Why was my seed not viable?

deanna in ME Barely zone 6a, more like 5b

13 years ago

I saved some seeds from last year and they didn't grow a thing, hoping for some help.

I saved Alma Potschke aster seeds, which are supposed to viable and true to seed. The aster pods got completely fluffy with a nice brown seed. In fact, I harvested in late fall and then also actually went out into the garden during the snows of Dec or Jan and harvested some really ripe pods off the plants. These were hung upside down in a paper bag so they could dry. After several days the seeds were removed from the pods.

Nothing grew! The seed pods were ripe with a brown stem and fluffy head, they stayed on the plant more than long enough to mature, and they were wintersown.

The only thing I can think is that some early October frosts ruined the seeds? We had a cold October with some snow dustings and frosts. Then November was WARM. Could the cold of October have damaged something in the flower that is part of the ripening processes? I know we lost our peaches this year because a late frost damaged the stolens/styli (I think) in the bud necessary for pollination, even though the buds themselves looked great. Can similar things happen to ripening seeds?

I traded these seeds with somebody, and feel very terrible that they weren't viable. I'd like to know this year what to do so I can send her a boxful of seeds!

Comments (5)

remy_gw
13 years ago
Hi Deanna,
You did nothing wrong. Asters are notorious for producing many non-viable seed. On the link below, it explains why in the Nature Unexplained section.
You may have given the trader viable seed, but you could always contact them and let them know you had no luck offing to make up for it.
Remy

Here is a link that might be useful: Tom Clothier Seed Viability Article
dorisl
13 years ago
could be a slug or someother seed-eating creature got in there also.

I am hoping to gather some seeds from a new Alma myself this year!

:)
Related Professionals
Birmingham Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Simi Valley Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Finneytown Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers · Ashburn Landscape Contractors · Bell Gardens Landscape Contractors · Concord Landscape Contractors · Costa Mesa Landscape Contractors · Deerfield Beach Landscape Contractors · Kettering Landscape Contractors · Lantana Landscape Contractors · Metairie Landscape Contractors · Roseville Landscape Contractors · Baileys Crossroads Landscape Contractors · Long Beach Roofing & Gutters · Colonia Roofing & Gutters
terrene
13 years ago
Deanna, according to Bill Cullina's book on native wildflowers, Asters are self-infertile. This means that you need at least 2 genetically different individuals that cross-pollinate with each other to get viable seed. For example, you need another cultivar of New England Aster (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae) besides Alma potschke, that blooms around the same time.

Is Alma Potschke the only New England aster that you have? If so, you won't get viable seed from your plant.
deanna in ME Barely zone 6a, more like 5b
Original Author
13 years ago
That's very helpful. Amazing how few resources ever mention that! I hope to get another Aster novi-anglae this fall, like Purple Dome, so maybe this fall I'll have some cross-pollinating happening. We have plenty of wild aster around here, but I'm sure none of them were close enough to get any pollination. In the garden, the Alma's rule the NE Aster world....but only for a little while longer!
caryltoo Z7/SE PA
13 years ago
Great info. I have a couple asters that are just blooming and was thinking of saving seeds. Now I know I can't since they're all from the same seed. And I've got no idea what variety they are, so I'm not even sure about buying another variety.