Return to the Square Foot Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Peat moss substitute - redwood compost?

Posted by spaghetina SF Bay Area (My Page) on
Wed, Sep 23, 09 at 20:55

I posted this over in the soil forum, but maybe it'd be better suited to those of you who are actually into SFG and who have used, or have at least thought about using Mel's Mix.

I've finally gotten my wheelbarrow, and it's time to really start looking into what kind of mix I'm going to put into my new raised beds. I'd like to stick mostly to Mel's mix, but since it seems like everyone has their own twist on the recipe, I thought I'd ask if it'd be acceptable to substitute redwood compost for the peat. I have a feeling peat is quite a bit more expensive for a yard than I'd be paying for the redwood, and I'd be able to have the redwood loaded into a truck and hauled to my house, rather than having to load up my sedan and bring home bales of peat.

I know the peat is there for moisture retention purposes, and I'm not sure whether or not the redwood compost will have the same properties, but as I've been reading about it, it does sound as though it might.

There are so many things out there marketed as "fines" and "compost" that it starts to get confusing as to which is good for what, but for reference, this is the stuff I'd be buying.

I'd be mixing it with this compost, and then some bagged vermiculite that the company has told me they carry, though I haven't seen it. Actually, I'll need to ask them what the REAL difference between their "finished" compost and their "garden" compost is because, honestly, when I saw them for the first time, they looked almost indistinguishable, and it sounds as though they're made from the exact same things.

Follow-Up Postings:

Going a different way

Ok, rather than starting a new post, I have another question to ask. As it turns out, vermiculite is crazy expensive. I thought the landscaping supply company would have it on the cheap, but no dice - $38 per 4cu ft. bag, and I'd need 5 bags of it.

So, now I'm rethinking the whole mix. I can get Napa Floor Dry for $8.99/bag delivered, but to make up the 1/3 of the mix, it'd take around 20 bags. I'm thinking of maybe 2/3 compost, 1/6 napa floor dry, and 1/6 redwood amendment, which basically looks like ground up redwood lumber.

OR 1/3 of the company's premade "essential soil mix", 1/3 compost, and 1/6 napa, and 1/6 redwood.

I'm still not sure if the redwood amendment is supposed to be moisture retentive, or provide aeration, or if it's just to change the ph of soil. Maybe it's some combination of all 3?

RE: Peat moss substitute - redwood compost?

I'd skip the Peat moss component entirely before using "composted" wood chips - especially from a rot-resistant species. I've made beds with essentially 100% "plain" compost, though I'd put in a heavy portion of leaves (from a property with a lot of oak) for their peat-like bulk when I was buying bulk compost from the local mushroom grower

Second, shop around for vermiculite (expanded shale/mica will also work if you stumble on some of that at a discount) IN the "Vermiculite sources" thread here: several people in SoCal have found it for less than $20 per 4 cu. ft. bag, and a place in WA has it for ~$30 a bag, so you are bound to be able to do better than ~$38 a bag.

RE: Peat moss substitute - redwood compost?

Hm, I thought conifer bark (and I think redwood is a conifer, isn't it?) was supposed to be good for the soil. Or if not necessarily "good", then at least ok for the soil.

I'm checking out the vermiculite thread now (thanks for the link!), and getting some ideas on other places that may carry it for cheaper. It does seem awfully expensive here compared to how much everybody else seems to be paying.

RE: Peat moss substitute - redwood compost?

I found vermiculite for around 20 bucks a bag, but since I live in Utah, Mel's foundation sells pre-mixed bags for 9-10 bucks for 2 or 3 square feet, I can't remember. I bought the pre mixed stuff and it worked great.

RE: Peat moss substitute - redwood compost?

Hi - I think the Redwood compost wouldn't be a good substitute - totally different properties. At the suggestion of one of the other threads, I used coir (which I think is coconut fiber) in one of my boxes when I ran out of peat moss and it was fine. Ended up buying it at OSH pretty cheap. (Can't remember the exact cost, but I think $7 for a big bag.)

If you want to drive yourself crazy, there are probably 100+threads across GW that go into much greater depth (too much - and some unpleasant!) about peat, peat substitutes, coir, etc.

RE: Peat moss substitute - redwood compost?

I've read through a lot of them re: peat subs, but I thought coir was really hard to get soaked well, and then to break up once soaked. Since I'll be working with around 3cu. yards of stuff, and I'll be mixing it all by hand, anything that's too tough or time consuming is going to be a big, big headache, lol.

RE: Peat moss substitute - redwood compost?

Hey you guys.. I have a bed with vermiculite in it, but I found out that vermiculite can contain asbestos, so you might want to think about using pearlite instead.

I just googled "asbestos vermiculite" and a lot of articles came up. You can read them for yourself.

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Square Foot Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here