salvia cuttings

It might carry more weight if you tell her, rather than hearing it from me. :) I did order the plant.

On the subject of salvia cuttings, how should I deal with them if I plan to go away for a few days? I tend to water them daily. Should I just leave the 4" pots in tubs of water?

One (S. Anthony Parker, I believe) rooted and is already starting to flower in under a month -- amazing.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Salvia Forum
 
 


iVillage GardenWeb: The Internet's Garden & Home Community  
  iVillage Home & Garden Network