Return to the Gardening in Shade Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Growing perennials among hickory trees

Posted by weavemama 5 (My Page) on
Tue, Feb 16, 10 at 20:26

I just moved to a new place and have 18 hickory trees and 1 walnut tree in a small lot. I understand both of these trees emmit a lovely toxin that stunts growth on many plants (I wish I would have known this before I bought the place). Not to mention the amount of limbs and nuts that continously fall (if it grows... don't worry, it'll get crushed to death!). I want perennials. Aside from usual hostas and astilbes, are there more "exotic" plants that may do well in zone 5 under these types of trees? For example: helleborus, begonias, caladiums, elephant ears (I know I have to dig up the later 3 in winter). Has anyone had success in this area? Or is this a totally lost cause (which explains why NOBODY in my entire neighborhood has any plants... other than more hickory trees!!)
(Yes, I am bitter.... I left behind a 1 acre, mostly sun, completely landscaped show garden that took my husband and me 20 years to create.... I don't mind shade, it's the hickory curse which I fear)

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: Growing perennials among hickory trees

The walnut could very well cause problems but you shouldn't have much to worry about with the hickories. They DO produce juglone as well, but in concentrations far lower than that of the walnut and are generally not considered much of an issue in this regard.

A great many plants are resistant to juglone, including most perennials. It is easier to list those that are intolerant :-) Do a Google search under juglone resistant plants and see what appeals.

One of the other factors involved in underplanting these trees has nothing to do with allelopathy and juglone intolerance. And that is the difficulty in getting plants to establish in the root zones of any large trees. The larger, more aggressive root system of the trees hog all available soil moisture and nutrients and smaller plants just cannot compete. And it's hard to dig through all those roots to prepare a proper planting hole! Start small and provide the necessary TLC in the form of additional watering and even fertilizing to help get the little guys properly established.

RE: Growing perennials among hickory trees

We don't have any hickory trees, but we do have several black walnuts on the land we live on, and have had good success with juglone tolerant perennials near them. I agree with gardengal48 that you may experience more of a challenge from the roots of the trees interfering with planting and moisture more than the juglone. Growing from seed may make the landscaping process easier, rather than trying to dig holes for larger nursery container plants.

Here are some links to some lists of juglone tolerant plants. Keep in mind though that sometimes various lists will contradict one another about what is juglone tolerant and what isn't:

You may want to try to select perennials that also tolerate dry soil, depending on much the trees root systems are dominating the land you live on.

Sometimes I find it helpful to research the natural forest habitat of trees...what forest-expert types usually call the "forest alliance"...and then look for the plants that naturally grow underneath them what's known as the "understory" or "herb layer". These types of native plants will likely grow the easiest and require the least maintenance.

Not sure what kind of hickory trees you have, but if they're naturally growing in your yard, they would be one of the Caryas...possibly Carya ovata (Shagbark Hickory) or maybe Carya glabra (Pignut Hickory). Depends of course on what area of the country you're in.

Here's some info on forests with hickories in Maryland:

Look for what's listed as growing in the "herbaceous layer", "herb layer" and "shrub layer" and you may get a better idea of what will naturally grow well beneath hickories.

RE: Growing perennials among hickory trees


Native perennials will do best in such a place. Under my Hickorys are the short early and tall late Tradescantia subaspera and T. ohioensis, Claytonia virginica or Spring Beauty, Trillium cuneatum, Cimicifuga racemosa (has a new name but I forget it), Tiarella or Foamflowers, Heuchera americana, and Hymenocallis occidentalis/caroliniana or White Spider Lily. Orchids are no strangers to Hickorys but one must avoid salt and chemicals with them. Developing beneficial soil organisms will help any plant community.

These are things I have seen in clay soils and sandy loams.

Many kinds of non-native bulbs will colonize in lighter soils under these trees. Epimediums are first class and a gamble- there are so many kinds avalable these days. Some will grow in heavy clay and on limestone and can be extremely drought tolerant. Others need Azalea conditions.


RE: Growing perennials among hickory trees

I have almost the same problem, only I have 1 hickory and about 15 black walnut trees. Penn State has a great publication titled "Landscaping and Gardening around Walnuts and other Juglone Producing Plants". You can find it at

My personal experience is that most shade loving plants with the exception of azalea do very well under the walnut trees.

Good luck. Carol

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Gardening in Shade Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here