Return to the Gardening in Shade Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
What grows under pine trees?

Posted by mariesgarden 6A RI (My Page) on
Wed, Dec 4, 02 at 14:07

Need help finding plants that will survive under pine. Also what can be done with all those pine needles? These are 40' to 60' needle pine and spruce trees with most branches removed up to about 10'. There's @ least 1/2 acre of them.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

I would suggest limbing up the pine trees to 20 feet or higher and removing some of the spruces. That will give uou a lot more light and then you can grow quite a number of our native woodland plants except those that don't like xeric conditions. As for the pine needles they make an excellent mulch and don't require shredding like leaves of decidious trees.


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

Did the same thing this summer with some pecan trees that had been let go. I trimmed some lower hanging limbs (trimmed to keep the vines from climbing them) This did let in alot more light and didn't affect the afternoon shade from the tree, which was all we were getting anyway.

as for the needle...at least you're not weeding under them


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

Thanks for your thoughts. You've helped me to see that the first thing to do is trim those trees a bit higher. Marie


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

azaleas/rhododendruns/wild hydrangea/dianthus (bleeding heart?)ferns, toad lillies, all love that acidic soil.

Pine straw is terrific mulch, I agree. Also, if you're into doing a woodland pathway, you can dig the path out, and fill in with loads and loads of pinestraw for a "cottage look". The straw stays compact and lightens up over time to a golden color.


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

Regarding paths from pinestraw... You might want to make the path on flat ground. Otherwise, you may find it sliding underfoot, leading to a fall. The first time, it's not so bad, but it gets annoying...I used to live in GA and had lots of pinestraw on our beds/banks of azaleas. It was sometimes a challenge to work among them.


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

  • Posted by MorZ8 Z8 Wa coast (My Page) on
    Wed, Jan 8, 03 at 23:39

I've had problems planting under a huge ancient pine where the soil is (was) compacted clay, acid, and dries out very quickly. I've added composted manure Spring and Summer for a few seasons, and planted things that can be potentially TOO vigerous for average garden soil, and it's beginning to look pretty good! Obedient plant, iris, campanula punctata, evening primrose, epimedium, Japanese anemone, monkshood, hydrangea...these things do need some supplemental water, though. Have found some long blooming hardy geraniums that are doing great in dry shade, g. nodosum 'Svelte Lilac', white eyed and stays fresh and bright for weeks and weeks. Also self seeds, a plus in this case.


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

  • Posted by dazed81 Illinois Zone 5 (My Page) on
    Wed, May 14, 03 at 13:14

HOSTAS!!! I have two huge pines that are so OLD and I have tons of different hostas and ferns under them. I have had soil and it wasn't overturned for at least 30 years. The grass naturally was dead under there because of the needles falling and I just planted hostas. I didn't even have to ammend the soil, they just took right off. I tried an azalea and it did fine the first year but died this year, but I think that was because I was TOLD it was bred for my zone but the winter was too harsh on it. The pine needles make a great natural mulch and you harly ever see a weed. it's my favorite part of my yard. Low maintenance and all. Good luck. This picture is a couple of years old (when I first planted the hostas...) but it will give you a general idea. I have two pics...
Here's the first


And the second is the link below:

Here is a link that might be useful: Hostas under pines


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

since we have tons of pine & Live Oak here, most folks plant azaleas around the pine, then as needles fall, we just rake into the azalea "bed" continuously.


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

We have not been in N.E. Texas long and I would like to know the best way to grow a great veg. garden like Lettuce, spinish, mellons, cukes, squash, broccli, etc.etc. among the many pines on our new place in N.E. Texas.

Thanks
Donna

Here is a link that might be useful: Caddo Lake


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

We have 7 mature pines and have had very good luck with ferns, snapdragons, and cineraria 'stellata'. It's too late to plant the cineraria now but if you put out seed in the fall you will be rewarded late winter. They do reseed quite heavy and you will end up with them everywhere but, we have found if you take a hoe to the areas you don't want they are very easy to controll. The colors range from white to a deep blue-purple. They only bloom once but hold for a good 6-8 weeks. We pull out cineraria late spring and plant impatiens trim back the snaps and they give us another bloom late summer.
If you want seed let me know but i think you can get plants at anniesannuals.com
Good Luck
MG


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

  • Posted by msa5 maryland (My Page) on
    Thu, Apr 22, 04 at 12:41

I have 2 large spruce in my backyard and have planted a rather extensive shade garden under them. Ocassionally I will supplement water in the summer, and usually add compost in the late fall. The soil is on the dry side, but I keep the bed well-mulched in the summer. Their are many shallow fibrous roots but there doesn't seem to be a problem. I have many hostas, rhododendron, ferns, tiarella, solomon's seal, toad lily and even a patch of mahonia that I think makes a nice complement to the bark of the spruce. Go for it!


