Return to the Growing Tomatoes Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Brown Cow :-(

Posted by rt_peasant 5 CO (My Page) on
Wed, Aug 13, 14 at 0:54

I'm growing Cowlick's Brandywine for the first time this year. It was my first slicer to ripen (78 days), tasted great, and set a bunch of nice sized tomatoes, ~30 greenies total. So you know how sad I was to find that the plant's leaves are now covered with brown spots. The same thing happened to two of my plants last year. Does this look like a common disease? The symptoms are:

* affected the top-most and outer-most leaves
* the leaves develop tiny brown spots, which grow in size, eventually joining and turning into big spots
* the leaves did not turn yellow. They went straight from green to covered with brown spots
* I don't know if it's coincidence, but the last 2 ripe tomatoes did not ripen evenly. They developed a streaked, splotchy appearance. The first ripe tomato (before the brown spots appeared) ripened evenly.

I cut all the affected leaves on Saturday. The next day, I went out, and found twice as many affected leaves. I cut those out, too. By Monday, I didn't see any more spots on the leaves, so the spread of the disease seems to have slowed. I'm contemplating pulling the plant before the disease spreads to its neighbors, but I'd like to milk a few more "Cows" out of this plant before ripping it out!

Diseased leaves
 photo 14743254-9e8e-4571-8ff5-6ad13406220d.jpg

 photo 20140809_120647.jpg

Another close-up
 photo 20140809_120605.jpg

Tiny brown spots
 photo 20140809_120557.jpg

Splotchy, streaked ripe tomato
 photo streakedtom.jpg

I'll be sad to toss the plant before these babies have a chance to ripen!
 photo fatcows.jpg


Follow-Up Postings:

RE: Brown Cow :-(

I'm having a similar experience with Aunt Gerties Gold. I doubt I'll get five fruit off of it. But I had similar issues last year, so I think it's off my list for good. I'm also debating about cutting it down. It could be septoria. I have a BW OTV next to it that is ok so it's hard to say. Good luck!

RE: Brown Cow :-(

My local cooperative extension office suggested that it might be early blight, but it doesn't look like early blight to me. For one thing, there's no yellowing of the leaves, as in this picture of early blight (taken from CSU's plant talk website):
 photo earlyblight.jpg

My leaves almost look like they have brown mold on them initially, before the spots spread and the entire leaf turns brown.

Another thing is the brown spots affect the top-most and outer-most leaves. In my experience with early blight, it affects the bottom, interior leaves first and moves its way up the plant, which is the opposite of what I'm seeing on my plant.

One final note, the fruit ripen with a streaked, orange appearance, and they have an off-flavor, like they're rotting on the vines. So that pretty much decides the fate of this plant.

I'd love to know what disease this was, if you have any ideas. I looked on several tomato disease websites, and didn't find anything to match my symptoms.

RE: Brown Cow :-(

I'll get back to you on this but not today, just no time today.


RE: Brown Cow :-(

Can't help with what the prob is, and hope it'll hold on long enough for those greenies to ripen, but if they don't it's time for you to make some fried green tomatoes. They're fabulous.

Rosie, Sugar Hill, GA

RE: Brown Cow :-(

In one picture I can see the ring structures inside one spot and that says Early Blight to me and note the yellow area around it.

There certainly can be other foliage infections as well, please consider Bacterial Spot or Speck that you show, they are best seen on green leaves and seldom show yellow areas, but I can speak only to the early blight now.

All new foliage infections are spread by wind and rain and show up on the upper leaves.

When such infections show up first on the lower foliage it means that plants that were infected the previous year,or so, shed the spores and bacteria to the ground and what then happens is called splashback reinfection with those spores, etc, splashing back up on the lower foliage due to rain or irrigation and then the infections moving upward on the plants,

Blotchy ripening is a well known condition and I'll link to it below.


Here is a link that might be useful: blotchy ripening

RE: Brown Cow :-(

To avoid that splashing back, this year I used 2 types of mulch: fabric and straw.

Until now, no problems.

Both mulches are good. Straw might be difficult to find. Fabric allows LESS water to go through, so it’s a better for controlling water coming from the rain. Wind might blow the straw so I put on the straw, wire / mesh fence with metal stakes. The 4 in. staples I used for the fabric mulch, do not work for straw - they are too short. Even 6 in. staples might not work, because when you step on the wire / mesh, some staples - being too short - might come out. The metal stakes are 8 in. long and are ok.

RE: Brown Cow :-(

Thanks, Carolyn. I appreciate the feedback. So that I can learn from you, I'm curious in which picture you see ring structures in one spot. Is it in the picture labeled "Another close-up", with the spot in question being just left of center in the picture?

I went out this weekend and removed the affected plant from the garden. I didn't notice it before, but the stem had black streaks running down it. And the ripening fruit tasted spoiled.

Almost all of my tomatoes have some amount of early blight this year, or at least what I assume is early blight because it looks just the like the early blight picture from CSU. The tomatoes on those plants taste fine. I just keep cutting off the leaves with blight, and hope that the plants can outgrow the disease. For the most part, it's the lower leaves that are affected, so it sounds like I have some splashback issues to deal with.

RE: Brown Cow :-(

Many people here are having all kinds of problems with their tomatoes, myself included.

The leaves are dying on entire stems while others on the same vine are ok.

The biggest problem (and it does not matter the verity) the tomatoes are rotting if they are touching anything. They rot before ripping if they are touching each other, Stem/stock, steak (wood or metal), leaf or another plant. But if you catch it in time and strip everything away from them to where they are not touching anything. They ripen and do good.

No one here can figure it out and no one has found a cure.

RE: Brown Cow :-(

hippy wrote:

> They rot before ripping if they are touching each other.

Mine are ok, if they touch each other.

They might not be ok, if a prune a diseased plant, and than I prune a healthy plant WITHOUT disinfecting the pruning snip.

RE: Brown Cow :-(

It is not that they are only rotting if they touch each other. They are rotting if they touch anything. A Tomato will rot if even part of a leaf on the same stem touches it. I did an experiment by ting a piece of thin cotton string loosely around a single tomato and in two days it turned black and rotted all the way round it just where the string was touching.

The only way to save them is to prune everything away from a single tomato and let that single one ripen.

Out of close to 100 plants. I have not gotten a bushel of ripe tomatoes. And I am not in the boat alone. Nearly everyone's are doing the same thing within a 5 to 10 mile radius of me.

RE: Brown Cow :-(

Brown Cow, I was looking at the picture of what was Early Blight but failed to notice that it wasn't from your garden at all.

Sorry about that.


RE: Brown Cow :-(

hippy, can we see some pictures please ?

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Growing Tomatoes Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here