Return to the Growing Tomatoes Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Steven Virgadamo determinate indeterminate

Posted by StevenVirgadamo none (My Page) on
Thu, May 1, 14 at 6:44

Steve Virgadamo looking for help in picking plants. What is the dideerence , growing requirements etc for determinate or indeterminate plants?

Thank you

Steve Virgadamo


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Steven Virgadamo determinate indeterminate

There is none, really. With the Indets you will need a good support system ( tall, wide cage or stakes ..) Most Dets are easier to manage, in terms of caging and staking. They both need the same growing conditions and care, otherwise.

In short, Det and Indet refers to certain growing habit in size and , to some extent, fruiting.


 o
RE: Steven Virgadamo determinate indeterminate

Here you go.

Dave

Here is a link that might be useful: What is the difference between determinate and indeterminate tomatoes


 o
RE: Steven Virgadamo determinate indeterminate

In that link above, a short paragraph reads as follows:

""They(DETS) stop growing when fruit sets on the terminal or top bud, ripen all their crop at or near the same time (usually over a 2 week period), and then die. """

As far as I know that statement is incorrect. Determinats, some (if not most) live through the end of season and continue fruiting, maybe not as regularly as Indets.


 o
RE: Steven Virgadamo determinate indeterminate

seysonn, when you start your own site, you can have FAQ which say anything you want them to.

Just think of the time you'll save in not needing to contradict GW's FAQ all the time.


 o
RE: Steven Virgadamo determinate indeterminate

The statement in the FAQ is correct. It is a broad general statement about the differences between the two types and is well supported by documented research and decades of experience. FAQs by nature are broad general guides not meticulous discussions of all possible variables..

So taking statements out of context just to dispute it only contributes confusion, not information. It is nitpicking.

Determinants, by their nature, set terminal buds on the ends of their branches. That means the branch terminates. It does not continue to grow much less produce. Once the plant sets its last terminal bud the plant begins to slowly die. Since most of the terminal buds will set fruit within a specific period of time they will all ripen within a similar specific period of time. What that time frame is has many variables but in general it ranges from 2-4 weeks.

Whether they live until the "end of the season" all depends on how long your season is. Whether they develop a few new lateral branches later on that may or may not produce fruits depends on many different factors. But in general they don't.

Are there exceptions that happen? Of course but exceptions do not make a general guideline "incorrect".

Dave


 o
RE: Steven Virgadamo determinate indeterminate

So taking statements out of context just to dispute it only contributes confusion, not information. It is nitpicking. (Dave)

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
Give me a break bro. Here comes the defense team.

I quoted the statement word by work. It says in plain clear English and it does not need anybody's INTERPRETATION.
here it is , once again:

""They(DETS) stop growing when fruit sets on the terminal or top bud, ripen all their crop at or near the same time (usually over a 2 week period), and then die. """

That is plain inaccurate. Tomato is perenial. It won't die, unless harsh cold (Or heat) unfavorable growing conditions kills it.


 o
RE: Steven Virgadamo determinate indeterminate

Hi, I'm Carolyn, and a friend just came to visit and, well, I've just asked her to bind my fingers together so I can't post on this issue at hand any more than what I just posted.

Carolyn, who coordinated the writing of three of the FAQ's here, but not the indet vs det one. The three were How To Start From Seed, How to Prevent Cross Pollination and different Foliage types, which she wrote pretty much herself, so she knows a bit about FAQ's and how they can be sometimes confusing, as she thinks the indet vs det one is, but that one was here when I joined GW way back in 2000 and if you look at her page here it says 2002 but that's b'c there was a computer malfunction so they had to readjust all those times, and posting this so that "someone" might say you lied Carolyn, you joined in 2002 and not 2000. (smile).


 o
RE: Steven Virgadamo determinate indeterminate

INdeterminate tomato varieties are perennials but only under the right circumstances/conditions. And those conditions do not exist in the continental US except for the tropical regions of the deep south.

Determinate variety tomatoes are NOT perennials and never have been. They are annuals at best. Even under the ideal growing conditions they will die. They are genetically terminal, set terminal buds, have a genetically terminated lifespan, are genetically "determined" to die, to terminate. See the pattern? Which is part of why they have that label - Determinants.

If they shed fruit on the ground they may re-seed themselves but that doesn't make them perennials.

Geeze - just look it up anywhere. It has been common knowledge among tomato growers for as long as they have existed.

Dave


 o
RE: Steven Virgadamo determinate indeterminate

Sorry Carolyn your post wasn't there when I was writing. You are more restrained than I. (pun intended) :)

Dave


 o
RE: Steven Virgadamo determinate indeterminate

Steven - have you got some varieties in mind? Have you been looking at seedlings in nurseries or big box stores? If you tell us the names, or if you tell us what you're looking for as far as fruit size, maturity, height of the plant, how much room you have to plant in ground or if you're growing in containers, etc. we can help.


 o
RE: Steven Virgadamo determinate indeterminate

Nice deflection! Yes Steve, give us an idea of what your space is and growing season, condition, etc.
Sharon


 o
RE: Steven Virgadamo determinate indeterminate

Just trying to get back on topic - his plant out date is coming up and he has to get plants - esp. if he has to harden them off himself.

(Title may be asking det. vs indet. but he said he needed help picking plants)


 o
RE: Steven Virgadamo determinate indeterminate

Thank you. I got an answer and seem to have stirred up a bit of banter.

Steven Virgafamo


 o
RE: Steven Virgadamo determinate indeterminate

So what are you going for?


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Growing Tomatoes Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here