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

Use the needles as mulch. You don't have to worry about acidity of soil because of needles (old wife's tale). The biggest challenges are compact soil and lack of moisture (due to competiting tree roots and restricted rain due to canopy of mature trees).

I would mix a layer of compost into the top 4-6" of soil before covering with mulch (the needles are fine). Then snake a soaker hoses around your bed for watering. water 2-3 times per week by giving it a good long soaking in summer.


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

lily of the valley and english ivy


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

creeping charlie grows really well under my pine trees ;-)


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

You guys are great!!
Nearly every time I have a question, someone else asks it first!
The front of the bed where my 3 tall pines grow is filled with very healthy perennial candytuft -- but that's because the sun reaches there. The candytuft all faces outward and it abruptly stops where the sun lets off. I have a small clump of asiatic lilies growing in the midst of the candytuft and it is just blooming now. Looks great surrounded by a veritable hedge of green.
However, behind the candytuft is nothing but pine needles.
The problem is not primarily the pine needles, as someone else pointed out. It's the shade and the dry compacted soil.
I will try the compost and the soaker hoses next spring and see what happens!


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

Pine needles are great for keeping slugs away!!!


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

I planted ten violets under my huge, old spruce tree. That was two years ago. I have hundreds of violets now. The area is covered, with them. They are beautiful in the spring when they bloom and are green all summer long.

I use the pine needles under my Nikko blue hydrangea. The blue color is gorgeous.


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

Hostas, impatiens, ferns, perilla magilla, coleus, caladium. In our pure sand yard, my shade garden under the pines does better than those in the sun.


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

My pines are limbed up only 10' and it works fine. I have rhodos, azalea, hosta, pulmonaria, pieris japonica, brunera, day lilies, lamium, many different ferns, hydrangea, solomon's seal, and impatiens all doing quite well. I do water regularly.


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

Need help to find the best hedge next to pine tree. the sapace next to the pine in one side have full sun and no shade. In the other side of garden there is morning shade due to higher branch of pine tree. the lower branch up to 2 m has been removed. I am thinking of sheenas Gold or murraya? and standard roses in between. are they a good choice.


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

what about zone 4? perenial flowers and shrubs under pine trees. often they say zone 4 but don't make it. Any suggestions?


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

I planted an oakleaf hydrangea by my pine. The fall colors are striking if it gets enough sun. If not, the leaves are still interesting and its artistically compatable w/the pine. T


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

We have some very tall pines that get good morning sun. My dh installed drip irrigation under them and I have a number of roses that grew and bloomed well under them. I use pine needles for mulch too.


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

We have two 25 year old pines (Austrian pines) that provide wonderful pine needles for an acidic mulch. Now that they have got really tall, we are going to de-limb them to around 8 feet and plant some azaleas and rhodies or hydrangeas.

Ferns, hostas, daylillies, pachysandra, ribbon grass, and astilbes will all do wonderful. The biggest problem is light...take out the lower limbs and they will take off!!


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

Hellabores are wonderful under pines! Ferns are great too, especially autumn brilliance. The shorter ferns tend to get buried under the pine needles, taller ones look much better and are less maintenance. If you want to grown ivy, make it your only plant because it WILL take over. I got rid of all of mine so I could grown some other plants. Ivy also gets covered by the needles, being a ground cover.


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

I recently read that pink lady slippers actually require white pine be above them, because there is a fungus in the soil under white pines that is necessary for pink lady slippers to grow. This explains why pink lady slippers are growing in only one section of the woodlands in my backyard--the section under teh white pines. I wonder if there is anything else that actually requires white pine to be above it. I'm in NH.


 o
RE: What grows under pine trees?

I have 2 White pines, and thought nothing could grow under them. I may try Rhodedendron Maximum, but will surely have to irrigate now and then.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Gardening in Shade Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here